文献速递耳科与耳神经

任务难度可预测性与降噪对回忆表现及瞳孔扩张的影响

The Effects of Task Difficulty Predictability and Noise Reduction on Recall Performance and Pupil Dilation Responses.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2021-01-01

结果显示任务难度可预测性不影响资源分配,降噪释放资源用于言语存储,表现为回忆表现更好且句子基线瞳孔扩张更高,两种测量反映资源分配的不同时间层面。

要点

  • 任务难度可预测性不影响回忆表现,但不可预测时句子基线瞳孔扩张更高。
  • 降噪开启时回忆表现更好且句子基线瞳孔扩张更高,尤其在长列表末尾。
  • 降噪对任务诱发峰值瞳孔扩张(PPD)无影响。

核心结论

  • 任务难度可预测性不影响资源分配,回忆表现相似。
  • 不可预测时句子基线瞳孔扩张更高,可能反映回忆策略或警觉/唤醒差异。
  • 降噪释放资源用于言语存储,表现为回忆更好和列表末尾基线瞳孔扩张更高。
  • 瞳孔测量捕捉了SWIR测试未捕捉的过程,两者反映资源分配的不同时间层面。

研究设计与样本

  • 同步进行SWIR测试和瞳孔测量,背景噪声为四说话者嘈杂语。
  • 降噪在测试助听器中开启和关闭,任务难度可预测性通过三、五、七句列表操纵。
  • 测试分两次 session:一次提前告知列表长度(可预测),一次不告知(不可预测)。

主要发现

  • 不可预测任务难度时句子基线瞳孔扩张高于可预测,但列表开始时无差异。
  • PPD在列表开始时倾向于更高,不可预测时更明显。
  • 降噪开启时回忆表现更好且句子基线瞳孔扩张更高,尤其在长列表末尾。
  • 降噪对PPD无影响。

临床怎么用

  • 降噪有助于释放认知资源用于言语存储,可能改善回忆表现。
  • 瞳孔测量可提供SWIR测试未反映的资源分配信息。
  • 任务难度可预测性对回忆表现无显著影响,但可能影响警觉/唤醒状态。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Communication requires cognitive processes which are not captured by traditional speech understanding tests. Under challenging listening situations, more working memory resources are needed to process speech, leaving fewer resources available for storage. The aim of the current study was to investigate the effect of task difficulty predictability, that is, knowing versus not knowing task difficulty in advance, and the effect of noise reduction on working memory resource allocation to processing and storage of speech heard in background noise. For this purpose, an "offline" behavioral measure, the Sentence-Final Word Identification and Recall (SWIR) test, and an "online" physiological measure, pupillometry, were combined. Moreover, the outcomes of the two measures were compared to investigate whether they reflect the same processes related to resource allocation. DESIGN: Twenty-four experienced hearing aid users with moderate to moderately severe hearing loss participated in this study. The SWIR test and pupillometry were measured simultaneously with noise reduction in the test hearing aids activated and deactivated in a background noise composed of four-talker babble. The task of the SWIR test is to listen to lists of sentences, repeat the last word immediately after each sentence and recall the repeated words when the list is finished. The sentence baseline dilation, which is defined as the mean pupil dilation before each sentence, and task-evoked peak pupil dilation (PPD) were analyzed over the course of the lists. The task difficulty predictability was manipulated by including lists of three, five, and seven sentences. The test was conducted over two sessions, one during which the participants were informed about list length before each list (predictable task difficulty) and one during which they were not (unpredictable task difficulty). RESULTS: The sentence baseline dilation was higher when task difficulty was unpredictable compared to predictable, except at the start of the list, where there was no difference. The PPD tended to be higher at the beginning of the list, this pattern being more prominent when task difficulty was unpredictable. Recall performance was better and sentence baseline dilation was higher when noise reduction was on, especially toward the end of longer lists. There was no effect of noise reduction on PPD. CONCLUSIONS: Task difficulty predictability did not have an effect on resource allocation, since recall performance was similar independently of whether task difficulty was predictable or unpredictable. The higher sentence baseline dilation when task difficulty was unpredictable likely reflected a difference in the recall strategy or higher degree of task engagement/alertness or arousal. Hence, pupillometry captured processes which the SWIR test does not capture. Noise reduction frees up resources to be used for storage of speech, which was reflected in the better recall performance and larger sentence baseline dilation toward the end of the list when noise reduction was on. Thus, both measures captured different temporal aspects of the same processes related to resource allocation with noise reduction on and off.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Micula A, Rönnberg J, Fiedler L, et al. The Effects of Task Difficulty Predictability and Noise Reduction on Recall Performance and Pupil Dilation Responses. Ear Hear. 2021. PMID: 33859121. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001053

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。