文献速递耳科与耳神经

声学耳语音可干扰单侧聋人工耳蜗使用者的言语感知

Acoustic Hearing Can Interfere With Single-Sided Deafness Cochlear-Implant Speech Perception.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2020-01-01

本研究探讨单侧聋人工耳蜗(SSD-CI)使用者在多说话者场景中,声学耳竞争语音是否干扰人工耳蜗耳的言语理解。实验1对13名SSD-CI使用者测量人工耳蜗耳在竞争语音或噪声下的言语理解,声学耳呈现静音或竞争语音副本。结果显示,当竞争语音呈现于声学耳时,人工耳蜗耳言语理解分数在目标-掩蔽比≥4 dB时下降,且干扰效应仅见于竞争语音条件,个体差异大并与年龄相关。反向配置(实验2)则显示对侧人工耳蜗耳呈现竞争语音可改善声学耳表现。

要点

  • SSD-CI使用者关注人工耳蜗耳时,声学耳竞争语音可干扰言语理解。
  • 干扰效应在目标-掩蔽比≥4 dB时出现,且仅见于竞争语音而非噪声。
  • 干扰程度个体差异大(1-43 RAU),与年龄相关,年长者更易受干扰。

核心结论

  • 多数SSD-CI使用者在关注人工耳蜗耳且声学耳加入竞争语音时出现干扰,但个体差异大,年长者更易受影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 实验1:13名SSD-CI使用者,测量人工耳蜗耳在竞争语音或噪声下的言语理解,声学耳呈现静音或竞争语音副本。
  • 实验2:6名使用者的反向配置测试,目标与竞争语音呈现于声学耳,人工耳蜗耳呈现静音或竞争语音。
  • 实验3:检验竞争说话者关键词是否在响应集内的方法学差异影响。

主要发现

  • 实验1:声学耳呈现竞争语音副本使人工耳蜗耳言语理解分数在目标-掩蔽比≥4 dB时降低。
  • 干扰效应仅见于竞争语音条件,噪声掩蔽未观察到。
  • 干扰幅度个体间差异大(范围1至43 rationalized arcsine units),与年龄显著相关。
  • 实验2:对侧人工耳蜗耳呈现竞争语音副本较单耳声学耳表现显著改善。
  • 实验3:关键词条件未影响观察到的干扰模式。

临床怎么用

  • 对于SSD-CI使用者,在多说话者场景中需注意声学耳竞争语音可能干扰人工耳蜗耳言语理解。
  • 年长SSD-CI使用者可能更易受对侧语音干扰,调试或康复时可考虑此因素。

局限性

  • 需进一步研究自由场聆听条件下的效应。
  • 干扰幅度个体差异大,样本量有限。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Cochlear implants (CIs) restore some spatial advantages for speech understanding in noise to individuals with single-sided deafness (SSD). In addition to a head-shadow advantage when the CI ear has a better signal-to-noise ratio, a CI can also provide a binaural advantage in certain situations, facilitating the perceptual separation of spatially separated concurrent voices. While some bilateral-CI listeners show a similar binaural advantage, bilateral-CI listeners with relatively large asymmetries in monaural speech understanding can instead experience contralateral speech interference. Based on the interference previously observed for asymmetric bilateral-CI listeners, this study tested the hypothesis that in a multiple-talker situation, the acoustic ear would interfere with rather than improve CI speech understanding for SSD-CI listeners. DESIGN: Experiment 1 measured CI-ear speech understanding in the presence of competing speech or noise for 13 SSD-CI listeners. Target speech from the closed-set coordinate response-measure corpus was presented to the CI ear along with one same-gender competing talker or stationary noise at target-to-masker ratios between -8 and 20 dB. The acoustic ear was presented with silence (monaural condition) or with a copy of the competing speech or noise (bilateral condition). Experiment 2 tested a subset of 6 listeners in the reverse configuration for which SSD-CI listeners have previously shown a binaural benefit (target and competing speech presented to the acoustic ear; silence or competing speech presented to the CI ear). Experiment 3 examined the possible influence of a methodological difference between experiments 1 and 2: whether the competing talker spoke keywords that were inside or outside the response set. For each experiment, the data were analyzed using repeated-measures logistic regression. For experiment 1, a correlation analysis compared the difference between bilateral and monaural speech-understanding scores to several listener-specific factors: speech understanding in the CI ear, preimplantation duration of deafness, duration of CI experience, ear of deafness (left/right), acoustic-ear audiometric thresholds, and listener age. RESULTS: In experiment 1, presenting a copy of the competing speech to the acoustic ear reduced CI speech-understanding scores for target-to-masker ratios ≥4 dB. This interference effect was limited to competing-speech conditions and was not observed for a noise masker. There was dramatic intersubject variability in the magnitude of the interference (range: 1 to 43 rationalized arcsine units), which was found to be significantly correlated with listener age. The interference effect contrasted sharply with the reverse configuration (experiment 2), whereby presenting a copy of the competing speech to the contralateral CI ear significantly improved performance relative to monaural acoustic-ear performance. Keyword condition (experiment 3) did not influence the observed pattern of interference. CONCLUSIONS: Most SSD-CI listeners experienced interference when they attended to the CI ear and competing speech was added to the acoustic ear, although there was a large amount of intersubject variability in the magnitude of the effect, with older listeners particularly susceptible to interference. While further research is needed to investigate these effects under free-field listening conditions, these results suggest that for certain spatial configurations in a multiple-talker situation, contralateral speech interference could reduce the benefit that an SSD-CI otherwise provides.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bernstein JGW, Stakhovskaya OA, Jensen KK, et al. Acoustic Hearing Can Interfere With Single-Sided Deafness Cochlear-Implant Speech Perception. Ear Hear. 2020. PMID: 31584504. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000805

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。