文献速递鼻科小儿耳鼻咽喉

鼻窦炎与鼻炎替代疗法:改良德尔菲法系统综述

Alternative therapies for sinusitis and rhinitis: a systematic review utilizing a modified Delphi method.
PubMed 文献 · Int Forum Allergy Rhinol · 2020-02-27

该研究采用改良德尔菲法,由鼻科专家对鼻窦炎和鼻炎替代疗法的疗效、潜在危害及研究需求达成共识,并据此开展系统文献综述。检索PubMed、EMBASE和Cochrane数据库,纳入2066条题录、220篇相关全文。多数替代疗法几乎无科学证据,针灸、辣椒素、菠萝蛋白酶和蜂斗菜提取物当前证据等级为低至中高。

要点

  • 多数鼻窦炎和鼻炎替代疗法缺乏科学证据支持。
  • 针灸、辣椒素、菠萝蛋白酶和蜂斗菜提取物证据等级为低至中高。
  • 替代疗法多与安慰剂比较,缺乏与传统疗法的对照研究。

核心结论

  • 部分替代疗法显示出作为鼻窦炎和鼻炎潜在治疗的前景,但多与安慰剂比较,缺乏与传统疗法的比较。
  • 许多网站对替代疗法存在无依据的疗效宣称,并忽视潜在副作用。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用改良德尔菲法在鼻科专家间建立共识,经首轮讨论后用Google搜索确定议题并审查在线获益报告。
  • 后续轮次确定检索标准与纳入排除标准,对PubMed、EMBASE和Cochrane数据库进行系统文献综述。
  • 使用CEBM和GRADE标准评估证据等级与推荐强度,最终德尔菲轮次持续至达成共识。

主要发现

  • 共识别出60余种潜在替代疗法。
  • 文献综述纳入2066条题录,其中220篇全文被认为相关。
  • 多数疗法几乎没有科学证据,针灸、辣椒素、菠萝蛋白酶和蜂斗菜提取物当前GRADE评级为低至中高。
  • 过敏性鼻炎是被研究最多的疾病。

关键数值与推荐

  • 针灸、辣椒素、菠萝蛋白酶和蜂斗菜提取物当前具有低至中高GRADE评级。

临床怎么用

  • 临床应告知患者多数替代疗法证据不足,并警惕网站上无依据的获益宣称及被忽视的潜在副作用。
  • 对针灸、辣椒素、菠萝蛋白酶和蜂斗菜提取物可结合低至中高证据等级谨慎讨论其潜在作用。

局限性

  • 多数替代疗法研究证据有限,且主要与安慰剂比较,缺乏与传统疗法的对照研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Sinusitis and rhinitis are common diseases for which patients seek medical attention. Alternative therapies constitute a multibillion-dollar industry despite poorly established efficacy and safety profiles. This study was designed to identify and grade the evidence for alternative therapies purported to treat sinusitis and rhinitis. METHODS: A modified Delphi method was used to establish a consensus opinion among rhinology experts of the current evidence for efficacy, potential harm, and future research needs for alternative therapies in sinusitis and rhinitis. Following the initial Delphi round of discussion, a Google search query was performed to identify topics and review online reports of benefit. Subsequent rounds established search criteria and inclusion/exclusion criteria for a systematic literature review utilizing PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane databases. Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (CEBM) and Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) criteria were used to assess levels of evidence and recommendations. Final Delphi rounds were performed until consensus opinions could be reached. RESULTS: Over 60 potential alternative therapies for sinusitis and rhinitis were identified. The literature review included 2066 titles with 220 full-text articles found to be relevant. Most of the therapies had little to no scientific evidence; however, acupuncture, capsaicin, bromelain, and butterbur extract currently have low to moderate-high GRADE rating. Allergic rhinitis was the most common disease studied. CONCLUSION: Some alternative therapies show promise as potential treatments for sinusitis and rhinitis, mostly compared to placebo. Comparisons to traditional therapies are lacking. For other alternative therapies, many websites included unsubstantiated claims of benefit and ignored potential side effects for which patients should be warned appropriately.

来源:Int Forum Allergy Rhinol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Wu AW, Gettelfinger JD, Ting JY, et al. Alternative therapies for sinusitis and rhinitis: a systematic review utilizing a modified Delphi method. Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2020. PMID: 32104974. doi:10.1002/alr.22488

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。