文献速递耳科与耳神经

Advanced Bionics 人工耳蜗使用者电诱发复合动作电位阈值的重测变异性

Test/Retest Variability of the eCAP Threshold in Advanced Bionics Cochlear Implant Users.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2019-01-01

该研究为无掩蔽、描述性、观察性交叉重复测量设计,纳入 13 名 Advanced Bionics 人工耳蜗使用者,在耳蜗底、中、顶三个电极触点、10 个刺激强度下记录电诱发复合动作电位(eCAP),以蒙特卡洛模拟计算 eCAP 阈值精密度。结果显示,波形平均次数加倍时 eCAP 阈值标准差约降至原来的二分之一平方根;在 Advanced Bionics 系统默认 32 次平均下,eCAP 阈值标准差中位数为 2 至 3 μA,全耳蜗范围 1 至 11 μA。

要点

  • eCAP 阈值标准差随平均次数加倍约按二分之一平方根降低。
  • 默认 32 次平均下 eCAP 阈值标准差中位数为 2 至 3 μA,范围 1 至 11 μA。
  • 交替刺激极性平均(AP averaging)的精密度优于前向掩蔽(FM)。

核心结论

  • eCAP 阈值的中位变异性相对于线性外推法引入的总变异性较小,但受试者间变异性较大。
  • 作者建议在 eCAP 记录过程中监测标准差,以便有依据地决定何时终止波形采集。
  • 从精密度角度看,交替刺激极性平均(AP averaging)优于前向掩蔽(FM),且所需记录次数更少,是两者中更省时的方法。

研究设计与样本

  • 无掩蔽、描述性、观察性研究,采用交叉(重复测量)设计,纳入 13 名受试者。
  • 在耳蜗底、中、顶三个电极触点、10 个刺激强度下记录 eCAP,每个刺激强度记录 256 个 eCAP 波形。
  • 通过构建幅度增长函数(AGF)并线性外推至零振幅来确定 eCAP 阈值。
  • 采用蒙特卡洛模拟计算 eCAP 阈值的精密度,以标准差表示,并作为波形平均次数的函数。

主要发现

  • eCAP 波形平均次数加倍时,eCAP 阈值标准差约降至原来的二分之一平方根。
  • AGF 斜率越陡,精密度显著越好;耳蜗底的精密度优于耳蜗顶。
  • 使用交替刺激极性平均(AP averaging)时精密度更好。
  • 绝对 eCAP 阈值对精密度无显著影响。
  • 在 Advanced Bionics 系统默认 32 次波形平均下,eCAP 阈值标准差中位数为 2 至 3 μA,全耳蜗范围为 1 至 11 μA。

关键数值与推荐

  • 在 Advanced Bionics 系统默认 32 次波形平均下,eCAP 阈值标准差中位数为 2 至 3 μA,范围为 1 至 11 μA。
  • 波形平均次数加倍时,eCAP 阈值标准差约降低二分之一平方根。
  • 基于线性外推 95% 置信边界的总误差可高达 -260 至 +120 μA。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议在 eCAP 记录过程中监测标准差,以辅助决定何时终止波形采集。
  • 从精密度角度,作者认为交替刺激极性平均(AP averaging)优于前向掩蔽(FM),且所需记录次数更少、更省时。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The reliability of the electrically evoked compound action potential (eCAP) threshold depends on its precision and accuracy. The precision of the eCAP threshold reflects its variability, while the accuracy of the threshold shows how close it is to the actual value. The objective of this study was to determine the test/retest variability of the eCAP threshold in Advanced Bionics cochlear implant users, which has never been reported before. We hypothesized that the test/retest variability is dependent on the presence of random noise in the recorded eCAP waveforms. If this holds true, the recorded error should be reduced by approximately the square-root of the number of averages. As secondary objectives, we assessed the effects of the slope of the amplitude growth function (AGF), cochlear location, and eCAP threshold on eCAP threshold precision. We hypothesized that steeper slopes should result in better precision of the linearly extrapolated eCAP threshold. As other studies have shown that apical regions have steeper slopes and larger eCAPs, we recorded eCAPs in three different cochlear locations. The difference of the precision between two commonly applied stimulus-artifact reduction paradigms on eCAP threshold precision was compared, namely averaging of alternating stimulus polarities (AP averaging) and forward masking (FM). FM requires the addition of more waveforms than AP averaging, and hence we expected FM to have lower precision than AP. DESIGN: This was an unmasked, descriptive, and observational study with a cross-over (repeated measures) design that included 13 subjects. We recorded eCAPs on three electrode contacts: in the base, middle, and apex of the cochlea at 10 stimulus intensities. Per stimulus level, 256 eCAP waveforms were recorded. eCAP thresholds were determined by constructing AGFs and linear extrapolation to zero-amplitude. The precision of the eCAP threshold was calculated as the SD using a Monte Carlo simulation, as a function of the number of waveform averages. RESULTS: The SD of the eCAP threshold was reduced by approximately the square root of two when the number of averages in the eCAP waveforms was doubled. The precision was significantly better when the slope of the AGF was steeper and was more favorable in the cochlear base than in the apex. Precision was better when AP averaging was used. Absolute eCAP threshold did not significantly affect precision. At the default number of 32 waveform averages in the Advanced Bionics system, we report a median SD of the eCAP threshold of 2 to 3 μA, with a range of 1 to 11 μA across the cochlea. Previous studies have shown that the total error, based on the 95% confidence bounds of the linear extrapolation, can be as high as -260 to +120 μA. CONCLUSIONS: The median variability in the eCAP threshold proved to be small compared with the total variability introduced by the linear extrapolation method. Yet there was substantial intersubject variability. Therefore, we recommend monitoring the SD during eCAP recording to facilitate informed decisions when to terminate waveform collection. From a precision perspective, AP averaging is preferable over FM as it has better precision, while fewer recordings are needed, making it the more time-efficient method of the two.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Stronks HC, Biesheuvel JD, de Vos JJ, et al. Test/Retest Variability of the eCAP Threshold in Advanced Bionics Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 30946135. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000721

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。