血压检查诊断高血压:卫生专业人员的知识、信念与实践
结果显示,虽然多数人认为手动听诊血压和动态血压监测准确,但实际诊断几乎都依赖诊室血压,且对家庭血压和动态血压监测的指南一致性阈值(135/85 mmHg)使用率很低(分别为14.0%和8.4%)。作者认为这些知识、信念与实践差距可能导致诊疗与指南不一致,需要通过系统变革和干预来改善高血压诊断。
要点
- 多数受访者认为手动听诊血压(78.6%)和动态血压监测(84.2%)非常或高度准确。
- 95.7%的受访者诊断时总是或几乎总是依赖诊室血压测量。
- 仅14.0%的医生/助理/高级执业注册护士使用家庭血压监测的指南一致性阈值135/85 mmHg。
核心结论
- 卫生专业人员在诊断高血压的知识、信念和实践上存在差距,可能导致诊疗与指南不一致,需系统变革和干预以改善诊断和结局。
主要发现
- 约三分之二受邀者回应(163名医疗助理/执业护士/注册护士,86名医生,33名医生助理/高级执业注册护士)。
- 多数受访者认为手动听诊血压(78.6%)或动态血压监测(84.2%)非常或高度准确,而多数不认为自动化诊室血压、家庭血压或自助机血压非常或高度准确。
- 几乎所有受访者(95.7%)报告诊断时总是或几乎总是依赖诊室血压测量,但多数医生/助理/高级执业注册护士(60.5%)若动态血压监测可及则更倾向使用。
- 极少数医生/助理/高级执业注册护士使用家庭血压监测(14.0%)或动态血压监测(8.4%)的指南一致性诊断阈值135/85 mmHg;家庭血压(59.4%)和动态血压监测(49.6%)最常报告的阈值是140/90 mmHg。
关键数值与推荐
- 美国预防服务工作组建议在作出新高血压诊断和开始治疗前,使用24小时动态血压监测或家庭血压监测进行诊室外血压测量。
临床怎么用
- 基层医生应提高对诊室外血压测量(家庭或动态血压监测)在高血压诊断中作用的认识,并采用指南一致性阈值135/85 mmHg。
- 系统层面可增加动态血压监测的可及性,因为多数有诊断权的受访者若可及则更倾向使用动态血压监测。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The US Preventive Services Task Force recommends out-of-office blood pressure (BP) measurement before making a new hypertension diagnosis and initiating treatment, using 24-hour ambulatory (ABPM) or home BP monitoring. However, this approach is not common. METHODS: e-mail-linked surveys were sent to primary care team members (n = 421) from 10 clinics. The sample included medical assistants, licensed practical nurses, registered nurses, and advanced practice registered nurses (LPN/RN/APRNs), physician assistants (PAs), and physicians. Those licensed to diagnosis hypertension (physician/PA/APRNs) received additional questions. Data were collected from November 2017 to July 2019. RESULTS: 2-thirds of invitees responded (163 MA/LPN/RNs, 86 physicians, and 33 PA/APRNs). When making a new hypertension diagnosis, most respondents believed that BP measured manually with a stethoscope (78.6%) or ABPM (84.2%) were very or highly accurate. In contrast, most did not believe that automated clinic BPs, home BP, or kiosk BP measurements were very or highly accurate. Almost all reported always or almost always relying on clinic BP measurements in making a diagnosis (95.7%), but most physician/PA/APRNs (60.5%) would prefer ABPM if it was readily available. Very few physician/PA/APRNs used the guideline-concordant diagnostic threshold (135/85 mmHg) with home monitoring (14.0%) or ABPM (8.4%), with 140/90 mmHg the most commonly reported threshold for home (59.4%) and ABPM (49.6%). DISCUSSION: Our study found health care professional knowledge, beliefs, and practices gaps in diagnosing hypertension. These gaps could lead to clinical care that is not aligned with guidelines. CONCLUSION: System changes and interventions to increase use of evidence-based practices could improve hypertension diagnosis and outcomes.
引用
- Green BB, Anderson ML, Ehrlich K, et al. Blood Pressure Checks for Diagnosing Hypertension: Health Professionals' Knowledge, Beliefs, and Practices. J Am Board Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 35379718. doi:10.3122/jabfm.2022.02.210318
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。