预测成人助听器满意度的行为学指标:系统综述
本系统综述纳入21项研究,评估成人助听器验配前行为学测量与满意度的关系。结果显示言语噪声下测试与满意度关联最高,而可听度(听力损失程度)在13项报告中与满意度无显著相关。QuickSIN、合成句识别、噪声下听力测试和可接受噪声级测试显示出临床应用潜力。
要点
- 言语噪声下测试与助听器满意度关联最高,可听度无显著相关。
- QuickSIN、合成句识别、噪声下听力测试和可接受噪声级测试有临床潜力。
- 纳入研究方法学质量评级为0至4,内部效度弱至中等。
核心结论
- 言语噪声下测试与助听器满意度关联最高,提示其在听觉康复评估中作用更大。
- 可听度(听力损失程度)在13项报告中与助听器满意度无显著相关。
- 需要设计良好、高质量的前瞻性研究评估验配前测量对当前助听器满意度的预测价值。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索6个电子数据库至2020年6月,纳入21项同行评议研究。
- 评估六类验配前行为学测量:安静下言语识别(%正确)、噪声下言语识别(%正确)、言语噪声下接收阈值、言语主观评级、双耳言语测试和非言语材料测试。
- 每项研究由两名评审独立审核,采用美国言语语言听力协会证据水平评级评估方法学质量。
- 所有纳入研究方法学质量评级为0至4,内部效度弱至中等。
主要发现
- 初检1342篇文章,去除重复并应用纳入标准后纳入21项研究。
- 与满意度显著相关且具临床应用潜力的测试包括QuickSIN、合成句识别、噪声下听力测试和可接受噪声级测试。
- 13项报告可听度(以听力损失程度衡量)的研究中,可听度与助听器满意度无显著相关。
临床怎么用
- 验配前可考虑使用言语噪声下测试(如QuickSIN、噪声下听力测试)评估患者助听器满意度风险。
- 不应仅依据听力损失程度预测助听器满意度。
局限性
- 纳入研究方法学质量评级为0至4,内部效度弱至中等。
- 需要设计良好、高质量的前瞻性研究评估验配前测量对当前助听器满意度的预测价值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Adults with hearing loss report a wide range of hearing aid satisfaction that does not significantly correlate to degree of hearing loss. It is not clear which auditory behavioral factors do contribute to hearing aid satisfaction. While poor speech understanding in noise is known to contribute to dissatisfaction, there are many categories of this type of assessment. The purpose of this systematic review is to answer the question, "Are behavioral pre-fitting measures using speech and nonspeech materials related to hearing aid satisfaction among adults?" DESIGN: Six electronic databases were searched to find peer-reviewed studies published before June 2020. The included studies reported on the relationship between auditory behavioral measures and hearing aid satisfaction alone or globally with other outcome domains among adults with hearing loss. Six types of behavioral prefitting measures were evaluated: speech recognition in quiet (% correct), speech recognition in noise (% correct), reception thresholds for speech-in-noise, speech-based subjective ratings, dichotic speech tests, and tests using nonspeech material. Each relevant study was independently reviewed by two reviewers. Methodological quality was evaluated in each included study using the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association's level of evidence ratings. RESULTS: There were 1342 articles identified in the systematic review process. After duplicates were removed and specific inclusion criteria were applied, 21 studies were included. All studies included had a 0 to 4 methodological quality rating indicating weak to moderate internal validity. The tests that showed potential for clinical application due to significant correlations with satisfaction were the QuickSIN, the synthetic sentence identification, the hearing in noise test, and the acceptable noise level test. Audibility, as measured by degree of hearing loss, was not significantly correlated to hearing aid satisfaction in the 13 studies that reported on this measure. CONCLUSIONS: Based on this review, results indicated that speech-in-noise tests had the highest associations to hearing aid satisfaction, suggesting a greater role for assessment of speech-in-noise perception in auditory rehabilitation. This is an important finding for clinical practice, given that audibility was not a significant factor in predicting satisfaction. Overall, the results from this review show a need for well-designed, high-quality, prospective studies assessing the predictive value of prefitting measures on hearing aid satisfaction with current hearing aid models.
引用
- Davidson A, Marrone N, Wong B, et al. Predicting Hearing Aid Satisfaction in Adults: A Systematic Review of Speech-in-noise Tests and Other Behavioral Measures. Ear Hear. 2021. PMID: 33883425. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。