头颈显微血管重建中游离皮瓣并发症术语共识
该共识通过11名头颈/重建外科医生的临床共识调查,采用内容效度指数和改良kappa值筛选游离皮瓣并发症术语。
要点
- 剔除术语包括血管危象、蜂窝织炎、手术部位脓肿等。
- 标准化术语有助于多中心研究、基准设定和沟通教育。
核心结论
- 标准化游离皮瓣并发症术语可促进多中心研究合作、大规模质量改进、风险调整基准设定及教育培训。
研究设计与样本
- 临床共识调查,由11名头颈/重建外科医生组成专家组。
- 计算每个术语相关性和清晰度的内容效度指数,并调整偶然一致性(改良kappa,K)。
- 相关性K<0.74(即评级为「好」或「一般」)的术语被剔除。
主要发现
- 达成共识的术语包括:完全/部分游离皮瓣失败、游离皮瓣回收、动脉血栓形成、静脉血栓形成、微血管吻合修正、瘘管、伤口裂开、血肿、血清肿、部分皮肤移植失败、完全皮肤移植失败、硬件或骨暴露、硬件失败。
关键数值与推荐
- 剔除标准:相关性改良kappa K<0.74(评级为「好」或「一般」)。
- 保留术语均达到共识标准(未报告具体K值)。
临床怎么用
- 临床报告游离皮瓣并发症时应使用共识术语,避免使用被剔除的模糊术语。
- 标准化术语有助于机构间比较和风险调整基准的建立。
局限性
- 专家组仅11人,样本量较小。
- 未报告各保留术语的具体K值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We aim to define a set of terms for common free flap complications with evidence-based descriptions. METHODS: Clinical consensus surveys were conducted among a panel of head and neck/reconstructive surgeons (N = 11). A content validity index for relevancy and clarity for each item was computed and adjusted for chance agreement (modified kappa, K). Items with K < 0.74 for relevancy (i.e., ratings of "good" or "fair") were eliminated. RESULTS: Five out of nineteen terms scored K < 0.74. Eliminated terms included "vascular compromise"; "cellulitis"; "surgical site abscess"; "malocclusion"; and "non- or mal-union." Terms that achieved consensus were "total/partial free flap failure"; "free flap takeback"; "arterial thrombosis"; "venous thrombosis"; "revision of microvascular anastomosis"; "fistula"; "wound dehiscence"; "hematoma"; "seroma"; "partial skin graft failure"; "total skin graft failure"; "exposed hardware or bone"; and "hardware failure." CONCLUSION: Standardized reporting would encourage multi-institutional research collaboration, larger scale quality improvement initiatives, the ability to set risk-adjusted benchmarks, and enhance education and communication.
引用
- Mady LJ, Poonia SK, Baddour K, et al. Consensus of free flap complications: Using a nomenclature paradigm in microvascular head and neck reconstruction. Head Neck. 2021. PMID: 34145676. doi:10.1002/hed.26789
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。