文献速递鼻科

呼气递送系统与常规鼻喷或大容量冲洗在Draf II/III术后鼻腔鼻窦的药物沉积比较

Deposition of drugs in the nose and sinuses with an exhalation delivery system vs conventional nasal spray or high-volume irrigation in Draf II/III post-surgical anatomy.
PubMed 文献 · Rhinology · 2020-01-01

本研究利用3D打印硅胶模型(基于Draf II及Draf III术后患者的高分辨率CT数据)比较了常规鼻喷、呼气递送系统(EDS)和大容量低流量(HVLF)冲洗在鼻腔鼻窦的药物沉积。结果显示常规鼻喷仅沉积于鼻前段,EDS可深入鼻腔及手术开放的筛窦、上颌窦,在Draf III中可达额窦;HVLF在45°倾斜时进入上颌窦但不达额窦或筛区,90°倾斜时可达大部分额窦和上颌窦但筛顶及后壁不足。

要点

  • 常规鼻喷术后仅沉积于鼻前段,难以到达开放鼻窦。
  • EDS可深入鼻腔及手术开放的筛窦、上颌窦,Draf III中可达额窦。
  • HVLF冲洗90°倾斜可达大部分额窦和上颌窦,但筛顶和后壁不足。

核心结论

  • 与常规鼻喷相比,HVLF和EDS在硅胶模型中均产生深部鼻腔/鼻窦沉积,且均能沉积于手术开放的鼻窦内。
  • HVLF具有冲洗的优势,而EDS可能更高效和便捷。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于一例Draf II及Draf III术后患者的高分辨率CT数据,3D打印硅胶鼻腔鼻窦模型,内表面涂覆液体敏感变色凝胶。
  • 比较常规鼻喷(0.1 mL×2,Nasonex)、EDS(0.1 mL×2,XHANCE)和HVLF(80 mL)在头部倾斜45°或90°时的沉积情况。

主要发现

  • 常规鼻喷仅在鼻前段沉积液体。
  • EDS使液体分布于整个鼻腔、手术开放的筛窦和上颌窦、Draf II中额窦入口处以及Draf III中额窦内。
  • 45°倾斜HVLF进入上颌窦但不进入额窦或筛区;90°倾斜HVLF到达大部分额窦和上颌窦,但未达筛顶和后壁。

临床怎么用

  • 对于Draf II/III术后患者,若需药物深入开放鼻窦,EDS或HVLF可能优于常规鼻喷。
  • 选择HVLF时可考虑90°倾斜以增加额窦和上颌窦沉积,但筛顶和后壁覆盖仍有限。

局限性

  • 研究基于单例患者的硅胶模型,非人体在体研究。
  • 模型可能无法完全模拟活体鼻腔鼻窦的黏膜、纤毛及气流等生理条件。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Endoscopic sinus surgery is often performed to improve delivery of topical medication into sinus cavities. Intranasal steroids are guideline recommended in post-surgical patients, and experiments with cadavers suggest that surgery improves delivery of drug into sinuses. Exhalation delivery systems (EDS) use a new mechanism for intranasal delivery and have been shown to reach superior/posterior regions of the nasal cavity better than nasal sprays in unoperated patients. METHODS: Silicone casts of the nasal cavity and sinuses from a patient after Draf II, and then Draf III, were made from high-resolution computed tomography (CT) data using 3D printing. Internal surfaces were coated with liquid-sensitive, color-changing gel. Color changes were evaluated following conventional nasal spray delivery (0.1 mL x 2) (Nasonex), EDS delivery (0.1 mL x 2) (XHANCE), and high-volume, low-flow (HVLF) delivery (80 mL) with head tilted either 45° or 90°. RESULTS: Conventional nasal spray deposited liquid only in anterior nasal segments. EDS deposited liquid throughout the nasal cavity, in surgically opened ethmoid and maxillary spaces, at entrances of the frontal sinuses in Draf II geometry, and into frontal sinuses in Draf III. Tilted 45° HVLF delivery enters the maxillary sinuses but not the frontal sinuses or the ethmoid region. At full 90° inclination, HVLF delivery reaches most of the frontal and maxillary sinuses but not the roof and posterior wall of the ethmoid region. CONCLUSIONS: HVLF and EDS produced a deep intranasal/intrasinal deposition in the silicone cast compared with conventional nasal spray delivery; both deposited liquid inside the surgically opened sinuses. HVLF offers the benefit of lavage, whereas EDS may be more efficient and convenient.

来源:Rhinology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Djupesland PG, Messina JC, Palmer JN, et al. Deposition of drugs in the nose and sinuses with an exhalation delivery system vs conventional nasal spray or high-volume irrigation in Draf II/III post-surgical anatomy. Rhinology. 2020. PMID: 31813944. doi:10.4193/Rhin18.304

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。