三维打印鼻腔鼻窦模型制作与验证
研究利用桌面级熔融沉积成型3D打印机制作鼻腔和鼻窦仿真模型,由5名专家和5名住院医师评估解剖仿真性和操作实用性。模型所有组件24小时内打印完成,解剖结构评分多>4.0分,专家完成各项操作时间均短于住院医师。结论认为该模型可用于鼻内镜基本操作训练与教学。
要点
- 桌面级FDM打印的鼻腔鼻窦模型24小时内完成制作。
- 解剖仿真性评分除额窦3.6分外均>4.0分。
- 专家完成鼻内镜操作时间均显著短于住院医师。
核心结论
- 桌面级FDM打印机制作的3D鼻腔和鼻窦模型检验结果满意,可用于鼻内镜基本操作的训练与教学。
研究设计与样本
- 选取1例鼻中隔偏曲患者CT数据建立鼻腔模型,1例慢性鼻-鼻窦炎术后4个月随访CT数据建立鼻窦模型,均来自郑州大学第一附属医院鼻科。
- 应用自主研发的桌面级熔融沉积成型(FDM)打印机制作模型,由专家组和住院医师组各5名医师进行检验。
- 专家组以5分李克特量表评价模型解剖结构仿真性和训练实用性;两组分别在模型上进行双侧鼻内镜基本操作并计时比较。
- 组间操作时间比较采用Mann-Whitney检验,P<0.05设为差异有统计学意义。
主要发现
- 模型所有组件均在24小时内打印完成。
- 鼻腔模型各解剖结构仿真程度平均评分均>4.0分;鼻窦模型除额窦为3.6分外,其余解剖结构均>4.0分。
- 两个模型的各项鼻内镜下基本操作实用性平均评分均>4.0分。
- 鼻腔模型上完成鼻腔及鼻咽部探查、圆球形异物取出、填塞凡士林纱条、放置棉片表面麻醉;鼻窦模型上完成鼻腔及鼻咽部探查、鼻窦开口辨认、70°鼻内镜下双侧上颌窦换药。
- 专家组和住院医师组完成上述操作的时间中位数[P25,P75]分别为10.3[10.0,10.7]s比17.1[14.6,20.7]s、2.1[2.0,2.2]s比3.4[2.6,4.7]s、30.1[27.8,32.8]s比59.2[52.0,65.4]s、54.8[50.1,63.2]s比92.2[79.3,106.9]s、9.3[8.7,9.9]s比14.5[13.3,14.9]s、20.1[19.3,21.2]s比41.9[35.5,45.1]s、31.1[28.8,35.2]s比52.8[47.7,56.3]s,专家组均更短(U值分别为0、1.000、0、0、0、0、0,P值均<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 模型解剖结构仿真性及操作实用性采用5分李克特量表评价,评分>4.0分视为评价良好。
- 鼻腔模型各解剖结构仿真程度平均评分均>4.0分;鼻窦模型除额窦为3.6分外,其余均>4.0分。
- 两个模型各项鼻内镜下基本操作实用性平均评分均>4.0分。
临床怎么用
- 该模型可用于鼻内镜基本操作训练与教学,尤适用于住院医师练习鼻腔及鼻咽部探查、异物取出、填塞、鼻窦开口辨认及上颌窦换药等操作。
- 额窦解剖仿真性评分相对偏低(3.6分),涉及额窦的操作训练需注意模型局限性。
局限性
- 仅纳入2例患者影像数据制作模型,样本量小。
- 评估仅由5名专家和5名住院医师完成,评价者数量有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To make three-dimensional prototyped models of nasal cavities and paranasal sinuses for endoscopic skills training and teaching and to verify and evaluate the fidelity of the models. Methods: Imaging data of a patient with nasal septum deviation was selected for prototyping the nasal cavities model, and the imaging data of a patient with chronic rhinosinusitis who underwent the endoscopic sinus surgery 4 months ago was selected for the paranasal sinuses model. Both patients came from the Department of Rhinology, the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University. The models were printed by the desktop-level printer based on the fused deposition modeling (FDM). The evaluations of anatomical structures and prespecified tasks on the simulators were completed by 5 residents and 5 experts of Rhinology.The models were evaluated by survey ratings based on a 5-point Likert scale. The average time to complete each task was calculated.Mann-Whitney nonparametric test was used to assess the differences between experts and residents groups. The statistical significance level was set at P<0.05. Results: All the components of the two models were prototyped in 24 h. For the nasal cavities model, the scores of each anatomical structure were more