文献速递鼻科

全静脉麻醉与吸入麻醉在内镜鼻窦手术中的比较:一项Meta分析

Total intravenous versus inhalational anesthesia in endoscopic sinus surgery: A meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Laryngoscope · 2019-05-03

该Meta分析仅纳入随机对照试验,比较全静脉麻醉(TIVA)与吸入麻醉(IA)在内镜鼻窦手术(ESS)中对术野可见度、失血量等指标的影响。共纳入15项RCT、828例ESS病例,其中TIVA组391例(47%)、IA组437例(53%)。汇总分析显示TIVA在10分法和5分法评分上术野可见度均显著优于IA,失血量显著更少,而术中心率、平均动脉压、手术时间和麻醉时间两组间无显著差异。作者认为TIVA可能带来更优的术野可见度和更少失血,但存在显著异质性,需谨慎解读。

要点

  • TIVA组术野可见度评分显著优于IA组(10分法P=0.049、P=0.009;5分法P=0.002)。
  • TIVA组失血量显著少于IA组(P=0.003)。
  • 术中心率、平均动脉压、手术时间和麻醉时间两组间无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 该Meta分析提示,在ESS中TIVA可能较IA带来更优的术野可见度并减少术中失血量。
  • 目前该Meta分析存在显著的异质性顾虑,削弱了任一方法绝对优于另一方的预期。
  • 在获得进一步验证之前应谨慎解读这些结果。

研究设计与样本

  • 遵循PRISMA推荐指南进行的Meta分析,仅纳入随机对照试验(RCT)。
  • 检索电子数据库自建库至2018年9月,初筛得到157篇文章。
  • 最终纳入15项符合选择标准的RCT,共描述828例ESS病例。

主要发现

  • 828例ESS病例中,TIVA组391例(47%),IA组437例(53%)。
  • 基于10分评分法,TIVA术野可见度评分显著优于IA(视觉模拟量表P=0.049;Wormald量表P=0.009)。
  • 基于5分评分法(Boezaart量表),TIVA术野可见度评分显著优于IA(P=0.002)。
  • TIVA组失血量显著少于IA组(P=0.003)。
  • 术中心率(P=0.70)、平均动脉压(P=0.96)、手术时间(P=0.16)和麻醉时间(P=0.39)两组间无显著差异。

局限性

  • 该Meta分析目前存在显著的异质性顾虑,削弱了任一方法绝对优于另一方的预期。
  • 在获得进一步验证之前应谨慎解读这些结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Achieving optimal intraoperative surgical field visibility and minimizing blood loss are two important parameters in endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS). The aim of this meta-analysis was to compare two total intravenous anesthesia (TIVA) and inhalational anesthesia (IA) to determine if either conferred superior outcomes of these and other parameters based on randomized control trials (RCTs) only. METHODS: The recommended Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were followed, and searches of electronic databases from inception to September 2018 identified 157 articles for screening. Data were extracted and analyzed using meta-analysis of proportions. RESULTS: In total, we identified 15 RCTs that satisfied our selection criteria. There were 828 ESS cases described, with 391 (47%) and 437 (53%) being managed by TIVA and IA, respectively. Pooled analysis demonstrated significantly superior visibility scores for TIVA compared to IA based on 10-point grading scores (P = 0.049, visual analog scale; P = 0.009, Wormald scale) and 5-point grading scores (P = 0.002, Boezaart scale). Blood loss was significantly less following TIVA (P = 0.003), with no significant difference in intraoperative heart rate (P = 0.70) or mean arterial pressure (P = 0.96). Additionally, duration of surgery (P = 0.16) and anesthesia (P = 0.39) were comparable between the two approaches. CONCLUSION: This meta-analysis indicates that TIVA has the potential to confer superior surgical field visibility and reduce intraoperative blood loss compared to IA in ESS. Currently, there are significant heterogeneity concerns in this meta-analysis, which temper any expectations that either approach is absolutely superior to the other. Caution should be exercised when interpreting these results until further validation can be achieved. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 1A Laryngoscope, 130:575-583, 2020.

来源:Laryngoscope,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lu VM, Phan K, Oh LJ, et al. Total intravenous versus inhalational anesthesia in endoscopic sinus surgery: A meta-analysis. Laryngoscope. 2019. PMID: 31050818. doi:10.1002/lary.28046

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。