文献速递鼻科

Draf IIB 联合上鼻中隔切除术:寻找「中间地带」

Draf IIB with superior septectomy: finding the "middle ground".
PubMed 文献 · Int Forum Allergy Rhinol · 2018-12-12

在 6 例尸头标本上比较内镜鼻窦手术(ESS)联合 Draf IIb 加上鼻中隔切除术(IIb+SS)与内镜改良 Lothrop 手术(EMLP)的冲洗液渗透分布,由 4 名盲法鼻科医生评分 0~3 分,各鼻窦及嗅裂均无显著差异,结论为 IIb+SS 可提供与 EMLP 相似的冲洗递送益处,但需进一步研究。

要点

  • 尸头研究显示 IIb+SS 与 EMLP 的冲洗液渗透总体评分无显著差异。
  • 各鼻窦及嗅裂亚部位评分两组间均无显著差异。
  • IIb+SS 无需改变自然鼻窦流出道和造成环形瘢痕。

核心结论

  • ESS 联合 IIb+SS 可提供与 ESS 联合 EMLP 相似的冲洗递送益处,且无需改变自然鼻窦流出道和造成环形瘢痕。
  • 作者认为需要对再次手术高风险患者进一步研究 IIb+SS 的应用。

研究设计与样本

  • 在 6 例尸头标本上先后行 ESS 联合 IIb+SS 与 EMLP,每次术后用荧光素染色冲洗液冲洗并以视频内镜记录渗透情况。
  • 由 4 名接受过专科培训的盲法鼻科医生审阅视频,对上颌窦、筛窦、额窦、蝶窦及嗅裂的冲洗液渗透按 0~3 分评分(3 分表示完全染色)。

主要发现

  • 总体平均评分 IIb+SS 组 1.99 对 EMLP 组 1.97(p = 0.816)。
  • 上颌窦平均评分 IIb+SS 组 2.67 对 EMLP 组 2.38(p = 0.128)。
  • 筛窦平均评分 IIb+SS 组 1.88 对 EMLP 组 1.98(p = 0.536)。
  • 蝶窦平均评分 IIb+SS 组 2.58 对 EMLP 组 2.50(p = 0.467)。
  • 额窦平均评分 IIb+SS 组 1.13 对 EMLP 组 1.38(p = 0.073),嗅裂平均评分 IIb+SS 组 1.71 对 EMLP 组 1.63(p = 0.529),各亚部位两组间均无显著差异。

关键数值与推荐

  • 评分者间信度良好(Cronbach's alpha = 0.781)。

局限性

  • 作者指出需要对再次手术高风险患者进一步研究 IIb+SS 的应用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Previous studies have demonstrated a high failure rate of endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) with Draf IIa in patients with diffuse polyposis, asthma, and aspirin-exacerbated respiratory disease. A high percentage of these patients progress to endoscopic modified Lothrop procedure (EMLP). We describe a modification of the Draf IIb with a superior septectomy (IIb+SS), which may provide similar therapeutic benefit as demonstrated by the distribution of sinus irrigations in the sinus cavity with ESS with IIb+SS vs ESS with EMLP. METHODS: ESS with IIb+SS was performed on 6 cadaver heads. Fluorescein-dyed irrigations were performed on each head and penetration was recorded using video endoscopy. EMLP was subsequently performed on each head with repeat dye-irrigation and video endoscopy. The videos were reviewed by 4 blinded fellowship-trained rhinologists, and irrigant penetration of the maxillary, ethmoid, frontal, sphenoid sinuses, and olfactory cleft was graded 0 to 3 (3 implying complete staining). RESULTS: The mean scores when comparing IIb+SS to EMLP were as follows: overall 1.99 vs 1.97 (p = 0.816), maxillary sinus 2.67 vs 2.38 (p = 0.128), ethmoid sinus 1.88 vs 1.98 (p = 0.536), sphenoid sinus 2.58 vs 2.50 (p = 0.467), frontal sinus 1.13 vs 1.38 (p = 0.073), and olfactory cleft 1.71 vs 1.63 (p = 0.529). There was no significant difference between subsites. Interrater reliability was good (Cronbach's alpha = 0.781). CONCLUSION: Performing ESS with IIb+SS provides similar irrigation delivery benefits to ESS with EMLP, without the need for altering natural sinus outflow and creating circumferential scarring. Further studies evaluating its use in patients that are high risk for revision surgery are needed.

来源:Int Forum Allergy Rhinol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bhalla V, Sykes KJ, Villwock JA, et al. Draf IIB with superior septectomy: finding the "middle ground". Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2018. PMID: 30548455. doi:10.1002/alr.22228

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。