计算机听觉与唇读训练提升听障儿童言语识别:一项随机对照试验
结果显示儿童听力和唇读表现均显著改善,对训练者语音的识别提升大于未训练者,听觉训练组听力提升更明显,视听训练组两种评估提升相当。
要点
- 结构化言语感知训练可显著改善听障儿童的听力和唇读表现。
- 训练效果对训练者语音优于未训练者,并可泛化至其他说话者。
- 训练获益与年龄、语言水平及语音意识程度无显著相关。
核心结论
- 计算机化言语感知训练可提升听障儿童的言语识别能力,且效果可泛化至未训练说话者。
主要发现
- 儿童听力和唇读表现均显著改善。
- 对训练者语音的识别提升大于未训练者。
- 听觉训练组听力提升大于唇读,视听训练组两种评估提升相当。
- 年龄、语言水平和语音意识对训练获益无预测作用或仅可忽略。
临床怎么用
- 可为听障儿童提供结构化言语感知训练。
- 未来听觉康复项目可考虑加入针对特定教师的言语感知训练,以帮助儿童适应新学年。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Transfer appropriate processing (TAP) refers to a general finding that training gains are maximized when training and testing are conducted under the same conditions. The present study tested the extent to which TAP applies to speech perception training in children with hearing loss. Specifically, we assessed the benefits of computer-based speech perception training games for enhancing children's speech recognition by comparing three training groups: auditory training (AT), audiovisual training (AVT), and a combination of these two (AT/AVT). We also determined whether talker-specific training, as might occur when children train with the speech of a next year's classroom teacher, leads to better recognition of that talker's speech and if so, the extent to which training benefits generalize to untrained talkers. Consistent with TAP theory, we predicted that children would improve their ability to recognize the speech of the trained talker more than that of three untrained talkers and, depending on their training group, would improve more on an auditory-only (listening) or audiovisual (speechreading) speech perception assessment, that matched the type of training they received. We also hypothesized that benefit would generalize to untrained talkers and to test modalities in which they did not train, albeit to a lesser extent. DESIGN: Ninety-nine elementary school aged children with hearing loss were enrolled into a randomized control trial with a repeated measures A-A-B experimental mixed design in which children served as their own control for the assessment of overall benefit of a particular training type and three different groups of children yielded data for comparing the three types of training. We also assessed talker-specific learning and transfer of learning by including speech perception tests with stimuli spoken by the talker with whom a child trained and stimuli spoken by three talkers with whom the child did not train and by including speech perception tests that presented both auditory (listening) and audiovisual (speechreading) stimuli. Children received 16 hr of gamified training. The games provided word identification and connected speech comprehension training activities. RESULTS: Overall, children showed significant improvement in both their listening and speechreading performance. Consistent with TAP theory, children improved more on their trained talker than on the untrained talkers. Also consistent with TAP theory, the children who received AT improved more on the listening than the speechreading. However, children who received AVT improved on both types of assessment equally, which is not consistent with our predictions derived from a TAP perspective. Age, language level, and phonological awareness were either not predictive of training benefits or only negligibly so. CONCLUSIONS: The findings provide support for the practice of providing children who have hearing loss with structured speech perception training and suggest that future aural rehabilitation programs might include teacher-specific speech perception training to prepare children for an upcoming school year, especially since training will generalize to other talkers. The results also suggest that benefits of speech perception training were not significantly related to age, language level, or degree of phonological awareness. The findings are largely consistent with TAP theory, suggesting that the more aligned a training task is with the desired outcome, the more likely benefit will accrue.
引用
- Tye-Murray N, Spehar B, Sommers M, et al. Teaching Children With Hearing Loss to Recognize Speech: Gains Made With Computer-Based Auditory and/or Speechreading Training. Ear Hear. 2022. PMID: 34225318. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001091
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。