VHI-10是否比常见临床问诊更能预测喉镜/频闪喉镜检查结果?
前瞻性纳入204例新就诊的喉科门诊患者,完成VHI-10及16项嗓音特征问诊,以喉镜/频闪喉镜诊断为金标准计算AUC、敏感度和特异度。VHI-10对单侧声带麻痹和喉狭窄的诊断判别力优于多项常见问诊,但对声带轻瘫、LPR、反常声带运动及声带瘢痕或萎缩的诊断能力均有限。
要点
- VHI-10对单侧声带麻痹的AUC为0.78,优于12项常见临床问诊。
- VHI-10对喉狭窄的AUC为0.79,优于3项常见临床问诊。
- VHI-10与常见问诊对声带轻瘫、LPR、反常声带运动及声带瘢痕/萎缩诊断能力均低。
核心结论
- VHI-10是喉镜/频闪喉镜发现声带麻痹和喉狭窄的有效诊断指标,表现优于多项主流嗓音特征问诊。
- VHI-10和常见临床问诊对声带轻瘫、反流、反常声带运动及声带瘢痕或萎缩的指示能力有限。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,连续纳入204例新就诊于门诊喉科评估的患者。
- 每例患者完成VHI-10及16项关于嗓音特征(如无力、气息声、易疲劳或无法喊叫)的主流问诊。
- 以喉镜/频闪喉镜客观诊断为金标准,计算AUC、敏感度和特异度。
主要发现
- 单侧声带麻痹:VHI-10的AUC为0.78(95%CI 0.68-0.88),判别力优于12项常见临床问诊。
- 喉狭窄:VHI-10的AUC为0.79(95%CI 0.56-1.00),判别力优于3项常见临床问诊。
- VHI-10和常见临床问诊对声带轻瘫、LPR、反常声带运动及声带瘢痕或萎缩的诊断能力均低。
关键数值与推荐
- 单侧声带麻痹:VHI-10阈值≥11时敏感度为0.94;阈值≥31时特异度为0.91。
- 喉狭窄:VHI-10阈值≥11时敏感度为1.00;阈值≥31时特异度为0.89。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考VHI-10评分辅助判断喉镜/频闪喉镜发现声带麻痹或喉狭窄的可能性,但需结合客观检查。
- 对声带轻瘫、LPR、反常声带运动及声带瘢痕或萎缩,不应仅依赖VHI-10或常见问诊进行诊断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To determine whether the Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) predicts diagnoses made via laryngoscopy/stroboscopy, as compared to common clinical inquiries about vocal characteristics. METHODS: We prospectively collected data from a cohort of 204 consecutive patients newly presenting for ambulatory laryngology evaluation. Each patient completed the VHI-10 and 16 concurrent mainstream queries about vocal characteristics such as weakness, breathiness, fatiguability, or inability to shout. Using the objective diagnoses made by laryngoscopy/stroboscopy as a gold standard, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curves (AUC), sensitivity, and specificity were determined. RESULTS: For unilateral vocal fold paralysis, VHI-10 scores had an AUC of 0.78 (95% CI, 0.68-0.88) and had better discrimination than 12 common clinical queries. At a threshold score of ≥11, VHI-10 sensitivity was 0.94; at a threshold of ≥31, specificity was 0.91. For laryngeal stenosis, the VHI-10 score demonstrated moderate discrimination, with an AUC of 0.79 (95% CI, 0.56-1.00) and higher discrimination than three common clinical queries. At a threshold score of ≥11, VHI-10 sensitivity was 1.00; at a threshold of ≥31, specificity was 0.89. Both VHI-10 scores and common clinical queries had low diagnostic ability for vocal fold paresis, laryngopharyngeal reflux (LPR), paradoxical vocal fold motion, and vocal fold scar or atrophy. CONCLUSIONS: The VHI-10 score is an effective diagnostic indicator of laryngoscopy/stroboscopy findings of vocal fold paralysis and laryngeal stenosis, performing better than multiple mainstream queries about vocal characteristics. VHI-10 scores and common clinical queries are limited in their ability to indicate paresis, reflux, paradoxical motion, and vocal fold scar or atrophy. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2c Laryngoscope, 130:992-999, 2020.
引用
- DeVore EK, Carroll TL, Shin JJ, et al. Is a voice-specific instrument more indicative of stroboscopy results than common clinical queries? Laryngoscope. 2019. PMID: 31418872. doi:10.1002/lary.28207
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。