文献速递耳科与耳神经

更高最大力输出对骨锚式助听系统使用者聆听努力的影响:瞳孔测量研究

Benefit of Higher Maximum Force Output on Listening Effort in Bone-Anchored Hearing System Users: A Pupillometry Study.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2019-01-01

本研究采用单盲随机顺序设计,在21例传导性或混合性听力损失的骨锚式助听系统使用者中,以瞳孔扩张评估三种不同最大力输出(MFO)声音处理器在噪声中言语测试时的聆听努力。结果显示,在条件1下Ponto 3 SuperPower(P3SP)的峰值瞳孔扩张显著低于Ponto Pro(PP),整体瞳孔扩张在两种条件下P3SP和Ponto 3均显著低于PP。结论认为更高MFO的声音处理器可减少饱和伪迹,从而降低处理中等至大声言语信号的整体努力。

要点

  • 在条件1下,P3SP的峰值瞳孔扩张显著低于PP,提示聆听努力降低。
  • 整体瞳孔扩张在两种条件下P3SP和P3均显著低于PP,条件1下P3SP也显著低于P3。
  • P3SP在两种条件下言语识别率均高于PP,P3与PP及P3SP均无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 使用具有更高MFO的声音处理器(P3SP和P3)可显著降低处理中等至大声言语信号的整体努力,原因是饱和伪迹更少。
  • 研究结果提示,更高MFO的声音处理器可能通过改善音质、减少处理 incoming 言语声所需的认知资源,帮助BAHS使用者在日常聆听场景中,尤其是噪声环境中获益。

研究设计与样本

  • 单盲实验设计,21例传导性或混合性听力损失的BAHS使用者参与。
  • 在正信噪比(SNR)下进行噪声中言语测试,言语和噪声水平个体化调整至使用PP时言语识别率达95%正确。
  • 三种声音处理器(PP、P3、P3SP)以随机顺序测试,差异在于最大力输出(MFO)和MFO算法。
  • 受试者聆听噪声中句子、保持3秒后复述,同时用眼动追踪相机记录瞳孔扩张。
  • 设置两种条件:条件1言语水平设计为使PP饱和而非P3SP;条件2整体声级较条件1降低以减少饱和伪迹。

主要发现

  • P3SP在两种条件下的言语识别率均高于PP;P3的言语识别率与PP和P3SP均无显著差异。
  • 条件1下,P3SP的峰值瞳孔扩张(PPD)显著低于PP,提示聆听努力降低;P3的PPD与其他两种处理器均无显著差异。
  • 条件2下,三种处理器之间的PPD无差异。
  • 生长曲线分析(GCA)显示,两种条件下P3SP和P3的整体瞳孔扩张均显著低于PP;条件1下P3SP的整体瞳孔扩张也显著低于P3。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论指出,更高MFO的声音处理器可能帮助BAHS使用者在日常聆听场景中,尤其是噪声环境中获益。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to compare listening effort, as estimated via pupillary response, during a speech-in-noise test in bone-anchored hearing system (BAHS) users wearing three different sound processors. The three processors, Ponto Pro (PP), Ponto 3 (P3), and Ponto 3 SuperPower (P3SP), differ in terms of maximum force output (MFO) and MFO algorithm. The hypothesis was that listeners would allocate lower listening effort with the P3SP than with the PP, as a consequence of a higher MFO and, hence, fewer saturation artifacts in the signal. DESIGN: Pupil dilations were recorded in 21 BAHS users with a conductive or mixed hearing loss, during a speech-in-noise test performed at positive signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs), where the speech and noise levels were individually adjusted to lead to 95% correct intelligibility with the PP. The listeners had to listen to a sentence in noise, retain it for 3 seconds and then repeat it, while an eye-tracking camera recorded their pupil dilation. The three sound processors were tested in random order with a single-blinded experimental design. Two conditions were performed at the same SNR: Condition 1, where the speech level was designed to saturate the PP but not the P3SP, and condition 2, where the overall sound level was decreased relative to condition 1 to reduce saturation artifacts. RESULTS: The P3SP led to higher speech intelligibility than the PP in both conditions, while the performance with the P3 did not differ from the performance with the PP and the P3SP. Pupil dilations were analyzed in terms of both peak pupil dilation (PPD) and overall pupil dilation via growth curve analysis (GCA). In condition 1, a significantly lower PPD, indicating a decrease in listening effort, was obtained with the P3SP relative to the PP. The PPD obtained with the P3 did not differ from the PPD obtained with the other two sound processors. In condition 2, no difference in PPD was observed across the three processors. The GCA revealed that the overall pupil dilation was significantly lower, in both conditions, with both the P3SP and the P3 relative to the PP, and, in condition 1, also with the P3SP relative to the P3. CONCLUSIONS: The overall effort to process a moderate to loud speech signal was significantly reduced by using a sound processor with a higher MFO (P3SP and P3), as a consequence of fewer saturation artifacts. These findings suggest that sound processors with a higher MFO may help BAHS users in their everyday listening scenarios, in particular in noisy environments, by improving sound quality and, thus, decreasing the amount of cognitive resources utilized to process incoming speech sounds.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bianchi F, Wendt D, Wassard C, et al. Benefit of Higher Maximum Force Output on Listening Effort in Bone-Anchored Hearing System Users: A Pupillometry Study. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 30807542. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000699

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。