连续喉内收肌反射监测与间断神经监测在颈部内分泌手术中的比较
本研究为观察性历史病例对照研究,比较连续喉内收肌反射监测(LAR-CIONM)与间断术中神经监测(intermittent IONM)对颈部内分泌手术中喉返神经损伤的影响。结果显示LAR-CIONM组术后暂时性声带麻痹/声带运动减弱发生率显著低于间断监测组(P = .004),测试获益率比为5.23,相对风险降低81.0%。
要点
- LAR-CIONM可显著降低术后暂时性声带麻痹和声带运动减弱的发生率。
- 间断IONM虽有助于神经定位和术中决策,但对预防神经损伤获益有限。
- 两组各出现1例永久性术后声带麻痹。
核心结论
- LAR-CIONM较间断IONM显著降低术后暂时性声带麻痹和声带运动减弱的发生率(P = .004)。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性历史病例对照研究,单中心、单外科医生。
- 组1为历史队列接受间断IONM监测的130条风险神经。
- 组2为前瞻性连续收集的205条风险神经,接受LAR-CIONM监测。
主要发现
- 组1中9条风险神经出现术中神经信号丢失(LOS),术后暂时性声带运动减弱2条、声带固定7条。
- 组2中2条风险神经(0.98%)在双极电凝后出现突发术中LAR信号丢失,导致术后暂时性声带固定(P = .004)。
- 每组各有1例永久性术后声带固定。
- LAR-CIONM的测试获益率比为5.23,相对风险降低为81.0%。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生应了解间断IONM与连续IONM的获益与局限性。
- 间断IONM可用于神经定位和术中决策,但对预防神经损伤获益有限;CIONM可能降低神经损伤率并改善患者结局。
局限性
- 研究为观察性历史病例对照设计,证据等级为3级。
- 单中心、单外科医生,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Intraoperative neuromonitoring (IONM) techniques aim to identify and potentially prevent nerve injury during surgeries. Prior studies into the efficacy of recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) IONM convey mixed results, with some claiming equivalence between IONM and no monitoring at all. The goal of the current study was to compare continuous RLN monitoring using the laryngeal adductor reflex (LAR) to intermittent RLN monitoring (intermittent IONM) to determine whether continuous monitoring reduces the incidence of intraoperative RLN injury during neck endocrine surgeries. METHODS: In this observational, historical case-control study, a historical cohort of patients monitored with intermittent-IONM (group 1, n = 130) were compared to prospectively collected data from consecutive nerves-at-risk monitored continuously with the LAR (LAR-CIONM, group 2, n = 205), at a single center by a single surgeon. The test benefit ratio and relative risk reduction (RRR) for LAR-CIONM over intermittent IONM were calculated. RESULTS: For group 1, nine nerves at risk exhibited intraoperative LOS with transient postoperative vocal fold (VF) hypomobility (n = 2) or immobility (VFI, n = 7). For group 2, two nerves at risk (0.98%) had sudden intraoperative LAR LOS following bipolar cautery, resulting in postoperative transient VFI (P = .004). In each group, there was one case of permanent postoperative VFI. The test benefit rate ratio for LAR-CIONM demonstrated a dramatic effect at 5.23, with an RRR of 81.0%. CONCLUSION: LAR-CIONM significantly decreased rates of postoperative transient VF paralysis and paresis over intermittent IONM alone (P = .004). Surgeons should be aware of the benefits and limitations of intermittent IONM versus CIONM. Intermittent IONM, although useful in nerve mapping and intraoperative decision making, has minimal benefit for the prevention of nerve injury, whereas CIONM can potentially reduce nerve injury rates and improve patient outcomes. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3 Laryngoscope, 131:230-236, 2021.
引用
- Sinclair CF, Téllez MJ, Ulkatan S, et al. Continuous Laryngeal Adductor Reflex Versus Intermittent Nerve Monitoring in Neck Endocrine Surgery. Laryngoscope. 2020. PMID: 32364626. doi:10.1002/lary.28710
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。