文献速递耳科与耳神经

压缩对人工耳蜗使用者音乐音质的影响

Effect of Compression on Musical Sound Quality in Cochlear Implant Users.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2019-01-01

本研究采用CI-MUSHRA方法评估人工耳蜗(CI)使用者与正常听力(NH)者对施加于音乐片段的多级压缩的敏感性。CI组(n=7,11耳)与NH组(n=10)均能察觉压缩导致的音质差异,但CI组辨别能力减弱,对过度压缩所致劣化的敏感性降低,且爵士与嘻哈片段受影响最大,动态范围(DR)较窄与较差评分相关(小幅但具统计学显著性)。

要点

  • CI使用者对高压缩水平所致音乐音质变化的敏感性低于正常听力者。
  • CI组对锚定条件(20次迭代压缩)平均仅评为比参考片段「稍差」。
  • 爵士与嘻哈片段受压缩影响最大,摇滚与乡村片段受影响较小。

核心结论

  • CI使用者对高压缩水平所致音乐音质变化敏感性较低,这可能是其音乐感知普遍较差的一个附加因素,尤其在听商业录制音乐时。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用CI-MUSHRA评估CI使用者与NH听者对逐级加重压缩的音乐片段的音质敏感性。
  • CI受试者7例(11耳),NH听者10例。
  • 对音乐片段施加多次迭代的激进压缩算法,测试条件为1、3、5、20次迭代声令牌,20次迭代样本作为锚定刺激。
  • 压缩片段长5秒,五种常见音乐流派(古典、爵士、乡村、摇滚、嘻哈)各五个片段,另呈现未额外压缩的原始参考片段。

主要发现

  • NH组与CI组均能检测到随压缩水平变化的音质差异,但CI组辨别能力较NH组减弱。
  • CI组反应变异性较小,总体对过度压缩所致劣化的敏感性降低。
  • CI组对锚定条件平均仅评为比参考「稍差」。
  • 受压缩影响最大的音乐片段为爵士与嘻哈,摇滚与乡村受影响较小。
  • 音乐片段DR对音质评分有小的但具统计学显著性的影响,较窄DR与较差评分相关。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Cochlear implant (CI) users frequently report poor sound quality while listening to music, although the specific parameters responsible for this loss of sound quality remain poorly understood. Audio compression, which reduces the dynamic range (DR) for a given sound, is a ubiquitous component of signal processing used by both CI and hearing aid technology. However, the relative impact of compression for acoustic and electric hearing on music perception has not been well studied, an important consideration especially given that most compression algorithms in CIs were developed to optimize speech perception. The authors hypothesized that normal-hearing (NH) listeners would detect increased levels of compression more easily than CI users, but that both groups would perceive a loss of sound quality with increasing compression levels. DESIGN: The present study utilizes the Cochlear Implant-MUltiple Stimulus with Hidden Reference and Anchor to evaluate the listener sensitivity to increasing levels of compression applied to music stimuli. The Cochlear Implant-MUltiple Stimulus with Hidden Reference and Anchor is a tool used to assess relative changes in the perceived sound quality of music across increasingly degraded listening conditions, in both CI and NH subjects. In this study, the authors applied multiple iterations of an aggressive compression algorithm to the music clips using Adobe Audition. The test conditions included 1, 3, 5, and 20 iterations sound tokens, with the 20-iteration samples serving as the Anchor stimuli. The compressed excerpts were 5 sec in length, with five clips for each of the five common musical genres (i.e., Classical, Jazz, Country, Rock, and Hip-Hop). Subjects were also presented with a Reference excerpt, which was the original music clip without any additional compression applied. CI recipients (n = 7, 11 ears) and NH listeners (n = 10) were asked to rate the sound quality of additionally compressed music as compared to the Reference. RESULTS: Although both NH and CI groups could detect sound quality differences as a function of compression level, the discriminatory ability of the CI group was blunted compared to the NH group. The CI group had less variability in their responses and overall demonstrated reduced sensitivity to deterioration caused by excessive levels of compression. On average, the CI group rated the Anchor condition as only "Slightly worse" than the Reference. The music clips that were most affected by the compression were from Jazz and Hip-Hop genres and less so for Rock and Country clips. Corollary to this was a small but statistically significant impact of DR of the music clips on sound quality ratings, with narrower DR showing an association with poorer ratings. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that CI users exhibit less sensitivity to sound quality changes in music attributable to high levels of compression. These findings may account for another contributing factor to the generally poor music perception observed in CI users, particularly when listening to commercially recorded music.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gilbert M, Jiradejvong P, Limb C, et al. Effect of Compression on Musical Sound Quality in Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 30946137. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000715

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。