乳突切除术气溶胶扩散及耳科手术定制防护策略
研究通过尸头模拟量化乳突皮质钻孔产生的1-10微米气溶胶,并测试两种屏障铺巾及附加吸引的防护效果。无屏障钻孔产生大量颗粒;OtoTent1下颗粒密度显著高于基线,OtoTent2下维持基线;两种铺巾加第二吸引均有效,且第二吸引加暂停移除可防止气溶胶逸出。
要点
- 无屏障乳突钻孔产生大量1-10微米气溶胶,加第二吸引仍产生。
- OtoTent1下钻孔颗粒密度高于基线,OtoTent2下维持基线。
- 第二吸引加暂停60秒移除铺巾可防止气溶胶逸出。
核心结论
- 无屏障乳突钻孔即使加第二吸引仍产生大量1-10微米气溶胶。
- OtoTent1下钻孔气溶胶高于基线,OtoTent2下维持基线。
- 第二吸引加暂停移除可防止两种铺巾移除时气溶胶逸出。
研究设计与样本
- 尸头模拟研究,在手术模拟实验室进行。
- 用光学粒径谱仪在距乳突皮质钻孔30厘米处量化1-10微米气溶胶。
主要发现
- 无屏障铺巾钻孔产生大量1-10微米颗粒。
- OtoTent1下钻孔颗粒密度高于基线环境水平(P < .001,U = 107)。
- OtoTent2下钻孔平均颗粒密度维持基线。
- 移除OtoTent1或OtoTent2时释放显著气溶胶(P < .001,U = 0,n = 10,12;P < .001,U = 2,n = 12,12)。
关键数值与推荐
- OtoTent1或OtoTent2内加第二吸引使颗粒密度维持基线。
- 第二吸引加移除前暂停60秒使颗粒密度不高于基线。
临床怎么用
- 乳突钻孔时应使用屏障铺巾并加第二吸引以减少气溶胶。
- 移除铺巾前应暂停60秒并保持第二吸引以防气溶胶逸出。
局限性
- 研究为尸头模拟,非活体临床环境。
- 仅评估1-10微米气溶胶,未涉及其他粒径或病毒传播直接证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate small-particle aerosolization from mastoidectomy relevant to potential viral transmission and to test source-control mitigation strategies. STUDY DESIGN: Cadaveric simulation. SETTING: Surgical simulation laboratory. METHODS: An optical particle size spectrometer was used to quantify 1- to 10-µm aerosols 30 cm from mastoid cortex drilling. Two barrier drapes were evaluated: OtoTent1, a drape sheet affixed to the microscope; OtoTent2, a custom-structured drape that enclosed the surgical field with specialized ports. RESULTS: Mastoid drilling without a barrier drape, with or without an aerosol-scavenging second suction, generated large amounts of 1- to 10-µm particulate. Drilling under OtoTent1 generated a high density of particles when compared with baseline environmental levels (P < .001, U = 107). By contrast, when drilling was conducted under OtoTent2, mean particle density remained at baseline. Adding a second suction inside OtoTent1 or OtoTent2 kept particle density at baseline levels. Significant aerosols were released upon removal of OtoTent1 or OtoTent2 despite a 60-second pause before drape removal after drilling (P < .001, U = 0, n = 10, 12; P < .001, U = 2, n = 12, 12, respectively). However, particle density did not increase above baseline when a second suction and a pause before removal were both employed. CONCLUSIONS: Mastoidectomy without a barrier, even when a second suction was added, generated substantial 1- to 10-µm aerosols. During drilling, large amounts of aerosols above baseline levels were detected with OtoTent1 but not OtoTent2. For both drapes, a second suction was an effective mitigation strategy during drilling. Last, the combination of a second suction and a pause before removal prevented aerosol escape during the removal of either drape.
引用
- Chari DA, Workman AD, Chen JX, et al. Aerosol Dispersion During Mastoidectomy and Custom Mitigation Strategies for Otologic Surgery in the COVID-19 Era. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2020. PMID: 32660367. doi:10.1177/0194599820941835
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。