病史准确性是否影响视频喉频闪喉镜检查的解读?
该研究探讨初始诊断假设对临床医生识别异常、判断严重程度、临床印象及治疗建议的影响。32名语音障碍领域的言语语言病理学家和耳鼻咽喉科医生在解读视频喉频闪喉镜检查前阅读病史,病史提示准确或不准确的特定喉部诊断,或正常喉部对照。结果显示,病史提示的异常会显著增加相关视觉感知参数的严重程度评分;当病史与检查一致时,临床印象的总体一致性从49%提升至72%;提示语音症状的病史(无论准确与否)可预测治疗建议,且独立于视频喉频闪喉镜表现本身(P<0.001)。
要点
- 病史提示的异常会显著增加后部喉外观(P<0.05)和黏膜波(P<0.02)的感知严重程度。
- 当病史与检查一致时,临床印象的总体一致性从49%提升至72%。
- 提示语音症状的病史(准确或不准确)可预测治疗建议,且独立于视频喉频闪喉镜表现(P<0.001)。
核心结论
- 病史提示特定异常会显著影响三个主要结局视觉感知参数中两个的严重程度评分。
- 准确的病史提示特定异常会增加异常检测的概率和感知严重程度。
- 不准确的病史会导致假阳性发现以及未能检测或低估异常。
- 病史影响视觉感知判断,并影响临床印象和治疗决策。
研究设计与样本
- 32名专攻语音障碍的经验丰富的言语语言病理学家和耳鼻咽喉科医生在解读视频喉频闪喉镜检查前阅读病史。
- 病史提示准确的特定喉部诊断、不准确的特定喉部诊断,或提示正常喉部的对照场景。
- 研究检查了病史准确性对相关视觉感知参数的感知严重程度、临床印象和治疗建议的影响。
主要发现
- 当病史提示这些异常时,后部喉外观的感知严重程度显著增加(P<0.05)。
- 当病史提示这些异常时,黏膜波的感知严重程度显著增加(P<0.02)。
- 当病史与检查一致时,临床印象的总体一致性从49%提升至72%。
- 提示语音症状的病史(准确和不准确)预测治疗建议,且超出视频喉频闪喉镜表现本身(P<0.001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the effect of initial diagnostic hypotheses on clinicians' 1) detection and perceived severity of abnormalities, and 2) clinical impressions and treatment recommendations for individuals with and without voice disorders following interpretation of videolaryngostroboscopy (VLS). METHODS: Thirty-two experienced speech-language pathologists and otolaryngologists specializing in voice disorders read case histories prior to interpreting exams. Case histories suggested specific accurate or inaccurate laryngeal diagnoses, or a control scenario that suggested a normal larynx. The effects of the accuracy of case histories on perceived severity of associated visual-perceptual parameters, clinical impressions, and treatment recommendations were examined. RESULTS: Significant increases in perceived severity of posterior laryngeal appearance (P < 0.05) and mucosal wave (P < 0.02) were observed when these abnormalities were suggested by case histories. Overall agreement with clinical impressions improved from 49% to 72% when the case history was consistent with the examination. Case histories (accurate and inaccurate) indicating voice symptoms predicted recommendations for treatment above and beyond that of VLS presentation alone, P < 0.001. CONCLUSION: Case histories suggesting specific abnormalities significantly affected severity ratings for two of three associated visual-perceptual parameters selected as primary outcome measures. Accurate case histories suggesting specific abnormalities increased the probability of detection and perceived severity. Inaccurate case histories led to false-positive findings and failures to detect abnormalities or to interpret them as less severe. Case histories affected visual-perceptual judgments and contributed to decisions about clinical impressions and treatment. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2b Laryngoscope, 130:718-725, 2020.
引用
- Sauder C, Nevdahl M, Kapsner-Smith M, et al. Does the accuracy of case history affect interpretation of videolaryngostroboscopic exams? Laryngoscope. 2019. PMID: 31124157. doi:10.1002/lary.28081
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。