《致聋人书》:历史上最早对耳聋社会分析的现代意义
本文回顾了19世纪社会学家Harriet Martineau于1834年发表的《致聋人书》,这是最早描述听力损失社会挑战的历史文献。文章指出,Martineau描述的社交孤立、医生不足、音乐欣赏受限和助听设备污名化等问题,在当今社会仍普遍存在。尽管技术进步和对听力损失社会影响的认知改善了听障人士的社交体验,但社会挑战依然存在。
要点
- 《致聋人书》是1834年最早描述听力损失社会挑战的文献。
- 19世纪听障者面临的社交孤立、医生不足、音乐欣赏受限和助听设备污名化等问题至今仍存在。
- 技术进步和认知提升改善了听障者的社交体验,但社会挑战仍需克服。
核心结论
- 尽管技术进步和认知提升改善了听障者的社交体验,但《致聋人书》中描述的社会挑战在当今仍具有相关性。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为历史文献综述,回顾了Harriet Martineau于1834年发表的《致聋人书》一文。
主要发现
- Martineau详细描述了19世纪听障者经历的复杂情境,包括因沟通挫折导致的社交孤立、医生不足、音乐欣赏受限和助听设备污名化。
- 这些体验在当今听障者中仍普遍存在。
- 技术进步和对听力损失负面社会影响的认知改善了听障者的社交体验,但社会挑战依然存在。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应认识到听力损失的社会挑战(如社交孤立、污名化)在当今仍普遍存在,需关注听障者的社会心理体验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Harriet Martineau was a 19th-century sociologist who had a progressive form of deafness. Her 1834 essay, Letters to the Deaf, was the earliest historical document depicting the social challenges of hearing loss. Martineau details complex situations that hard-of-hearing people experienced in the 19th century such as social isolation due to frustrations with communication, physician shortcomings, limited music appreciation, and the stigma of hearing amplification devices. Her descriptions of these experiences are commonly faced by hard-of-hearing people in present-day society. Advancements in technology and recognition of the negative social impact of hearing loss have improved the social experience for the hard of hearing; however, social challenges remain relevant. In this article, we review Letters to the Deaf and note the ways in which this essay provides a dual perspective regarding how much we have advanced as a society and how much we still have to overcome in addressing the social challenges of hearing loss.
引用
- Naples J, Valdez TA. Letters to the Deaf: Present-Day Relevance of History's Earliest Social Analysis of Deafness. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2020. PMID: 31959057. doi:10.1177/0194599819900492
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。