听力筛查中的信息框架对听力损失治疗态度的影响
研究探讨信息框架(获益或损失)及被暗示听力筛查未通过是否影响18至39岁无听力损失史者对听力治疗的态度。结果显示信息框架主效应显著,获益框架下更倾向健康积极反应,框架与反馈条件无显著交互。
要点
- 获益框架信息比损失框架信息更能促使受试者表达对听力治疗的积极态度。
- 被暗示筛查未通过与否与信息框架之间无显著交互效应。
- 信息框架策略可能对40岁以下无听力损失史人群的听力健康行为态度有积极影响。
核心结论
- 获益框架信息可能对40岁以下无听力损失史个体的听力健康行为态度产生积极影响。
主要发现
- 信息类型与实验者反馈条件之间无显著交互效应,但信息类型主效应显著。
- 事后检验显示信息类型在11个问卷条目中的5个上呈现中到大的效应量。
- 参与者暴露于获益框架信息时比损失框架信息更可能赞同健康积极反应(即对听力治疗更感兴趣)。
临床怎么用
- 在听力筛查沟通中可考虑采用获益框架信息以促进对听力治疗的积极态度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The moment patients learn the results from a hearing assessment can be a critical juncture on their journey to rehabilitation. Message framing (e.g., the positive or negative manner in which information is presented) has been explored in a wide range of health contexts as a method for shaping patients' decision-making. This study investigated whether attitudes toward hearing loss treatment varied as a function of how messages about treatment were framed, and whether such attitudes differed as a function of participants being led to believe they had failed a hearing screening. METHODS: Sixty-four participants (18 to 39 years of age) took the Hearing in Noise Test. In the sound booth, participants saw a poster bearing either a gain-framed or loss-framed message about hearing loss treatment. During the test, half the participants were interrupted by the researcher who stated that their performance appeared to suggest a hearing loss, with the caveat that it might be due to an equipment malfunction. While the researcher investigated the problem, the participants completed an 11-item questionnaire asking about their attitudes toward help seeking for hearing loss. Participants in the control group completed the same questionnaire with no interruption. RESULTS: Statistical analyses revealed no significant interaction effect between message type and experimenter feedback condition, though a significant main effect was present for message type. Post hoc testing showed medium to large effect sizes as a function of message type on five of the 11-questionnaire items. These data indicated that participants were more likely to endorse health-positive responses (i.e., greater interest in hearing treatment) when exposed to the gain-framed message than the loss-framed message. CONCLUSIONS: The greater likelihood of health-positive responses in the presence of the gain-framed message suggests that this framing strategy may have a positive influence on attitudes toward hearing health behaviors among individuals under 40 years of age with no history of hearing loss.
引用
- St Jean CR, Cummine J, Singh G, et al. Be Part of the Conversation: Audiology Messaging During a Hearing Screening. Ear Hear. 2021. PMID: 34010246. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001056
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。