双侧小耳畸形-闭锁患者单侧与双侧骨导助听的疗效评估
研究纳入32例双侧小耳畸形伴外耳道闭锁患者,平均年龄11.8岁,行个体化耳廓再造与骨桥植入。单侧骨桥及双侧骨导助听均较裸耳显著改善平均听阈和言语识别率;噪声环境下双侧骨导助听显著优于单侧骨桥。主观问卷显示单侧和双侧助听均获满意效果。
要点
- 单侧骨桥或双侧骨导助听均可显著改善双侧小耳畸形患者的纯音听阈和安静下言语识别率。
- 噪声环境(SNR=5 dB)下双侧骨导助听言语识别率显著优于单侧骨桥。
- 个体化耳廓再造联合骨桥植入安全有效,同时解决外观与听力问题。
核心结论
- 单侧骨桥植入和一侧骨桥+对侧ADHEAR均可改善双侧小耳畸形伴外耳道闭锁患者的纯音听阈和言语识别率。
- 双侧骨导助听较单侧骨桥可进一步提高噪声下的言语识别率。
- 个体化耳廓再造联合骨桥植入安全有效,同时解决外观和听力问题。
研究设计与样本
- 研究对象为2016年3月至2020年1月在北京协和医院手术治疗的32例双侧小耳畸形伴外耳道闭锁患者,男20例、女12例,平均年龄11.8岁。
- 术前测试裸耳平均听阈及言语识别率,行颞骨高分辨CT评估乳突发育,制定个体化分期耳廓再造及骨桥植入方案。
- 术后骨桥开机时及开机后3、6、12、24个月测试单侧骨桥助听的平均听阈及言语识别率(安静环境和信噪比5 dB噪声环境下的双音节词识别率)。
- 植入骨桥至少3个月后测试裸耳、单侧骨桥助听和双侧骨导助听(一侧骨桥+对侧ADHEAR)的平均听阈及言语识别率。
- 采用国际助听器评估问卷和Glasgow儿童获益调查问卷评估主观获益,使用SPSS 21.0软件进行统计学处理。
主要发现
- 32例中9例于耳廓再造术前植入骨桥,6例同期植入,17例于耳廓再造术后植入;32例均对侧佩戴ADHEAR。
- 单侧骨桥及双侧骨导助听的平均纯音听阈均较裸耳明显改善,差异具有统计学意义(t=22.15,P<0.05)。
- 单侧骨桥与双侧骨导助听阈值接近,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 安静环境下单侧骨桥及双侧骨导助听均可显著提高言语识别率(t=6.50,P<0.05),两者间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
- 噪声环境下双侧骨导助听显著优于单侧骨桥,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05);主观问卷显示单侧骨桥及双侧骨导助听均获满意效果。
关键数值与推荐
- 平均听阈测试频率为0.5、1、2、4 kHz。
- 噪声环境言语识别率测试采用信噪比5 dB下的双音节词识别率。
- 双侧骨导助听条件为一侧骨桥+对侧ADHEAR。
临床怎么用
- 对双侧小耳畸形伴外耳道闭锁合并重度传导性聋患者,可个体化安排耳廓再造与骨桥植入的时序。
- 单侧骨桥即可改善安静下听阈和言语识别,若需改善噪声下言语识别可考虑双侧骨导助听(骨桥+对侧ADHEAR)。
- 术后可采用国际助听器评估问卷和Glasgow儿童获益调查问卷评估主观获益。
局限性
- 样本量32例,平均年龄11.8岁,为单中心研究。
- 摘要未报告随机化、盲法及对照设置等设计细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objectives: To evaluate the therapeutic effects of unilateral/bilateral bone conduction hearing rehabilitation in patients with bilateral microtia accompanied with severe conductive hearing loss following staged auricle reconstruction and bonebridge implantation. Methods: Thirty-two patients, including 20 males and 12 females, with an average age of 11.8, who received surgical treatment in Peking Union Medical College Hospital (PUMCH) from March, 2016 to January, 2020 with bilateral microtia-atresia were included. Hearing thresholds, speech perception and high-resolution CT of the temporal bone were evaluated prior to surgery and individualized surgery plans (staged auricle reconstruction and bonebridge implantation) were made. Hearing thresholds and speech perception in quiet and noise (SNR = 5 dB) using unilateral Bonebridge were tested two weeks after the implantation surgery when the Bonebridge was activated and at 3th, 6th, 12th month after activation. Hearing thresholds and speech perception were also tested at least three months after the activation of the Bonebridge under three conditions: unaided, unilateral