成人人工耳蜗决策影响因素的多利益相关者视角探索
本研究采用概念映射法,整合93名参与者(客户60人,专业人员33人)的头脑风暴、分组命名和五点评分数据,探索影响成人人工耳蜗植入决策的因素及其影响程度。各概念对决策影响的平均评分从2.24(外部影响,主要障碍)到4.45(目标与支持,主要驱动)不等,客户与专业人员队列的评分存在显著差异。
要点
- 外部影响(如非植入专业人员的认知、费用、转诊路径)是主要障碍,平均评分2.24。
- 目标与支持(如听力目标、家庭支持、植入者导师)是主要驱动,平均评分4.45。
- 客户与专业人员对影响因素的评分存在显著差异,提示需多学科协作提升认知。
核心结论
- 客户驱动域中的陈述数量之多突显了个体化护理在临床决策中的关键作用。
- 客户持续的听力困难、目标和支持网络是人工耳蜗植入的驱动因素。
- 障碍因素提示需要多学科协作提高非植入听力专业人员对人工耳蜗流程的认知,并赋能客户做出知情决策。
研究设计与样本
- 采用概念映射这一混合参与式方法,整合多个利益相关者的输入。
- 共93人参与:客户队列60人(平均年龄66.60岁),专业队列33人(平均年龄45.24岁)。
- 参与者针对「什么影响人们决定植入/不植入人工耳蜗?」进行头脑风暴,随后分组命名并对每条陈述的影响程度和改变/改进需求进行五点评分。
- 使用多维标度法生成概念视觉表征,并进一步分析队列、亚队列和概念间的差异。
主要发现
- 六个概念为:外部影响;不确定性、信念和恐惧;健康问题;听力困难;植入专业人员;目标和支持。
- 各概念对客户植入决策影响的平均评分从2.24(外部影响,主要障碍)到4.45(目标和支持,主要驱动)。
- 客户队列与专业队列的评分存在显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 外部影响包括非植入专业人员对植入的认知和态度、费用、物流、转诊路径、公众意识。
- 不确定性、信念和恐惧包括恐惧、口碑的负面影响、既往耳部手术失败、设备外观、对人工耳蜗功能的误解、植入资格和植入后结果。
- 健康问题包括心理和身体健康。
- 听力困难包括听力损失的社会、情感和沟通影响,听力损失严重程度,助听器获益和经验。
- 植入专业人员包括植入团队的态度、知识和与客户的关系,整体服务质量。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应重视个体化护理,了解客户的需求和期望以影响其决策。
- 需通过多学科协作提高非植入听力专业人员对人工耳蜗流程的认知和教育。
- 为客户提供信息赋能,使其做出知情决策并将人工耳蜗视为听力管理选项。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To explore the factors influencing the uptake of cochlear implants in adults, determine the impact of each factor, and to conceptualize the journey to implantation from a multistakeholder perspective. DESIGN: Concept mapping was used to integrate input from multiple stakeholders, each with their own experience and expertise. This mixed participatory method collects qualitative and quantitative data collection and enables further quantitative analysis. There were two participant cohorts: clients (cochlear implant recipients, candidates, and family members) and professionals (cochlear implant audiologists, ear, nose, and throat surgeons, administration staff, managers. and manufacturer representatives). A total of 93 people participated in the study: client cohort (n = 60, M age = 66.60 years) and professional cohort (n = 33, M age = 45.24 years). Participants brainstormed statements in response to the question "What influences people's decision to get/not get a cochlear implant?" They subsequently grouped the statements and named each group. They rated each statement as to its impact on the decision and prioritized the need for each to be changed/improved using a five-point Likert scale. Multidimensional scaling was used to produce a visual representation of the ideas and their relationship in the form of concepts. Further analysis was conducted to determine the differences between the cohorts, subcohorts, and concepts. RESULTS: One hundred ten unique statements were generated and grouped into six concepts which either directly affected the client or their environment. These concepts were: external influences (awareness and attitude of non-implant professionals about uptake, cost, logistics, the referral pathway, public awareness); uncertainties, beliefs, and fears (fears, negative effect of word of mouth, unsuccessful previous ear surgery, cosmetics of the device, misunderstanding of how a cochlear implant functions, eligibility for an implant and outcomes after implantation); health problems (mental and physical health); hearing difficulties (social, emotional, and communication impacts of hearing loss, severity of hearing loss, benefit from and experience with hearing aids); implant professionals (implant team's attitude, knowledge and relationship with clients, quality of overall service); and goals and support (clients 'hearing desires and goals, motivation, positive impact of word of mouth, family support, having a cochlear implant mentor. The six concepts fell into two overarching domains: the client-driven domain with four concepts and the external domain with two concepts. The mean rating of concepts in terms of impact on a client's decision to get an implant ranged from 2.24 (external influences, the main barrier) to 4.45 (goals and support, the main driver). Ratings significantly differed between the client and professional cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: This study increases our understanding of the factors, which influence a client's decision choose a cochlear implant as a hearing treatment. It also provides new information on the influence of the other stakeholders on the client journey. The magnitude of the generated statements in the client-driven domain highlights the pivotal role of individualized care in clinical settings in influencing a client's decision and the need for the professionals to understand a client's needs and expectations. A client's persistent hearing difficulties, goals, and support network were identified as drivers to the uptake of cochlear implants. However, the barriers identified highlight the need for a collaborative multi- and interdisciplinary approach to raise awareness in and educate non-implant hearing professionals about the cochlear implant process, as well as providing information to empower clients to make educated decisions and consider a cochlear implant as a hearing management option.
引用
- Ebrahimi-Madiseh A, Eikelboom RH, Bennett RJ, et al. What Influences Decision-Making for Cochlear Implantation in Adults? Exploring Barriers and Drivers From a Multistakeholder Perspective. Ear Hear. 2020. PMID: 33136648. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000895
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。