挽救性全喉切除术后重建的成本效益分析
本研究通过构建马尔可夫决策模型,比较挽救性全喉切除术后一期关闭、胸大肌皮瓣和游离皮瓣三种重建方式的成本效益。结果显示一期关闭成本最低(44370美元)且质量调整生命年最高(0.91),最具成本效益;游离皮瓣优于胸大肌皮瓣(ICER=27025美元/QALY)。结论提示皮瓣重建并非总是最经济的选择。
要点
- 一期关闭在挽救性全喉切除术后最具成本效益。
- 游离皮瓣较胸大肌皮瓣更具成本效益。
- 皮瓣手术长期并发症可能抵消降低瘘率的获益。
核心结论
- 挽救性全喉切除术后采用皮瓣加强关闭并非总是最具成本效益的重建方式。
- 皮瓣手术的长期并发症往往超过降低术后瘘率的获益。
研究设计与样本
- 成本效益分析,构建马尔可夫决策模型比较一期关闭、胸大肌皮瓣和游离皮瓣。
- 模型参数来自原始文献的转移概率和健康效用值,成本基于Medicare计费代码估算。
主要发现
- 基础案例分析显示一期关闭成本为44370美元,获得0.91个QALY。
- 胸大肌皮瓣成本45163美元,获得0.81个QALY;游离皮瓣成本46244美元,获得0.85个QALY。
- 游离皮瓣相对于胸大肌皮瓣的ICER为27025美元/QALY。
- 敏感性分析显示一期关闭在69%的情况下相对于任一皮瓣具有成本效益。
关键数值与推荐
- 在美国,每获得一个QALY的成本低于150000美元(2019年美元)被视为具有成本效益。
- ICER用于比较重建方法的成本效益。
临床怎么用
- 为患者提供重建方案咨询时需仔细考虑,皮瓣重建并非总是最经济的选择。
局限性
- 结论对每种重建方式的健康效用值(生活质量)敏感。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the most cost-effective reconstruction method after salvage total laryngectomy. STUDY DESIGN: Cost-effectiveness analysis. SETTING: Tertiary care hospitals with head and neck oncologic and reconstructive surgeons. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: We constructed a Markov-based decision model to compare reconstruction by primary closure to pectoralis flap and free flap after salvage total laryngectomy. The model simulated disease with transition probabilities and health utilities found in primary literature and estimated the average overall cost of each reconstructive method using Medicare billing codes. Effectiveness was compared using quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). One-way and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed to scrutinize the conclusions of our model. Reconstruction methods were compared using incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs). In the United States, less than $150,000 per QALY gained is considered cost-effective (2019 US dollars). RESULTS: Our base case analysis revealed that primary closure was less expensive ($44,370) and yielded more QALYs (0.91) than both pectoralis ($45,163, 0.81 QALYs) and free flap ($46,244, 0.85 QALYs), making it the most cost-effective option. Between flaps, free flap was cost-effective over pectoralis flap (ICER = $27,025/QALY gained). Sensitivity analyses showed primary closure as cost-effective 69% of the time over either flap. These conclusions were sensitive to the health utilities (quality of life) of each method of reconstruction. CONCLUSION: Tissue flaps to augment closure after salvage total laryngectomy are not always the most cost-effective reconstructive option. The long-term morbidity of flap surgery oftentimes outweighs the benefit of lowering fistula rates after surgery. Careful consideration must be taken when advising patients of their reconstructive options.
引用
- Acevedo JR, Yu JC, Cameron B, et al. Reconstruction After Salvage Total Laryngectomy: A Cost-effectiveness Analysis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2020. PMID: 32660337. doi:10.1177/0194599820936264
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。