方向性处理、压缩与工作记忆对言语识别的影响
结果显示言语识别与工作记忆的关联取决于信号改变程度,方向性处理可降低快压缩在高SNR下对言语线索的不利影响。
要点
- 信号改变量随方向性与压缩速度的组合及SNR而变化,0与5 dB SNR下慢压缩信号改变低于快压缩。
- 言语识别与工作记忆的显著关联仅出现在较低信号改变水平,与原有假设方向相反。
- 工作记忆较好者在方向性加慢压缩使信号改变减少时获益更多。
核心结论
- 工作记忆能力在应用宽动态范围压缩与方向性处理时仍是言语识别的显著预测因素。
- 方向性处理可减少快压缩在高SNR下对言语线索的有害影响,从而影响言语识别能力。
- 与部分既往研究相反,本研究表明工作记忆较好者从信号改变减少中获益多于工作记忆较差者。
研究设计与样本
- 信号处理在方向性(全向与固定方向性)和WDRC速度(快与慢)两个维度变化。
- 在空间分离的多说话人噪声中测量0 dB、5 dB、10 dB SNR及安静条件下的句子识别。
- 采用个体化助听器设置测量所有实验条件下的累积信号改变,并用线性混合效应模型分析。
主要发现
- 0与5 dB SNR下,无论方向性如何,慢压缩的信号改变均低于快压缩。
- 10 dB SNR且固定方向性条件下,快压缩与慢压缩之间无信号改变差异。
- 言语识别与工作记忆的显著关联仅见于较低信号改变水平。
- 随着方向性与慢压缩使信号改变减少,工作记忆较好者的言语识别提升速度更快。
关键数值与推荐
- 信号改变用倒谱相关指标量化,反映处理后信号相对线性放大参考信号的时间包络变化。
- 测试条件包括0 dB、5 dB、10 dB SNR及安静,噪声为空间分离的多说话人 babble。
- 压缩速度分为快作用与慢作用,方向性分为全向与固定方向性。
临床怎么用
- 验配时可考虑方向性与慢压缩组合以减少信号改变,尤其在高SNR环境。
- 对工作记忆较好的听力损失者,减少信号改变的设置可能带来更大言语识别收益。
- 评估助听器效果时应同时考虑方向性、压缩速度与信噪比的交互作用。
局限性
- 研究采用商用助听器特定设置,信号处理参数范围有限。
- 未涉及其他年龄层或不同类型的听力损失人群。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Previous research has shown that the association between hearing aid-processed speech recognition and individual working memory ability becomes stronger in more challenging conditions (e.g., higher background noise levels) and with stronger hearing aid processing (e.g., fast-acting wide dynamic range compression, WDRC). To date, studies have assumed omnidirectional microphone settings and collocated speech and noise conditions to study such relationships. Such conditions fail to recognize that most hearing aids are fit with directional processing that may improve the signal to noise ratio (SNR) and speech recognition in spatially separated speech and noise conditions. Here, we considered the possibility that directional processing may reduce the signal distortion arising from fast-acting WDRC and in turn influence the relationship between working memory ability and speech recognition with WDRC processing. The combined effects of hearing aid processing (WDRC and directionality) and SNR were quantified using a signal modification metric (cepstral correlation), which measures temporal envelope changes in the processed signal with respect to a linearly amplified reference. It was hypothesized that there will be a weaker association between working memory ability and speech recognition for hearing aid processing conditions that result in overall less signal modification (i.e., fewer changes to the processed envelope). DESIGN: Twenty-three individuals with bilateral, mild to moderately severe sensorineural hearing loss participated in the study. Participants were fit with a commercially available hearing aid, and signal processing was varied in two dimensions: (1) Directionality (omnidirectional [OMNI] versus fixed-directional [DIR]), and (2) WDRC speed (fast-acting [FAST] versus slow-acting [SLOW]). Sentence recognition in spatially separated multi-talker babble was measured across a range of SNRs: 0 dB, 5 dB, 10 dB, and quiet. Cumulative signal modification was measured with individualized hearing aid settings, for all experimental conditions. A linear mixed-effects model was used to determine the relationship between speech recognition, working memory ability, and cumulative signal modification. RESULTS: Signal modification results showed a complex relationship between directionality and WDRC speed, which varied by SNR. At 0 and 5 dB SNRs, signal modification was lower for SLOW than FAST regardless of directionality. However, at 10 dB SNR and in the DIR listening condition, there was no signal modification difference between FAST and SLOW. Consistent with previous studies, the association of speech recognition in noise with working memory ability depended on the level of signal modification. Contrary to the hypothesis above, however, there was a significant association of speech recognition with working memory only at lower levels of signal modification, and speech recognition increased at a faster rate for individuals with better working memory as signal modification decreased with DIR and SLOW. CONCLUSIONS: This research suggests that working memory ability remains a significant predictor of speech recognition when WDRC and directionality are applied. Our findings revealed that directional processing can reduce the detrimental effect of fast-acting WDRC on speech cues at higher SNRs, which affects speech recognition ability. Contrary to some previous research, this study showed that individuals with better working memory ability benefitted more from a decrease in signal modification than individuals with poorer working memory ability.
引用
- Rallapalli V, Ellis G, Souza P, et al. Effects of Directionality, Compression, and Working Memory on Speech Recognition. Ear Hear. 2021. PMID: 33136708. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000970
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。