脂肪注射与喉内移成形术治疗非麻痹性声门闭合不全的嗓音结局比较
该回顾性研究纳入2009至2017年因声带麻痹或萎缩致声门闭合不全而接受自体脂肪注射或喉内移成形术(ML)的患者,比较两组嗓音结局。短期两组VHI-10与GFI均较术前显著下降,但随访全程仅ML组维持VHI-10与GFI的显著改善,脂肪注射疗效随时间减弱。
要点
- 脂肪注射与ML短期内均能显著改善VHI-10与GFI评分。
- 随访全程仅ML组维持VHI-10与GFI的显著改善。
- 脂肪注射疗效有限,VHI-10与GFI随时间出现恶化。
核心结论
- 脂肪注射与ML短期均改善嗓音评分,但脂肪注射效果有限,VHI-10与GFI随时间恶化。
主要发现
- 两组术前VHI-10评分无显著差异。
- 取随访期最低嗓音评分时,两组均较术前显著下降(P < 0.05)。
- 脂肪组VHI-10由27.8降至14.2,ML组由30.5降至9.1。
- 脂肪组GFI由13.7降至5.27,ML组由13.6降至4.6。
- 评估整个随访期(脂肪组中位19个月、ML组16.3个月),仅ML组VHI-10(中位差值14.5)与GFI(中位差值7)较术前维持显著改善。
关键数值与推荐
- 脂肪组平均年龄60.7岁,ML组55.6岁。
- 随访时间最短3个月。
- 证据等级为4。
临床怎么用
- 对声带麻痹或萎缩所致声门闭合不全,ML在长期嗓音改善上优于脂肪注射。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare voice outcomes of autogenous fat injection versus medialization laryngoplasty in patients with glottic insufficiency due to vocal fold paresis or atrophy. METHODS: A retrospective review was performed from 2009 to 2017 of all patients who underwent lipoinjection or medialization laryngoplasty (ML) for glottic insufficiency. Charts were reviewed for demographic information, preoperative diagnosis, surgical intervention, Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) and Glottal Function Index (GFI) scores, follow-up time (minimum 3 months), and concomitant voice therapy. RESULTS: Eighty-three patients were initially identified and limited to 28 based on the inclusion/exclusion criteria. Thirty-five procedures were performed with a total of 15 fat injections and 20 MLs. The mean age was 60.7 years in the lipoinjection group and 55.6 years in the ML group. There was no significant difference in pretreatment VHI-10 scores between the two groups. Using the lowest recorded voice scores during the follow-up period, both groups had a significant decrease (P < 0.05) compared to preoperative scores (VHI-10: fat decreased from 27.8 to 14.2, ML decreased from 30.5 to 9.1; GFI: fat decreased from 13.7 to 5.27, ML decreased from 13.6 to 4.6). When evaluating the entire follow-up period (median 19 months in fat group, 16.3 months in ML), only the ML group maintained a significant improvement in VHI-10 (median delta 14.5) and GFI (median delta 7) compared to preoperative scores. CONCLUSION: Although both autogenous fat injection and ML result in improved voice scores in the short term, the effect of fat injection appears to be limited, as evidenced by worsening VHI-10 and GFI scores over time. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4 Laryngoscope, 129:1164-1168, 2019.
引用
- M Dominguez L, Villarreal R, Simpson CB, et al. Voice Outcomes of Lipoinjection Versus Medialization Laryngoplasty for Nonparalytic Glottic Insufficiency. Laryngoscope. 2018. PMID: 30284284. doi:10.1002/lary.27573
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。