人工耳蜗的位置-音高间隔感知研究
该研究通过三个实验测试人工耳蜗(CI)使用者对旋律音程间隔变化的感知能力。实验一和实验二分别测试10名CI使用者和10名正常听力者,以及单侧聋CI使用者,发现CI使用者对音程间隔扭曲的评级无显著差异,但部分参与者对某些扭曲有改善评级。实验三证实CI使用者能可靠识别音高方向变化。结论认为位置-音高间隔在CI声音处理器中未得到恰当表征。
要点
- CI使用者对音程间隔扭曲的感知与正常听力者不同,评级无一致模式。
- 部分CI使用者对特定音程扭曲的评级优于标称正确间隔,但个体差异大。
- CI使用者能可靠识别位置-音高编码的音高方向变化。
核心结论
- 位置-音高间隔通过CI声音处理器未得到恰当表征,但部分参与者对某些间隔扭曲有改善评级。
- 由于个体差异大,不存在通用的频率表征校正方案。
研究设计与样本
- 实验一测试10名CI使用者和10名正常听力对照者对「Happy Birthday」旋律中半音间隔变化的敏感性。
- 实验二使用单侧聋CI使用者重复实验一,进行受试者内对照。
- 实验三验证实验一中的CI使用者能可靠判断音高方向。
主要发现
- CI使用者常将所有间隔扭曲评级相似,未检测到间隔间距的效应。
- 部分参与者认为扭曲的间隔比标称正确间隔更不跑调,但模式不一致。
- 正常听力者表现更好,CI使用者能可靠识别音高方向变化。
临床怎么用
- 临床需注意CI使用者对音程间隔的感知存在较大个体差异,不宜采用统一校正策略。
- 部分CI使用者可能从电极频率表征调整中获益,但需个体化评估。
局限性
- 样本量较小(10名CI使用者),结果可能不具备广泛代表性。
- 研究未明确排除耳蜗植入时长等因素对结果的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Pitch is poorly perceived by cochlear implant (CI) users. However, as it is not well understood how pitch is encoded with electric stimulation, improving pitch representation with a CI is challenging. Changes in place of stimulation along the cochlea have been described as changes in pitch and can be accurately ranked by CI users. However, it remains unknown if place-pitch can be used to encode musical intervals, which are a necessary attribute of pitch. The objective of these experiments is to determine if place-pitch coding can be used to represent musical intervals with a CI. DESIGN: In the first experiment, 10 CI users and 10 normal hearing (NH) controls were tested on their sensitivity to changes in the semitone spacing between each of the notes in the melody "Happy Birthday." The changes were implemented by uniformly expanding or compressing the frequency differences between each note in the melody. The participant's task was to scale how "out-of-tune" the melody was for various semitone spacing distortions. The notes were represented by pure-tones ≥440 Hz to minimize potential useful temporal information from the stimuli. A second experiment replicated the first experiment using single-sided deafened CI users allowing for a within-subject control. A third experiment verified that the CI users who participated in Experiment 1 were each able to determine pitch direction reliably. RESULTS: Unlike NH listeners, CI listeners often ranked all distortions of interval spacing similarly in both the first and second experiment, and no effect of interval spacing was detected across CI users. Some participants found distorted interval spacings to be less out-of-tune than the nominally correct interval spacings. However, these patterns were inconsistent across listeners. Although performance was better for the NH listeners, the third experiment demonstrated that the CI listeners were able to reliably identify changes in pitch direction from place-pitch coding. CONCLUSIONS: The data suggest that place-pitch intervals are not properly represented through a CI sound processor. Some limited support is found for place-pitch being useful for interval encoding as some participants demonstrated improved ratings for certain interval distortions. Presumably the interval representation for these participants could be improved by a change to the frequencies represented by each electrode. However, as these patterns vary across listeners, there is not a universal correction to frequency representation that will solve this issue. As results are similar for single-sided deafened CI users, the limitations in ratings are likely not limited by an eroded representation of the melody caused by an extended duration of deafness.
引用
- Stupak N, Todd AE, Landsberger DM, et al. Place-Pitch Interval Perception With a Cochlear Implant. Ear Hear. 2021. PMID: 33606415. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000922
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。