鼻窦手术解剖自学视频课程开发:第一阶段验证
本研究开发了两部突出鼻窦解剖的多媒体视频及配套评估,由鼻科专家小组评分。结果显示视频的面效度和内容效度均显著高于中性反应,评估适合测试医学生基础鼻窦手术解剖,多数受访者认为评估全面覆盖了应掌握的鼻窦解剖内容。
要点
- 两部鼻窦解剖视频面效度均为4.4/5,内容效度分别为4.5/5和4.3/5。
- 评估被57%受访者评为非常适合测试基础鼻窦手术解剖。
- 71%受访者同意或强烈同意评估全面覆盖医学生应熟悉的鼻窦解剖内容。
核心结论
- 开发的两部视频和评估能有效突出和测试鼻窦解剖,面效度和内容效度显著高于中性反应。
研究设计与样本
- 开发两部多媒体视频(视频1含音频解说和放射影像,视频2含鼻窦手术视频高亮图像)及评估,由鼻科专家小组评分效度。
主要发现
- 专家小组对视频1和视频2的面效度评分均为4.4/5。
- 视频1内容效度评分为4.5/5(0.83),视频2为4.3/5(0.75)。
- 视频间面效度和内容效度无统计学差异。
- 评估适合(29%)或非常适合(57%)测试基础鼻窦手术解剖。
- 71%受访者同意(14%)或强烈同意(57%)评估全面覆盖医学生应熟悉的鼻窦解剖内容。
临床怎么用
- 该自学视频课程和评估可用于医学生鼻窦解剖教学,提升基础解剖知识。
局限性
- 未来需研究自学视频课程是否改善鼻窦解剖意识,以及纳入手术内镜视频是否增强培训效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Sinusitis is a common outpatient diagnosis made by physicians and is a reason for referral to otolaryngologists. A foundation in basic sinonasal anatomy is critical in understanding sinus pathophysiology and avoiding complications. Our objective in this study was to develop and to validate a self-directed surgical anatomy video for medical students. METHODS: Two multimedia videos were developed highlighting sinonasal anatomy. In Video 1 we included audio narration and radiologic imaging. Video 2 incorporated highlighted images from a sinus surgery video. An assessment was developed to test sinonasal anatomy landmarks, spatial recognition of structures, and their clinical relevance. An expert panel of rhinologists scored face and content validity of the curriculum videos and assessment. Factor analysis was used to separate questions into face and content validity domains, and a one-sample t test was performed. RESULTS: The panel scored face validity (Videos 1 and 2: 4.4/5) and content validity (Video 1: 4.5/5, 0.83; Video 2: 4.3/5, 0.75) significantly higher than a neutral response. There were no statistical differences for face or content validity between videos. The assessment was rated suitable (29%) or very suitable (57%) for testing basic sinonasal surgical anatomy, and the majority (71%) of respondents agreed (14%) or strongly agreed (57%) that the assessment thoroughly covered the sinus anatomy content with which medical students should be familiar. CONCLUSION: We have developed two videos and an assessment that highlight and test sinonasal anatomy. Future studies will aim to identify whether the use of a self-directed video curriculum improves sinonasal anatomy awareness and whether incorporation of surgical endoscopic videos augments training.
引用
- Bailey CE, Grauer JS, Chen PG, et al. Development of a self-directed sinonasal surgical anatomy video curriculum: Phase 1 validation. Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2021. PMID: 34021535. doi:10.1002/alr.22814
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。