诊室喉部手术局部麻醉技术:患者偏好比较
该队列研究纳入100例连续在门诊喉科接受清醒手术的患者,分别采用雾化器、经通道喉镜软管或经气管滴注4%利多卡因2立方厘米麻醉,比较患者与术者满意度。90例完成调查者中经气管滴注组患者满意度最高(2.04),高于软管组(1.46)和雾化器组(1.45),差异有统计学意义(P=0.0167);术者满意度雾化器组较低、经气管注射组较高(P=0.0081)。
要点
- 经气管滴注组患者满意度评分2.04,高于软管组1.46和雾化器组1.45(P=0.0167)。
- 术者满意度雾化器组较低、经气管注射组较高(P=0.0081)。
- 术者满意度与患者满意度之间存在相关性(P<0.0001)。
核心结论
- 经气管滴注受到患者和术者双方的偏好。
- 局部麻醉技术选择可能影响患者偏好和手术成功,或可作为优化诊室喉部手术麻醉管理的依据。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,纳入所有连续到门诊喉科接受清醒手术的患者。
- 共100例连续患者(37例女性,73例男性),组间数量相对均衡(雾化器组32例、软管组35例、经气管组33例)。
- 麻醉方式为局部麻醉(4%利多卡因2立方厘米),分三种:雾化器、经通道喉镜软管、经气管滴注。
- 记录人口学资料、手术时间和术者满意度,术后用经验证的11项患者满意度问卷(Iowa Satisfaction with Anesthesia Survey)计算总体满意度评分(-3最差至3最佳),并进行描述性与相关性统计。
主要发现
- 7例手术中止(雾化器组4例、软管组2例、经气管组1例),原因为移动、焦虑或技术问题。
- 3例患者未充分完成问卷;余90例中患者满意度经气管组2.04,高于软管组1.46和雾化器组1.45,差异有统计学意义(P=0.0167)。
- 该差异由经气管组疼痛和恶心评分降低所驱动。
- 术者满意度雾化器组较低、经气管注射组较高(P=0.0081)。
- 术者满意度与患者满意度之间存在相关性(P<0.0001)。
临床怎么用
- 经气管滴注受到患者和术者双方的偏好。
- 局部麻醉技术选择可能影响患者偏好和手术成功,或可作为优化诊室喉部手术麻醉管理的依据。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Multiple topical anesthesia techniques exist for office-based laryngeal surgery. Our objective was to assess patient and surgeon satisfaction for three different techniques. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study. METHODS: All consecutive patients presenting to an outpatient laryngology office for awake surgical procedures were enrolled. Patients were anesthetized with local anesthesia (2 cubic centimeters of 4% lidocaine) in one of three ways: 1) nebulizer, 2) flexible cannula through a channeled laryngoscope, or 3) transtracheal instillation. Demographics, procedure times, and surgeon satisfaction were recorded. A validated 11-item patient satisfaction questionnaire (Iowa Satisfaction with Anesthesia Survey) was administered after the procedure to calculate an overall satisfaction score (-3[worst] to 3[best]). Descriptive and correlative statistics were performed. RESULTS: One hundred consecutive patients were included (37 females, 73 males), with relatively equal numbers between groups (32 nebulizer, 35 cannula, 33 transtracheal). Seven procedures were aborted (4 nebulizer, 2 cannula, 1 transtracheal) due to movement, anxiety, or technical issues. Three patients did not adequately complete the survey. Of the 90 remaining patients, patient satisfaction was highest with the transtracheal technique (2.04) versus cannula (1.46) or nebulizer (1.45), and this was statistically significant (P = 0.0167). This difference was driven by decreased pain and nausea scores in the transtracheal group. Surgeon satisfaction was lower with nebulizer and higher with transtracheal injection (P = 0.0081). There was a correlation between surgeon satisfaction and patient satisfaction (P < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: Transtracheal instillation was favored by both patients and the surgeon. Choice of local anesthetic techniques may impact patient preferences and surgical success. This may serve as a basis for optimizing anesthetic care in office-based laryngeal surgery. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4 Laryngoscope, 130:166-170, 2020.
引用
- Naunheim MR, Woo P. Topical anesthetic techniques in office-based laryngeal surgery: A comparison of patient preferences. Laryngoscope. 2019. PMID: 30835852. doi:10.1002/lary.27894
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。