文献速递耳科与耳神经

Cogmed训练未泛化至成人助听器使用者的真实世界获益:盲法主动对照随机试验结果

Cogmed Training Does Not Generalize to Real-World Benefits for Adult Hearing Aid Users: Results of a Blinded, Active-Controlled Randomized Trial.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2022-01-01

该 preregistered 随机对照试验纳入57名轻中度听力损失成人助听器使用者,比较5周自适应Cogmed RM训练与非自适应主动对照。结果显示训练任务及训练外工作记忆任务(倒背数字)有改善,自我报告听力能力小幅改善,但未泛化至未训练认知、噪声下言语感知或日常听力。

要点

  • Cogmed训练仅改善训练相关任务及倒背数字,未泛化至噪声下言语感知。
  • 自我报告听力能力仅小幅改善,日常沟通获益证据不足。
  • 基线工作记忆较好者训练任务学习获益更大。

核心结论

  • 以工作记忆存储成分为主的Cogmed训练未产生域一般性改善以惠及成人助听器使用者的日常沟通。

研究设计与样本

  • preregistered 随机对照试验,57名轻中度听力损失成人助听器使用者(实验组27例,主动对照组30例),参与者与结局评估者双盲,6个月随访。

主要发现

  • 符合方案分析显示训练任务(Cogmed Index Improvement)改善,并转移至训练外工作记忆任务(倒背数字)及自我报告听力能力小幅改善(格拉斯哥助听器获益量表初始残疾子量表)。
  • 上述改善在训练后6个月维持。
  • 未观察到向未训练认知(工作记忆或注意力)、噪声下言语感知或日常自我报告听力的转移。
  • 基线工作记忆表现更好者训练任务学习获益更大;未训练结局的训练后表现主要由训练前表现预测。

关键数值与推荐

  • 训练任务改善:Cogmed Index Improvement;训练外工作记忆:倒背数字;自我报告听力:格拉斯哥助听器获益量表初始残疾子量表。

临床怎么用

  • 不应期望以存储成分为主的Cogmed训练改善成人助听器使用者的噪声下言语感知或日常沟通。
  • 若关注认知训练,未来应探索针对认知控制动态成分、嵌入日常沟通情境的干预。

局限性

  • 样本量57例,结果基于符合方案分析;主动对照组为非自适应Cogmed RM。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Performance on working memory tasks is positively associated with speech-in-noise perception performance, particularly where auditory inputs are degraded. It is suggested that interventions designed to improve working memory capacity may improve domain-general working memory performance for people with hearing loss, to benefit their real-world listening. We examined whether a 5-week training program that primarily targets the storage component of working memory (Cogmed RM, adaptive) could improve cognition, speech-in-noise perception and self-reported hearing in a randomized controlled trial of adult hearing aid users with mild to moderate hearing loss, compared with an active control (Cogmed RM, nonadaptive) group of adults from the same population. DESIGN: A preregistered randomized controlled trial of 57 adult hearing aid users (n = 27 experimental, n = 30 active control), recruited from a dedicated database of research volunteers, examined on-task learning and generalized improvements in measures of trained and untrained cognition, untrained speech-in-noise perception and self-reported hearing abilities, pre- to post-training. Participants and the outcome assessor were both blinded to intervention allocation. Retention of training-related improvements was examined at a 6-month follow-up assessment. RESULTS: Per-protocol analyses showed improvements in trained tasks (Cogmed Index Improvement) that transferred to improvements in a trained working memory task tested outside of the training software (Backward Digit Span) and a small improvement in self-reported hearing ability (Glasgow Hearing Aid Benefit Profile, Initial Disability subscale). Both of these improvements were maintained 6-month post-training. There was no transfer of learning shown to untrained measures of cognition (working memory or attention), speech-in-noise perception, or self-reported hearing in everyday life. An assessment of individual differences showed that participants with better baseline working memory performance achieved greater learning on the trained tasks. Post-training performance for untrained outcomes was largely predicted by individuals' pretraining performance on those measures. CONCLUSIONS: Despite significant on-task learning, generalized improvements of working memory training in this trial were limited to (a) improvements for a trained working memory task tested outside of the training software and (b) a small improvement in self-reported hearing ability for those in the experimental group, compared with active controls. We found no evidence to suggest that training which primarily targets storage aspects of working memory can result in domain-general improvements that benefit everyday communication for adult hearing aid users. These findings are consistent with a significant body of evidence showing that Cogmed training only improves performance for tasks that resemble Cogmed training. Future research should focus on the benefits of interventions that enhance cognition in the context in which it is employed within everyday communication, such as training that targets dynamic aspects of cognitive control important for successful speech-in-noise perception.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Henshaw H, Heinrich A, Tittle A, et al. Cogmed Training Does Not Generalize to Real-World Benefits for Adult Hearing Aid Users: Results of a Blinded, Active-Controlled Randomized Trial. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 34524150. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001096

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。