than 4.0. As to the paranasal sinuses model, except for the frontal sinus (3.6), the scores of each anatomical structure were more than 4.0. All the participants who performed the prespecified tasks evaluated the models well (>4.0). With the nasal cavity simulator, the experts completed the tasks (nasal cavity and nasopharyngeal endoscopy, removal of nasal foreign body, nasal packing, pledget insertion), and the other tasks (the nasal cavity and nasopharyngeal endoscopy, identification of ostiums of paranasal sinuses, maxillary sinus debridement with 70° nasal endoscopy) were completed with paranasal sinus model. The average time to complete each task by experts group and residents group (M (P(25), P(75))) were 10.3 (10.0, 10.7) s vs 17.1 (14.6, 20.7) s, 2.1 (2.0, 2.2) s vs 3.4 (2.6, 4.7) s, 30.1 (27.8, 32.8) s vs 59.2 (52.0, 65.4) s, 54.8 (50.1, 63.2) s vs 92.2 (79.3, 106.9) s, 9.3 (8.7, 9.9) s vs 14.5 (13.3, 14.9) s, 20.1 (19.3, 21.2) s vs 41.9 (35.5, 45.1) s, 31.1 (28.8, 35.2) s vs 52.8 (47.7, 56.3) s, respectively, and the average time to complete each task was shorter for the experts group than for the residents (U value was 0, 1.000, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, respectively, all P<0.05). Conclusion: The models of nasal cavities and paranasal sinuses made by our desktop-level FDM 3D-printer are useful for endoscopic training skills. 目的: 利用3D打印技术制作可供鼻内镜训练教学的鼻腔鼻窦仿真模型,并进行检验与评估。 方法: 于郑州大学第一附属医院鼻科选取1例鼻中隔偏曲患者的术前CT数据建立鼻腔模型;选取1例慢性鼻-鼻窦炎患者接受双侧全组鼻窦开放术及鼻中隔成形术后4个月随访时的CT数据建立鼻窦模型。应用自主研发的桌面级熔融沉积成型(fused deposition modeling,FDM)打印机分别制作鼻腔与鼻窦模型后,由专家组和住院医师组各5名医师对模型进行检验。专家组以5分李克特量表评价模型鼻内镜下解剖结构的仿真性和训练鼻内镜基本操作的实用性;专家组和住院医师组分别在模型上进行双侧鼻内镜基本操作,计时并进行比较。组间操作时间比较采用Mann-Whitney检验,将P<0.05设为差异有统计学意义。 结果: 模型所有组件均在24 h内打印完成。鼻腔模型各解剖结构的仿真程度平均评分均>4.0分,鼻窦模型仿真程度平均评分除额窦为3.6分外,其余诸解剖结构均>4.0分。两个模型的各项鼻内镜下基本操作实用性的平均评分均>4.0分。在鼻腔模型上完成鼻腔及鼻咽部探查、圆球形异物取出、填塞凡士林纱条、放置棉片表面麻醉;在鼻窦模型上完成鼻腔及鼻咽部探查、鼻窦开口辨认、70°鼻内镜下双侧上颌窦换药各项操作,专家组和住院医师组在上述操作中用时的中位数、25分位数和75分位数(M[P(25),P(75)])分别为:10.3[10.0,10.7]s比17.1[14.6,20.7]s、2.1[2.0,2.2]s比3.4[2.6,4.7]s、30.1[27.8,32.8]s比59.2[52.0,65.4]s、54.8[50.1,63.2]s比92.2[79.3,106.9]s、9.3[8.7,9.9]s比14.5[13.3,14.9]s、20.1[19.3,21.2]s比41.9[35.5,45.1]s、31.1[28.8,35.2]s比52.8[47.7,56.3]s,专家组在模型上完成基本操作的时间较住院医师组更短(U值分别为0、1.000、0、0、0、0、0,P值均<0.05)。 结论: 桌面级的FDM打印机制作的3D鼻腔和鼻窦模型检验结果满意,可用于鼻内镜基本操作的训练与教学。.
引用
- Dong D, Lyu L, Chen Z, et al. [Fabrication and verification of three-dimensional prototyped models of nasal cavities and paranasal sinuses]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2018. PMID: 30122001. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-0860.2018.08.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。