国际额窦解剖分类系统的评定者间与评定者内信度国际评估
评定者间加权kappa均值0.9162,评定者内均值0.9407,ICC均为0.98,表明IFAC是额窦气房分类的可靠工具,但效度仍需进一步研究。
要点
- IFAC在鼻科医生中评定者间信度均值κ=0.9162,评定者内均值κ=0.9407。
- 评定者间与评定者内ICC均为0.98,显示高度一致性。
- IFAC可作为额窦气房分类的可靠工具,但效度尚待结局研究验证。
核心结论
- IFAC在多样本鼻科医生中评定者间和评定者内均达到高度至几乎完美的一致性,是额窦气房分类的可靠工具。
主要发现
- 评定者间成对κ值范围0.7248至1.0,均值0.9162(SD,0.0537),ICC为0.98。
- 评定者内κ值范围0.8613至1.0,均值0.9407(SD,0.0376),评定者内ICC为0.98。
关键数值与推荐
- IFAC将额窦气房分为7类。
- 评定者间成对κ值范围0.7248至1.0,均值0.9162(SD,0.0537)。
- 评定者内κ值范围0.8613至1.0,均值0.9407(SD,0.0376)。
- 评定者间ICC为0.98,评定者内ICC为0.98。
临床怎么用
- IFAC可作为额窦气房分类的可靠工具,有助于统一命名和教学额窦内镜手术。
局限性
- IFAC的效度仍需进一步结局研究确定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Inconsistencies in the nomenclature of structures of the frontal sinus have impeded the development of a validated "reference standard" classification system that surgeons can reliably agree upon. The International Frontal Sinus Anatomy Classification (IFAC) system was developed as a consensus document, based on expert opinion, attempting to address this issue. The purposes of this study are to: establish the reliability of the IFAC as a tool for classifying cells in the frontal recess among an international group of rhinologists; and improve communication and teaching of frontal endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS). METHODS: Forty-two computed tomography (CT) scans, each with a marked frontal cell, were reviewed by 15 international fellowship-trained rhinologists. Each marked cell was classified into 1 of 7 categories described in the IFAC, on 2 occasions separated by 2 weeks. Inter- and intrarater reliability were evaluated using Light's kappa (κ), the interclass correlation coefficient (ICC), and simple proportion of agreement. RESULTS: Interrater reliability showed pairwise κ values ranging from 0.7248 to 1.0, with a mean of 0.9162 (SD, 0.0537). The ICC was 0.98. Intrarater reliability showed κ values ranging from 0.8613 to 1.0, with a mean of 0.9407 (SD, 0.0376). The within-rater ICC was 0.98. CONCLUSION: Among a diverse sample of rhinologists (raters), there was substantial to almost perfect agreement between raters, and among individual raters at different timepoints. The IFAC is a reliable tool for classification of cells in the frontal sinus. Further outcome studies are still needed to determine the validity of the IFAC.
引用
- Villarreal R, Wrobel BB, Macias-Valle LF, et al. International assessment of inter- and intrarater reliability of the International Frontal Sinus Anatomy Classification system. Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2018. PMID: 30216705. doi:10.1002/alr.22200
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。