Bonebridge, and bilateral bone conduction hearing devices (Bonebridge plus contralateral ADHEAR). The international hearing aid assessment questionnaire (IOI-HA) and Glasgow children's benefit questionnaire were used to evaluate the subjective benefits of the patients. SPSS 21.0 software was used for statistical analysis. Results: Among these 32 patients, nine were conducted Bonebridge implantation surgery before auricle reconstruction, six were simultaneously with auricle reconstruction and 17 were implanted after auricle reconstruction surgery. Compared with unaided, the mean hearing thresholds (0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz) and speech perception following unilateral BCHD and bilateral BCHD attachment were improved significantly (P<0.05 each). The speech perceptin in noise of bilateral BCHD was better than unilateral (P<0.05 each). The modified questionnaire revealed high levels of patient satisfaction following use of both unilateral and bilateral devices. Conclusions: Individulized surgical procedures involving auricle reconstruction and Bonebridge implantation are safe and effective for patients with bilateral microtia-atresia, solving both appearance and hearing problems. Speech perception in noise is better following bilateral BCHD than unilateral BCHD attachment. 目的: 探讨双侧小耳畸形合并重度传导性听力损失患者分期耳廓再造-骨桥植入术后单侧及双侧骨导助听的疗效。 方法: 研究对象为2016年3月至2020年1月在北京协和医院手术治疗的32例双侧小耳畸形伴外耳道闭锁患者,其中男20例,女12例,平均年龄11.8岁。术前测试裸耳平均听阈及言语识别率,行颞骨高分辨CT评估乳突发育情况,制定个体化手术方案(分期耳廓再造及骨桥植入术)。术后骨桥开机时、开机后3、6、12、24个月,测试单侧骨桥助听的平均听阈及言语识别率(安静环境和信噪比5 dB噪声环境下的双音节词识别率);植入骨桥至少3个月后,分别测试裸耳、单侧骨桥助听和双侧骨导助听(一侧骨桥+对侧ADHEAR)的平均听阈及言语识别率。采用国际助听器评估问卷和Glasgow儿童获益调查问卷评估患者术后主观获益情况。使用SPSS 21.0软件进行统计学处理。 结果: 32例患者中9例于耳廓再造术前植入骨桥,6例同期植入骨桥,17例于耳廓再造术后植入骨桥;32例均对侧佩戴ADHEAR。单侧骨桥及双侧骨导助听的平均纯音听阈均较裸耳明显改善,差异具有统计学意义(t=22.15,P<0.05),单侧骨桥与双侧骨导助听阈值接近,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。安静环境下单侧骨桥及双侧骨导助听均可显著提高患者的言语识别率(t=6.50,P<0.05),单侧骨桥与双侧骨导助听之间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);噪声环境下,双侧骨导助听显著优于单侧骨桥,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。主观调查问卷显示单侧骨桥植入及双侧骨导助听均可获得满意效果。 结论: 对于双侧先天性小耳畸形伴外耳道闭锁同时合并重度传导性聋患者,单侧骨桥植入和一侧骨桥+对侧ADHEAR均可改善其纯音听阈和言语识别率,双侧骨导助听较单侧骨桥可进一步提高噪声下的言语识别率。.
引用
- Niu XM, Ping L, Fan XM, et al. [Evaluation of unilateral and bilateral bimodal bone conduction hearing intervention in patients with bilateral microtia-atresia]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2021. PMID: 33832192. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn115330-20200910-00733
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。