透明口罩在噪声下言语识别中的作用
本研究通过在线方式比较透明口罩与不透明口罩对噪声下言语识别的影响,纳入154名正常听力及听力损失成人。结果显示透明口罩的视听识别得分显著更高(68.9% vs 58.9%),且获益源于视觉线索而非声学优势。
要点
- 透明口罩较不透明口罩显著改善噪声下言语识别。
- 获益来自面部视觉线索,而非录音声学差异。
- 建议在安全许可下优先使用透明口罩以改善沟通。
核心结论
- 使用透明口罩可显著促进噪声下的言语识别,即使对正常听力者也是如此。
- 透明口罩的获益归因于通过透明口罩可见的说话者面部视觉线索,而非声学优势。
研究设计与样本
- 采用重复测量设计,评估背景噪声下录制的句子在透明口罩、不透明口罩和无口罩条件下的视听识别(N=154)。
- 较小规模的后续研究(N=29)采用仅听觉呈现相同文件,以判断差异是否源于额外视觉线索或录音声学差异。
- 参与者为以英语为第一语言的成人志愿者,通过社交媒体链接和电子邮件招募,分为正常听力、确诊或疑似听力损失(使用或不使用助听设备)三组。
- 参与者在安静房间内通过个人听音设备(耳塞或助听设备)在电脑、笔记本电脑或平板电脑上完成40分钟在线会话。
主要发现
- 对所有参与者,透明口罩录制的句子视听识别(M=68.9%)显著优于不透明口罩(M=58.9%)。
- 使用助听技术的参与者得分有低于其他两组的趋势,而其他两组在各条件下表现相似,无论口罩类型。
- 主观信心和专注度评分与客观得分模式一致。
- 正常听力者仅听觉呈现时,透明口罩下的表现(M=40.7%)显著低于不透明口罩(M=58.2%)。
临床怎么用
- 在临床、就业和教育环境中,为减少沟通挑战,强烈鼓励使用安全批准的透明口罩而非不透明口罩。
- 透明口罩可帮助改善噪声下的言语识别,对正常听力者也有益。
局限性
- 后续仅听觉研究样本较小(N=29)。
- 研究通过在线格式进行,参与者使用个人设备。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to assess the speech recognition in noise when using a transparent mask that allows greater visibility of the talker's face compared to an opaque mask in persons with normal and impaired hearing via an online format. DESIGN: A repeated-measures design was used to evaluate the auditory-visual recognition of sentences recorded in background noise with transparent and opaque face masks, and without a mask (N = 154). In a smaller follow-up study (N = 29), the same files were presented via auditory-only presentation to determine if differences observed in the transparent and opaque mask conditions were attributable to additional visual cues or to acoustic differences between the recordings of the two mask types. Listeners completed the 40-minute online session on a computer, laptop, or tablet in a quiet room via their personal listening devices (earbuds or hearing assistive device). The adult volunteers who used English as their first language were recruited through social media links and email and categorized into three groups: normal hearing and confirmed or suspected hearing loss either with or without the use of assistive listening devices. RESULTS: Auditory-visual recognition of sentences recorded with the transparent mask was significantly better (M = 68.9%) than for sentences recorded with the opaque mask (M = 58.9%) for all participants. There was a trend for those who used hearing assistive technology to score lower than the other two groups who had similar performance across all conditions regardless of the mask type. Subjective ratings of confidence and concentration followed the expected pattern based on objective scores. Results of the auditory-only presentation of the sentences to listeners with normal hearing suggested that the transparent mask benefits were not attributable to an acoustic advantage but rather to the addition of the visual cues of the talker's face available through the transparent mask. In fact, performance in the auditory-only presentation was significantly lower with the transparent mask (M = 40.7%) compared to the opaque mask (M = 58.2%). CONCLUSIONS: Use of transparent masks can significantly facilitate speech recognition in noise even for persons with normal hearing and thus may reduce stressful communication challenges experienced in medical, employment, and educational settings during the global pandemic. To mitigate the spread of COVID-19 and facilitate communication, safety-approved transparent masks are strongly encouraged over opaque masks.
引用
- Thibodeau LM, Thibodeau-Nielsen RB, Tran CMQ, et al. Communicating During COVID-19: The Effect of Transparent Masks for Speech Recognition in Noise. Ear Hear. 2021. PMID: 33813522. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。