重路由助听系统在动态聆听中克服模拟单侧听损
结果显示两种系统仅在对侧或中线特定方位有小幅识别获益,仅CROS在约6.5个百分点上改善整体理解。
要点
- CROS仅对患侧方向言语识别及整体理解有小幅获益。
- RM仅改善中线信号识别,未改善整体理解。
- 两种系统对健侧方向信号识别均有负面影响。
核心结论
- CROS和RM系统均为非手术干预,在动态噪声教室情境中对模拟单侧听损儿童有改善言语识别和理解的潜力。
- 本研究中CROS的获益较小,仅针对言语指向患侧耳的情境,且仅与使用单一麦克风的RM系统相比。
研究设计与样本
- 通过插入式耳机向单耳播放言语谱掩蔽噪声模拟单侧听损。
- 言语刺激来自0°、±45°、±90°、±135°方位的扬声器, cafeteria噪声从周围扬声器播放。
- 测试条件包括未助听、RM系统(麦克风置于前方扬声器附近)和CROS系统(患侧耳级麦克风)。
- 任务包括句子识别和听陌生故事后回答问题(理解)。
主要发现
- 与未助听相比,两种系统在大多数健侧耳附近信号(单耳直接扬声器)下均降低句子识别成绩。
- 仅RM系统改善中线信号(靠近RM)的言语识别。
- 仅CROS系统显著改善患侧耳附近信号(单耳间接扬声器)的言语识别。
- CROS系统还改善理解分数(反映全部四个扬声器的整体聆听),获益一般较小(约6.5个百分点)。
- RM系统相对于未助听未改善理解分数。
关键数值与推荐
- CROS系统理解获益约6.5个百分点。
- CROS系统显著改善患侧耳附近信号的言语识别。
- RM系统仅改善中线信号的言语识别。
临床怎么用
- 对于单侧听损儿童,CROS系统可能有助于言语指向患侧耳时的识别和整体理解。
- RM系统需将麦克风靠近目标说话者才能改善中线信号识别。
- 两种系统在健侧耳直接聆听时可能降低识别成绩,选配时需考虑方向性影响。
局限性
- 研究为实验室环境,使用正常听力儿童模拟单侧听损,可能限制外推性。
- CROS获益仅与使用单一麦克风的RM系统比较,未与其他干预比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Unilateral hearing loss increases the risk of academic and behavioral challenges for school-aged children. Previous research suggests that remote microphone (RM) systems offer the most consistent benefits for children with unilateral hearing loss in classroom environments relative to other nonsurgical interventions. However, generalizability of previous laboratory work is limited because of the specific listening situations evaluated, which often included speech and noise signals originating from the side. In addition, early studies focused on speech recognition tasks requiring limited cognitive engagement. However, those laboratory conditions do not reflect characteristics of contemporary classrooms, which are cognitively demanding and typically include multiple talkers of interest in relatively diffuse background noise. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the potential effects of rerouting amplification systems, specifically a RM system and a contralateral routing of signal (CROS) system, on speech recognition and comprehension of school-age children in a laboratory environment designed to emulate the dynamic characteristics of contemporary classrooms. It was expected that listeners would benefit from the CROS system when the head shadow limits audibility (e.g., monaural indirect listening). It was also expected that listeners would benefit from the RM system only when the RM was near the talker of interest. DESIGN: Twenty-one children (10 to 14 years, M = 11.86) with normal hearing participated in laboratory tests of speech recognition and comprehension. Unilateral hearing loss was simulated by presenting speech-shaped masking noise to one ear via an insert earphone. Speech stimuli were presented from 1 of 4 loudspeakers located at either 0°, +45°, -90°, and -135° or 0°, -45°, +90°, and +135°. Cafeteria noise was presented from separate loudspeakers surrounding the listener. Participants repeated sentences (sentence recognition) and also answered questions after listening to an unfamiliar story (comprehension). They were tested unaided, with a RM system (microphone near the front loudspeaker), and with a CROS system (ear-level microphone on the ear with simulated hearing loss). RESULTS: Relative to unaided listening, both rerouting systems reduced sentence recognition performance for most signals originating near the ear with normal hearing (monaural direct loudspeakers). Only the RM system improved speech recognition for midline signals, which were near the RM. Only the CROS system significantly improved speech recognition for signals originating near the ear with simulated hearing loss (monaural indirect loudspeakers). Although the benefits were generally small (approximately 6.5 percentage points), the CROS system also improved comprehension scores, which reflect overall listening across all four loudspeakers. Conversely, the RM system did not improve comprehension scores relative to unaided listening. CONCLUSIONS: Benefits of the CROS system in this study were small, specific to situations where speech is directed toward the ear with hearing loss, and relative only to a RM system utilizing one microphone. Although future study is warranted to evaluate the generalizability of the findings, the data demonstrate both CROS and RM systems are nonsurgical interventions that have the potential to improve speech recognition and comprehension for children with limited useable unilateral hearing in dynamic, noisy classroom situations.
引用
- Picou EM, Lewis D, Angley G, et al. Rerouting Hearing Aid Systems for Overcoming Simulated Unilateral Hearing in Dynamic Listening Situations. Ear Hear. 2020. PMID: 31584502. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000800
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。