文献速递鼻科

上颌窦球囊扩张的术中准确性:一项盲法试验

The intraoperative accuracy of maxillary balloon dilation: a blinded trial.
PubMed 文献 · Int Forum Allergy Rhinol · 2019-01-10

这项前瞻性单盲试验在18例无鼻息肉的慢性鼻窦炎或接受颅底入路的患者中评估上颌窦球囊扩张(BSD)的术中准确性。29次尝试中18次(62%)成功,9次(31%)未成功,3名不同机构的鼻科医生盲法判读一致性几乎完美(kappa=0.86)。两种BSD系统间准确性无统计学差异(p=0.81)。作者结论:上颌窦BSD在活体患者中的准确性似乎低于既往尸体研究,需进一步研究其临床意义。

要点

  • 上颌窦BSD在活体患者中29次尝试成功18次(62%),未成功9次(31%)。
  • 导丝基与探针基两种BSD系统间准确性无统计学差异(p=0.81)。
  • 3名盲法鼻科医生判读一致性几乎完美(kappa=0.86)。

核心结论

  • 上颌窦球囊扩张在活体患者中的准确性似乎低于既往发表的尸体研究结果。
  • 探针基与导丝基两种球囊扩张系统之间准确性无差异。
  • 这是首个由非产业资助的、在活体患者中评估上颌窦球囊扩张的研究。
  • 需要进一步研究来探讨这些发现的临床意义。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性、单盲试验,评估上颌窦球囊扩张的准确性。
  • 使用两种市售球囊扩张系统(导丝基和探针基),随机分配给因无鼻息肉的慢性鼻窦炎接受内镜手术或对无鼻窦疾病患者行颅底入路的患者。
  • 所有患者接受上颌窦球囊扩张后行钩突切除以显露上颌窦自然开口的扩张情况。
  • 记录的手术由来自不同机构的3名经过鼻科专科培训的鼻科医生在不知所用球囊扩张系统的情况下进行判读。
  • 共18例患者(年龄范围20-79岁;平均51岁)接受了29次上颌窦球囊扩张操作。

主要发现

  • 29次上颌窦球囊扩张尝试中,18次(62%)成功,9次(31%)未成功。
  • 3名判读医生间一致性统计为「几乎完美」(kappa=0.86)。
  • 两种球囊扩张系统之间无统计学差异(p=0.81)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 需要进一步研究来探讨这些发现的临床意义。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Balloon sinus dilation (BSD) is a commonly performed sinus procedure in the United States. Several cadaveric studies have evaluated BSD accuracy and the maxillary sinus has consistently been shown to be the most challenging to cannulate. We designed an independent study to evaluate the intraoperative accuracy of maxillary sinus BSD. METHODS: A prospective, single-blinded trial evaluating the accuracy of maxillary sinus BSD was performed using 2 commercially available BSD systems (guidewire- and probe-based systems) randomly assigned to patients undergoing endoscopic surgery for chronic rhinosinusitus without nasal polyps (CRSsNP) or a skullbase approach in patients without sinus disease. All patients underwent maxillary BSD followed by uncinectomy to reveal dilation of the natural maxillary sinus ostia. The recorded procedures were reviewed by 3 fellowship-trained rhinologists from different institutions blinded to the BSD system utilized. The primary endpoint compared accuracy of maxillary BSD attempts. The secondary endpoint compared accuracy between the 2 systems. RESULTS: Twenty-nine maxillary BSD procedures were performed in 18 patients (age range, 20-79 years; mean, 51 years) without nasal polyposis undergoing maxillary antrostomy as part of a more extensive procedure. BSD was successful in 18 of 29 (62%) attempts and unsuccessful in 9 of 29 (31%) attempts, with statistically "almost perfect" interrater agreement (kappa = 0.86). There was no statistical difference between the 2 BSD systems (p = 0.81). CONCLUSION: Maxillary BSD appeared to be less accurate in living patients when compared with findings from previously published cadaver studies. There were no differences in accuracy between the probe- and guidewire-based systems. This is the first non-industry-sponsored study evaluating maxillary sinus BSD in living patients. Further studies are needed to investigate the clinical implications of our findings.

来源:Int Forum Allergy Rhinol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jensen BT, Holbrook EH, Chen PG, et al. The intraoperative accuracy of maxillary balloon dilation: a blinded trial. Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2019. PMID: 30629822. doi:10.1002/alr.22286

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。