声带沟与声带瘢痕外科治疗的系统综述
该系统综述纳入31项研究共617例患者,评估声带沟与瘢痕的各类外科技术,并将术式分为直接、间接与联合三类。分析未发现任一技术具有优越性,自报结局改善最常被报道;作者提出序贯策略趋势,即从创伤较小的术式开始。
要点
- 声带沟与瘢痕的外科术式可分为直接、间接与联合三类。
- 系统综述未发现任一术式在结局上具有优越性。
- 自报结局是报道中最常改善的结局类型。
核心结论
- 声带沟与声带瘢痕可能不存在一种万能术式,也缺乏明确的决策模式。
- 近期可观察到序贯治疗的趋势,即从创伤较小的术式开始。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE与Google Scholar至2020年8月。
- 共纳入31项研究、617例患者。
- 采用MINORs标准评估方法学质量,结局分为声学、空气动力学、自报、感知与频闪喉镜五类。
主要发现
- 直接技术包括剥离、移植物插入或固有层再生/瘢痕降解,间接技术旨在闭合声门裂隙。
- 仅1篇文章对不同类型技术进行了比较,仅8项研究涵盖五类结局。
- 分析未发现任一技术具有优越性;自报结局是最常改善的结局。
关键数值与推荐
- 术式分类:直接、间接或联合。
- 结局分类:声学、空气动力学、自报、感知与频闪喉镜。
- 方法学质量评估采用MINORs标准。
临床怎么用
- 术式选择需个体化,不宜期望单一术式适用于所有声带沟与瘢痕病例。
- 可考虑序贯策略,从创伤较小的术式开始。
- 评估疗效时应涵盖声学、空气动力学、自报、感知与频闪喉镜等多维结局。
局限性
- 仅1项研究比较了不同术式,术式间比较证据有限。
- 仅8项研究涵盖全部五类结局,结局报告不完整。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Vocal fold sulcus and scars are benign vocal fold lesions that present as a challenge to the laryngologist. A number of different surgical techniques have been proposed, aiming at restoring the lamina propria (LP), closing the glottal gap, or both. This study aimed to provide a systematic review of surgical treatment for sulcus and scar and to propose a new classification for these techniques. STUDY DESIGN: A literature search using MEDLINE and Google Scholar through August 2020. METHODS: Data on study design were retrieved and outcomes were classified as acoustic, aerodynamic, self-reported, perceptual, and stroboscopic. Methodological quality was assessed using the MINORs criteria. Each technique was classified as direct, indirect, or combined. RESULTS: Our search included 31 studies with a total of 617 patients. Direct techniques included dissection, graft interposition, or LP regeneration/scar degradation while indirect techniques aimed for glottal gap closure. Only one article performed a comparison between different types of techniques and only eight studied the five types of outcomes. No superiority of any technique was noted in our analysis. Self-reported outcomes were the most frequently improved. CONCLUSIONS: There seems to not exist a one-fits-all treatment for this clinical picture and no clear decision-making pattern. A recent trend toward sequential approaches, starting with less invasive procedures, can be observed. Laryngoscope, 132:822-830, 2022.
引用
- Medeiros N, Castro MEM, van Lith-Bijl JT, et al. A Systematic Review on Surgical Treatments for Sulcus Vocalis and Vocal Fold Scar. Laryngoscope. 2021. PMID: 34057225. doi:10.1002/lary.29665
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。