文献速递慢病管理老年与多病共存

移动技术支持目标导向照护:ePRO工具混合方法试验发现

Supporting goal-oriented care using mobile technology: Findings from the mixed-methods trial of the ePRO tool.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Fam Med · 2022-04-01

本研究在安大略省6个初级保健机构中,采用阶梯楔形设计的多方法实用随机对照试验和民族志案例研究,评估电子患者报告结局(ePRO)移动应用与门户系统在老年复杂照护需求患者中实施目标导向照护的效果。由于招募困难,仅45名患者参与,ePRO对生活质量的影响无法确定评估;民族志数据显示实施过程复杂,技术对个体生活、关系和慢病管理方式的意义驱动了采用和感知价值。

要点

  • ePRO工具在跨专业初级保健中实施面临广泛且出乎意料的挑战。
  • 因招募困难,ePRO对生活质量的影响无法确定评估。
  • 技术对个体生活与关系的意义是采用和感知价值的关键驱动因素。

核心结论

  • ePRO工具的实施挑战广泛且大多出乎意料,技术对个体生活、关系和慢病管理方式的意义驱动了采用和感知价值。
  • 由于招募困难导致样本量不足,ePRO对生活质量的影响无法确定评估,分析趋势提示对照组和干预组患者的生活质量均下降。

研究设计与样本

  • 多方法实用随机对照试验,采用阶梯楔形设计,辅以民族志案例研究,为期15个月。
  • 研究在加拿大安大略省6个综合性初级保健机构开展,目标样本为176名有复杂照护需求的老年人。
  • 6个机构随机分为早期组(3个月对照;12个月干预)或晚期组(6个月对照;9个月干预)。
  • 结局指标为基线及每3个月收集的Assessment of Quality of Life-4D,采用线性模型分析;民族志数据在干预中期和结束时收集,采用定性描述和框架分析法,以Normalization Process Theory为指导。

主要发现

  • 试验遭遇招募困难,实际机构数(n=6)和参与者数(n=45)均少于预期。
  • ePRO对生活质量的影响无法确定评估;分析趋势提示对照组和干预组患者的生活质量均下降。
  • 民族志数据揭示实施过程复杂,技术对个体生活、关系和慢病管理方式的意义(或一致性)驱动了采用和感知价值或无关性。

临床怎么用

  • 在跨专业初级保健中实施数字健康工具时,需关注技术对患者个体生活、关系和慢病管理方式的意义,以促进采用和感知价值。
  • 复杂干预在不同用户群体间长期对齐意义存在困难,提示干预可能适应性不足,或需要更动态的试验方法。

局限性

  • 招募困难导致机构和参与者数量少于预期,样本量不足,无法确定评估ePRO对生活质量的影响。
  • 实施挑战广泛且大多出乎意料,可能影响研究结果的推广。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Context: Goal-oriented models of care are becoming more widely used as part of primary care delivery for older adults with multimorbidity and complex care needs. While these models hold promise, implementation remains challenging. Digital health solutions may improve adoption however, they require evaluation to determine feasibility and impact. Objective: This study evaluates the implementation and effectiveness of the electronic Patient Reported Outcome (ePRO) mobile application and portal system, designed to enable goal-oriented care delivery in inter-professional primary care practices. Study design: Multi-method pragmatic randomized control trial using a stepped-wedge design and ethnographic case studies over a 15-month period. Setting: 6 comprehensive primary care practices across Ontario. Population studied: Older adults with complex care needs; target sample 176 patients. Intervention: Patient and provider participants used the ePRO tool in addition to usual care. The 6 practices randomized into either early (3-month control; 12-month intervention) or late (6-month control; 9-month intervention) groups. Outcome measures: The Assessment of Quality of Life-4D collected at baseline and 3-month intervals. Ethnographic data (observations and interviews) collected at mid-point and end of the intervention. Outcome data were analyzed using linear models. Ethnographic data was analyzed using qualitative description and framework analysis methods, guided by Normalization Process Theory. Results: The trial experienced recruitment challenges resulting in fewer sites (n=6) and participants (n=45) than expected. As such the impact of ePRO on quality of life could not be definitively assessed; analysis trends suggest decreased quality of life for patients over both the control and intervention periods. Ethnographic data reveals a complex implementation process, in which the meaningfulness (or coherence) of the technology to individuals lives, relationships and approach chronic disease management drove adoption and perceived value or irrelevance of ePRO. Conclusions: Implementation challenges were broad and largely unexpected. The difficultly in aligning meaningfulness of a complex intervention across diverse user groups over time, suggests the intervention may not be sufficiently adaptable, or that more dynamic trial methods may be required. Including ethnographic data collection reveals critical underlying mechanisms driving digital health innovations.

来源:Ann Fam Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Steele Gray C, Nie J, Loganathan M, et al. Supporting goal-oriented care using mobile technology: Findings from the mixed-methods trial of the ePRO tool. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 38270909. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.2763

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。