助听器带宽与听力损失配置对双模语音识别的影响
结果显示双模获益模式与听力损失程度和配置一致,支持为所有双模患者验配最宽有效可听带宽的助听器。
要点
- CI>HA组句子识别在所有双模条件下均优于单模CI,且全带宽最佳。
- HA>CI组单词识别在2kHz和全带宽下优于单模HA,但句子识别无显著改善。
- 听力曲线越陡峭、中频阈值≥82.5 dB的CI>HA患者,限制带宽不影响双模句子获益。
核心结论
- 双模获益模式与听力损失程度和配置一致,支持为所有双模患者验配最宽有效可听带宽的助听器。
研究设计与样本
- 测试条件包括单模CI、单模HA全带宽及双模全带宽、2kHz、1kHz、500Hz带宽。
主要发现
- CI>HA组AzBio句子评分在所有双模条件下均显著高于单模CI,全带宽最高。
- CI>HA组CNC单词评分在任何双模条件下均未显著优于单模CI。
- HA>CI组CNC单词评分在2kHz和全带宽双模下显著高于单模HA,但AzBio句子无显著改善。
- CI>HA组中听力曲线较平坦且中频听力较好者,仅全带宽双模AzBio显著优于单模CI。
- CI>HA组中听力曲线陡降且中频阈值≥82.5 dB者,所有双模条件下AzBio均显著更高。
关键数值与推荐
- CI>HA组中频阈值≥82.5 dB者所有双模条件AzBio均显著更高,全带宽与限制带宽无显著差异。
- HA>CI组轻度低频听力损失者CNC单词双模改善最大,且受带宽降低影响较小。
临床怎么用
- 为双模患者验配助听器时,应尽可能提供与有效可听度一致的最宽带宽。
- 对于低频听力较好的HA>CI患者,带宽降低对双模获益影响较小。
局限性
- 样本量较小(33例),分组后各组例数少。
- 未报告统计学检验的具体P值或置信区间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: (1) To determine the effect of hearing aid (HA) bandwidth on bimodal speech perception in a group of unilateral cochlear implant (CI) patients with diverse degrees and configurations of hearing loss in the nonimplanted ear, (2) to determine whether there are demographic and audiometric characteristics that would help to determine the appropriate HA bandwidth for a bimodal patient. DESIGN: Participants were 33 experienced bimodal device users with postlingual hearing loss. Twenty three of them had better speech perception with the CI than the HA (CI>HA group) and 10 had better speech perception with the HA than the CI (HA>CI group). Word recognition in sentences (AzBio sentences at +10 dB signal to noise ratio presented at 0° azimuth) and in isolation [CNC (consonant-nucleus-consonant) words] was measured in unimodal conditions [CI alone or HAWB, which indicates HA alone in the wideband (WB) condition] and in bimodal conditions (BMWB, BM2k, BM1k, and BM500) as the bandwidth of an actual HA was reduced from WB to 2 kHz, 1 kHz, and 500 Hz. Linear mixed-effect modeling was used to quantify the relationship between speech recognition and listening condition and to assess how audiometric or demographic covariates might influence this relationship in each group. RESULTS: For the CI>HA group, AzBio scores were significantly higher (on average) in all bimodal conditions than in the best unimodal condition (CI alone) and were highest at the BMWB condition. For CNC scores, on the other hand, there was no significant improvement over the CI-alone condition in any of the bimodal conditions. The opposite pattern was observed in the HA>CI group. CNC word scores were significantly higher in the BM2k and BMWB conditions than in the best unimodal condition (HAWB), but none of the bimodal conditions were significantly better than the best unimodal condition for AzBio sentences (and some of the restricted bandwidth conditions were actually worse). Demographic covariates did not interact significantly with bimodal outcomes, but some of the audiometric variables did. For CI>HA participants with a flatter audiometric configuration and better mid-frequency hearing, bimodal AzBio scores were significantly higher than the CI-alone score with the WB setting (BMWB) but not with other bandwidths. In contrast, CI>HA participants with more steeply sloping hearing loss and poorer mid-frequency thresholds (≥82.5 dB) had significantly higher bimodal AzBio scores in all bimodal conditions, and the BMWB did not differ significantly from the restricted bandwidth conditions. HA>CI participants with mild low-frequency hearing loss showed the highest levels of bimodal improvement over the best unimodal condition on CNC words. They were also less affected by HA bandwidth reduction compared with HA>CI participants with poorer low-frequency thresholds. CONCLUSIONS: The pattern of bimodal performance as a function of the HA bandwidth was found to be consistent with the degree and configuration of hearing loss for both patients with CI>HA performance and for those with HA>CI performance. Our results support fitting the HA for all bimodal patients with the widest bandwidth consistent with effective audibility.
引用
- Neuman AC, Zeman A, Neukam J, et al. The Effect of Hearing Aid Bandwidth and Configuration of Hearing Loss on Bimodal Speech Recognition in Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 30067559. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000638
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。