文献速递耳科与耳神经小儿耳鼻咽喉

重度听力损失儿童助听器与人工耳蜗效果比较的范围综述

A Scoping Review of Studies Comparing Outcomes for Children With Severe Hearing Loss Using Hearing Aids to Children With Cochlear Implants.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2022-01-01

言语语言发展和言语感知最常被评估,但生活质量、教育成就、复杂聆听和语言结果等证据稀疏。临床医生在为残余听力较多的儿童做管理决策时需了解这一有限证据基础。

要点

  • 言语语言发展和言语感知是重度听力损失儿童助听器与人工耳蜗比较中最常评估的结果。
  • 仅有2项研究比较读写能力,2项比较声源定位,1项比较生活质量,1项比较心理社会结果。
  • 无研究比较教育成就、聆听疲劳、平衡、耳鸣或音乐感知。

核心结论

  • 该范围综述总结了重度听力损失儿童使用助听器与人工耳蜗的比较结果文献,并指出生活质量、教育成就及复杂聆听和语言结果等知识缺口。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用范围综述方法,遵循Joanna Briggs研究所建议的研究选择、数据提取和数据呈现方法。
  • 纳入比较助听器组与人工耳蜗组儿童的研究,以及重度听力损失儿童植入前后自身对照的重复测量研究。

主要发现

  • 多数研究儿童为先天性或语前听力损失,认知功能典型,有口语经验,多数植入儿童使用单侧人工耳蜗。
  • 言语语言发展和言语感知是最常评估的结果,但声音、沟通和语用技能以及复杂背景噪声下的言语感知等 aspects 代表不足。
  • 2项研究比较读写能力,2项比较声源定位,1项比较生活质量,1项比较心理社会结果。
  • 无研究比较教育成就、聆听疲劳、平衡、耳鸣或音乐感知。

临床怎么用

  • 临床医生在为残余听力多于传统植入候选者的儿童做管理决策时,应意识到比较证据基础稀疏。

局限性

  • 证据基础在生活质量、教育成就以及复杂聆听和语言结果等方面存在明显缺口。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Clinical practice regarding children's candidature for cochlear implantation varies internationally, albeit with a recent global trend toward implanting children with more residual hearing than in the past. The provision of either hearing aids or cochlear implants can influence a wide range of children's outcomes. However, guidance on eligibility and suitability for implantation is often based on a small number of studies and a limited range of speech perception measures. No recent reviews have catalogued what is known about comparative outcomes for children with severe hearing-loss using hearing aids to children using cochlear implants. This article describes the findings of a scoping review that addressed the question "What research has been conducted comparing cochlear implant outcomes to outcomes in children using hearing aids with severe hearing-loss in the better-hearing ear?" The first objective was to catalogue the characteristics of studies pertinent to these children's candidature for cochlear implantation, to inform families, clinicians, researchers, and policy-makers. The second objective was to identify gaps in the evidence base, to inform future research projects and identify opportunities for evidence synthesis. DESIGN: We included studies comparing separate groups of children using hearing aids to those using cochlear implants and also repeated measures studies comparing outcomes of children with severe hearing loss before and after cochlear implantation. We included any outcomes that might feasibly be influenced by the provision of hearing aids or cochlear implants. We searched the electronic databases Medline, PubMed, and CINAHL, for peer-reviewed journal articles with full-texts written in English, published from July 2007 to October 2019. The scoping methodology followed the approach recommended by the Joanna Briggs Institute regarding study selection, data extraction, and data presentation. RESULTS: Twenty-one eligible studies were identified, conducted across 11 countries. The majority of children studied had either congenital or prelingual hearing loss, with typical cognitive function, experience of spoken language, and most implanted children used one implant. Speech and language development and speech perception were the most frequently assessed outcomes. However, some aspects of these outcomes were sparsely represented including voice, communication and pragmatic skills, and speech perception in complex background noise. Two studies compared literacy, two sound localization, one quality of life, and one psychosocial outcomes. None compared educational attainment, listening fatigue, balance, tinnitus, or music perception. CONCLUSIONS: This scoping review provides a summary of the literature regarding comparative outcomes of children with severe hearing-loss using acoustic hearing aids and children using cochlear implants. Notable gaps in knowledge that could be addressed in future research includes children's quality of life, educational attainment, and complex listening and language outcomes, such as word and sentence understanding in background noise, spatial listening, communication and pragmatic skills. Clinician awareness of this sparse evidence base is important when making management decisions for children with more residual hearing than traditional implant candidates. This review also provides direction for researchers wishing to strengthen the evidence base upon which clinical decisions can be made.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Killan CF, Hoare DJ, Katiri R, et al. A Scoping Review of Studies Comparing Outcomes for Children With Severe Hearing Loss Using Hearing Aids to Children With Cochlear Implants. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 34347660. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001104

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。