早聋患者青少年或成年期迟发性人工耳蜗植入的系统综述:临床有效性
该系统综述检索五个数据库2000年至2017年9月的文献,纳入38项报告早聋患者青少年或成年期植入人工耳蜗前后言语或声音感知、视听或主观获益的研究。多数研究显示开放集言语感知、视听言语感知及听力相关生活质量显著改善,但术后平均开放集言语识别得分在绝大多数研究中仍低于50%,且高质量研究有限。
要点
- 迟发性人工耳蜗植入可显著改善早聋患者的开放集言语感知、视听言语感知及听力相关生活质量。
- 术后平均开放集言语识别得分在绝大多数研究中仍低于50%。
- 现有证据质量有限,需更多高质量研究明确该人群的植入结局。
核心结论
- 多数研究显示早聋患者青少年或成年期植入人工耳蜗后开放集言语感知、视听言语感知及听力相关生活质量显著改善。
- 术后平均开放集言语识别得分在绝大多数研究中仍低于50%。
- 需要更多且更高质量的研究来更详细地了解该人群的植入结局。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索PubMed、Embase、Cochrane library、CINAHL和PsycInfo五个电子数据库。
- 检索2000年至2017年9月发表的英文、法文、德文或荷兰文研究。
- 纳入报告早聋患者青少年或成年期植入人工耳蜗前后言语或声音感知、视听或主观获益(生活质量)结局的研究。
- 采用Institute of Health Economics病例系列研究质量评价工具评估研究质量。
- 最终纳入38项符合标准的研究。
主要发现
- 仅有限数量研究被Institute of Health Economics工具评为高质量,相关研究信息缺乏(清晰)呈现是反复出现的问题。
- 16项研究发现术后显著改善,但若所有研究均进行适当统计检验,该数量可能更高。
- 8项研究观察到植入后视听表现提高,其中6项差异有统计学意义。
- 评估主观结局的16项研究中仅5项使用了经验证的听力相关生活质量量表,多数问卷维度显示术后显著改善。
临床怎么用
- 早聋患者青少年或成年期植入人工耳蜗前,应告知其多数研究中术后开放集言语识别平均得分仍低于50%。
- 应向患者说明植入后开放集言语感知、视听言语感知及听力相关生活质量在多数研究中可获显著改善。
- 临床决策应结合现有证据质量有限的现状,个体化评估并充分沟通预期结局。
局限性
- 仅有限数量研究被Institute of Health Economics工具评为高质量。
- 相关研究信息缺乏(清晰)呈现是反复出现的问题。
- 部分研究未进行适当统计检验,可能低估显著改善的研究数量。
- 评估主观结局的研究中仅5项使用了经验证的听力相关生活质量量表。
- 仅两项研究评估听觉与主观结局关系且结果相互矛盾。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Cochlear implantation in early-deafened patients, implanted as adolescents or adults, is not always advised due to poor expected outcomes. In order to judge whether such reluctance is justified, the current systematic review aimed to gather all available evidence on postoperative outcomes obtained by early-deafened patients using a state-of-the art cochlear implant (CI). DESIGN: Five electronic databases (PubMed, Embase, the Cochrane library, CINAHL, and PsycInfo) were systematically searched for studies in English, French, German, or Dutch, published between 2000 and September 2017. Studies that reported pre- and postoperative outcomes on any measure of speech or sound perception, audiovisual or subjective benefit (quality of life) were included. Study quality was assessed with the Institute of Health Economics quality appraisal tool for case series studies. RESULTS: The systematic search and subsequent full-text evaluation identified 38 studies meeting the inclusion criteria. Only a limited number of studies were judged to be of high quality according to the Institute of Health Economics tool, with lack of (clear) presentation of relevant study information being a recurring problem. Twenty-five studies presented viable outcomes on open-set speech understanding in quiet: mean postoperative scores obtained with CI remained below 50% for the vast majority of studies; significant postoperative improvements were found in 16 studies, although this number might have been higher if appropriate statistical testing had been performed in all studies. Eight studies observed increased audiovisual performance after implantation, which was statistically significant in six studies. A validated measure of hearing-related quality of life was used in only 5 of the 16 studies assessing subjective outcomes, showing significant postoperative improvements for most questionnaire domains. The relation between auditory and subjective outcomes was assessed in two studies, with contradictory results. CONCLUSIONS: The current review showed that late cochlear implantation in early-deafened subjects resulted in significantly improved open-set speech perception, audiovisual speech perception, and (hearing-related) quality of life in the majority of the studies involved. Nonetheless, more and especially higher-quality research is needed in order to gain a more detailed understanding of the outcomes of cochlear implantation in this population.
引用
- Debruyne JA, Janssen AM, Brokx JPL, et al. Systematic Review on Late Cochlear Implantation in Early-Deafened Adults and Adolescents: Clinical Effectiveness. Ear Hear. 2020. PMID: 33136619. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000884
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。