儿童听力损失的临床指南:使用AGREE II工具的系统评价
该系统评价通过PubMed、Google Scholar、EBSCO及手动Google搜索检索儿童听力损失相关临床实践指南,由3名独立评估者使用AGREE II工具对符合纳入标准的4部指南进行评价。结果显示,范围和目的领域中位得分较高为83%,利益相关者参与、清晰性、编辑独立性分别为67%、54%、50%,制定严谨性和适用性得分较低分别为22%和38%;4部指南各领域得分均低于60%,未经修改均不能推荐。结论认为儿童听力损失临床实践指南存在不足,需要全面的指南。
要点
- 共4部儿童听力损失临床实践指南符合纳入标准并被评价。
- 范围和目的领域中位得分83%,制定严谨性22%、适用性38%得分低。
- 基于AGREE II,4部指南各领域得分均低于60%,未经修改均不能推荐。
核心结论
- 基于AGREE II评价,儿童听力损失临床实践指南存在若干不足,仍需要全面的临床实践指南。
- 制定严谨性和适用性是这些指南最需要改进的方面。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价,检索PubMed、Google Scholar、EBSCO及手动Google搜索,由3名独立评估者使用AGREE II工具评价儿童听力损失相关临床实践指南,共4部指南符合纳入标准并被评价。
主要发现
- 范围和目的领域达到较高的中位得分83%。
- 利益相关者参与、清晰性、编辑独立性领域分别达到中位得分67%、54%、50%。
- 制定严谨性和适用性领域得分较低,分别为22%和38%。
- 基于AGREE II测量,4部指南各领域得分均低于60%,未经修改均不能推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Despite the importance, impact, and prevalence of pediatric hearing loss (HL), there are very few published clinical practice guidelines (CPG) supporting the evaluation and management of pediatric patients with HL. Our objective was to appraise existing CPGs to ensure safe and effective practices. METHODS: A literature search was conducted in PubMed, Google Scholar, EBSCO, as well as a manual Google search. Three independent assessors using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) instrument evaluated CPGs related to HL in children. Standardized domain scores were calculated for each guideline. RESULTS: A total of four guidelines met the inclusion criteria and were appraised. Scope and purpose achieved a high median score of 83%. Stakeholder involvement, clarity of presentation, and editorial independence achieved intermediate scores of 67%, 54%, and 50%, respectively. The areas that required most improvement and achieved low scores were rigor of development and applicability, with scores of 22% and 38%, respectively. Based on the AGREE II measures, the four guidelines had domain scores less than 60% for each domain, and without modification no guideline could be recommended. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the AGREE II, the qualities of CPGs for pediatric HL have several shortcomings, and the need for a comprehensive CPG remains. Rigor of development and applicability present the greatest opportunities for improvement of these CPGs. Laryngoscope, 130:212-216, 2020.
引用
- Kanabur P, Hubbard C, Jeyakumar A, et al. Clinical Guidelines in Pediatric Hearing Loss: Systemic Review Using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II Instrument. Laryngoscope. 2018. PMID: 30536859. doi:10.1002/lary.27722
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。