文献速递耳科与耳神经

听力努力测量具有多维性

Measures of Listening Effort Are Multidimensional.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2019-01-01

研究纳入116名听力阈值从正常到重度听力损失的55至85岁参与者,同步测量瞳孔大小、脑电α功率、皮肤电导和自我报告听力努力,并检验重测信度与结构效度。除皮肤电导和疲劳自我报告外,各测量重测信度良好(最小ICC为0.71),但测量间相关性弱或无显著相关;因子分析揭示四个潜在维度。作者据此提出听力努力不存在「金标准」测量,不同测量方法不应互换使用。

要点

  • 除皮肤电导和疲劳自我报告外,各听力努力测量重测信度良好(最小ICC为0.71)。
  • 各测量间相关性弱或无显著相关,信度不足并非缺乏相关的原因。
  • 因子分析揭示四个潜在维度,瞳孔测量、α功率与自我报告分属不同维度。

核心结论

  • 良好的ICC表明测试信度差不是测量间缺乏相关的原因,传统上作为听力努力指标的测量涉及多个潜在维度,因此不存在听力努力的「金标准」测量,不同测量方法不应互换使用。
  • 选择听力努力测量方法时,应考虑任务性质以及所关注的听力需求增加方面。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入116名听力阈值从正常到重度听力损失的参与者,年龄范围55至85岁,50.3%为男性。
  • 同步测量瞳孔大小、脑电α功率、皮肤电导和自我报告听力努力,并纳入一项疲劳自我报告测量。
  • 信噪比(SNR)采用3位数字序列调整至71%正确率标准;主要听力任务为在正确率约82%至93%的SNR下正确回忆6位数字序列中的随机一位数字。
  • 通过30名参与者在初次测试7天后重测来建立重测信度。

主要发现

  • 除皮肤电导和疲劳自我报告外,组内相关系数(ICC)显示重测信度良好(最小ICC为0.71)。
  • 各测量间发现弱相关或无显著相关。
  • 仅使用可靠测量进行的因子分析揭示四个潜在维度:因子1包括SNR、听力级、基线α功率和表现正确率;因子2包括瞳孔测量;因子3包括α功率(言语呈现期间和保持期间);因子4包括自我报告听力努力和基线α功率。

关键数值与推荐

  • 重测信度良好标准:最小ICC为0.71(除皮肤电导和疲劳自我报告外)。
  • 信噪比调整至71%正确率标准;主要听力任务SNR下正确率约82%至93%。
  • 因子分析仅纳入可靠测量,提取四个因子。

临床怎么用

  • 作者提出不存在听力努力的「金标准」测量,不同测量方法不应互换使用。
  • 作者建议选择听力努力测量方法时考虑任务性质以及所关注的听力需求增加方面。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Listening effort can be defined as the cognitive resources required to perform a listening task. The literature on listening effort is as confusing as it is voluminous: measures of listening effort rarely correlate with each other and sometimes result in contradictory findings. Here, we directly compared simultaneously recorded multimodal measures of listening effort. After establishing the reliability of the measures, we investigated validity by quantifying correlations between measures and then grouping-related measures through factor analysis. DESIGN: One hundred and sixteen participants with audiometric thresholds ranging from normal to severe hearing loss took part in the study (age range: 55 to 85 years old, 50.3% male). We simultaneously measured pupil size, electroencephalographic alpha power, skin conductance, and self-report listening effort. One self-report measure of fatigue was also included. The signal to noise ratio (SNR) was adjusted at 71% criterion performance using sequences of 3 digits. The main listening task involved correct recall of a random digit from a sequence of six presented at a SNR where performance was around 82 to 93%. Test-retest reliability of the measures was established by retesting 30 participants 7 days after the initial session. RESULTS: With the exception of skin conductance and the self-report measure of fatigue, interclass correlation coefficients (ICC) revealed good test-retest reliability (minimum ICC: 0.71). Weak or nonsignificant correlations were identified between measures. Factor analysis, using only the reliable measures, revealed four underlying dimensions: factor 1 included SNR, hearing level, baseline alpha power, and performance accuracy; factor 2 included pupillometry; factor 3 included alpha power (during speech presentation and during retention); factor 4 included self-reported listening effort and baseline alpha power. CONCLUSIONS: The good ICC suggests that poor test reliability is not the reason for the lack of correlation between measures. We have demonstrated that measures traditionally used as indicators of listening effort tap into multiple underlying dimensions. We therefore propose that there is no "gold standard" measure of listening effort and that different measures of listening effort should not be used interchangeably. When choosing method(s) to measure listening effort, the nature of the task and aspects of increased listening demands that are of interest should be taken into account. The findings of this study provide a framework for understanding and interpreting listening effort measures.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Alhanbali S, Dawes P, Millman RE, et al. Measures of Listening Effort Are Multidimensional. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 30747742. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000697

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。