文献速递耳科与耳神经

双耳聆听提升音乐享受:即使一耳为人工耳蜗降级信号

Music Is More Enjoyable With Two Ears, Even If One of Them Receives a Degraded Signal Provided By a Cochlear Implant.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2020-01-01

本研究以单侧耳聋伴人工耳蜗(SSD-CI)患者为对象,采用改良MUSHRA方法评估音乐享受度,发现仅CI电刺激的音乐享受度极低(平均20),但CI电刺激与对侧正常听力耳声刺激结合时享受度(平均123)高于仅声刺激;正常听力者双耳相同信号享受度更高(平均159),而声码器模拟则产生干扰。

要点

  • CI单耳电刺激音乐享受度极低,平均评分20(以正常耳100为参照)。
  • CI电刺激联合对侧正常耳声刺激可提升音乐享受度至平均123,优于仅声刺激。
  • 正常听力者双耳相同信号享受度平均159,但声码器模拟则产生干扰而非增强。

核心结论

  • CI电刺激的音乐享受度远低于正常听力基线,但CI与对侧正常耳声刺激结合可增强音乐享受度。
  • CI-SSD患者的双耳增强效应占正常听力者双耳增强的相当大比例。

研究设计与样本

  • 实验1:SSD-CI用户,改良MUSHRA法,0-200评分,100为正常耳参考,0为高度降级版本,200为两倍优于参考。
  • 实验2:正常听力者接受声码器刺激替代电刺激,重复实验1任务。
  • 实验3:正常听力者测试向第二耳添加相同未修改歌曲片段的效果。

主要发现

  • 仅CI电刺激音乐享受度平均评分20。
  • CI电刺激联合对侧声刺激享受度平均123,高于仅声刺激。
  • 正常听力者双耳相同信号享受度平均159,高于单耳。
  • 正常听力者一耳声码器刺激产生干扰而非增强。

临床怎么用

  • 对于SSD-CI患者,双耳聆听(CI+对侧正常耳)可改善音乐享受度。
  • 声码器模拟不能替代电刺激研究双耳音乐享受。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Cochlear implants (CIs) restore speech perception in quiet but they also eliminate or distort many acoustic cues that are important for music enjoyment. Unfortunately, quantifying music enjoyment by CI users has been difficult because comparisons must rely on their recollection of music before they lost their hearing. Here, we aimed to assess music enjoyment in CI users using a readily interpretable reference based on acoustic hearing. The comparison was done by testing "single-sided deafness" (SSD) patients who have normal hearing (NH) in one ear and a CI in the other ear. The study also aimed to assess binaural musical enjoyment, with the reference being the experience of hearing with a single NH ear. Three experiments assessed the effect of adding different kinds of input to the second ear: electrical, vocoded, or unmodified. DESIGN: In experiment 1, music enjoyment in SSD-CI users was investigated using a modified version of the MUSHRA (MUltiple Stimuli with Hidden Reference and Anchor) method. Listeners rated their enjoyment of song segments on a scale of 0 to 200, where 100 represented the enjoyment obtained from a song segment presented to the NH ear, 0 represented a highly degraded version of the same song segment presented to the same ear, and 200 represented enjoyment subjectively rated as twice as good as the 100 reference. Stimuli consisted of acoustic only, electric only, acoustic and electric, as well as other conditions with low pass filtered acoustic stimuli. Acoustic stimulation was provided by headphone to the NH ear and electric stimulation was provided by direct audio input to the subject's speech processor. In experiment 2, the task was repeated using NH listeners who received vocoded stimuli instead of electric stimuli. Experiment 3 tested the effect of adding the same unmodified song segment to the second ear, also in NH listeners. RESULTS: Music presented through the CI only was very unpleasant, with an average rating of 20. Surprisingly, the combination of the unpleasant CI signal in one ear with acoustic stimulation in the other ear was rated more enjoyable (mean = 123) than acoustic processing alone. Presentation of the same monaural musical signal to both ears in NH listeners resulted with even greater enhancement of the experience compared with presentation to a single ear (mean = 159). Repeating the experiment using a vocoder to one ear of NH listeners resulted in interference rather than enhancement. CONCLUSIONS: Music enjoyment from electric stimulation is extremely poor relative to a readily interpretable NH baseline for CI-SSD listeners. However, the combination of this unenjoyable signal presented through a CI and an unmodified acoustic signal presented to a NH (or near-NH) contralateral ear results in enhanced music enjoyment with respect to the acoustic signal alone. Remarkably, this two-ear enhancement experienced by CI-SSD listeners represents a substantial fraction of the two-ear enhancement seen in NH listeners. This unexpected benefit of electroacoustic auditory stimulation will have to be considered in theoretical accounts of music enjoyment and may facilitate the quest to enhance music enjoyment in CI users.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Landsberger DM, Vermeire K, Stupak N, et al. Music Is More Enjoyable With Two Ears, Even If One of Them Receives a Degraded Signal Provided By a Cochlear Implant. Ear Hear. 2020. PMID: 31469701. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000771

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。