成人助听器使用者的音乐欣赏及不同听力损失程度的影响
结果显示轻中度组间音乐欣赏差异小,重度组评分更差;偏好与满意度个体差异大,提示听力损失程度是影响因素之一但非唯一。
要点
- 重度或更差听力损失者音乐欣赏评分显著低于轻度者,轻中度组间差异较小。
- 所有组内音乐聆听满意度变异大,部分满意部分不满意。
- 听力损失程度是影响音乐欣赏的因素之一,但非唯一因素。
核心结论
- 轻度与中度听力损失者音乐欣赏差异小,重度或更差者评分更差,提示听力损失程度影响音乐欣赏但非唯一因素。
研究设计与样本
- 改编既有问卷共51题分七部分,邮寄给成人助听器使用者,按听力损失程度分轻度、中度至中重度、重度或更差三组。
主要发现
- 重度组报告听力损失导致音乐享受更大程度下降,助听器使音乐旋律感显著降低。
- 重度组对六种音乐风格的平均愉悦评分及组合评分除流行/摇滚愉悦评分外均低于轻度和中度组。
- 三组在助听器下最佳音乐风格及特定音色评分上存在显著差异,但乐器愉悦度和自然度评分无组间差异。
- 轻度和重度组在音高范围偏好上存在显著差异,重度组显著偏好男歌手和低音高乐器。
临床怎么用
- 对重度或更差听力损失助听器使用者,需关注音乐欣赏困难并考虑个体化音乐程序。
- 音乐偏好和满意度个体差异大,通用厂商音乐程序效果可能有限。
局限性
- 研究为问卷调查研究,样本量有限且各组人数不均,重度组仅18人。
- 音乐评分变异大,结果可能受多种因素影响,听力损失程度非唯一因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The main aim of this study was to collect information on music listening and music appreciation from postlingually deafened adults who use hearing aids (HAs). It also sought to investigate whether there were any differences in music ratings from HA users with different levels of hearing loss (HL; mild, versus moderate to moderately-severe, versus severe or worse. DESIGN: An existing published questionnaire developed for cochlear implant recipients was modified for this study. It had 51 questions divided into seven sections: (1) music listening and music background; (2) sound quality; (3) musical styles; (4) music preferences; (5) music recognition; (6) factors affecting music listening enjoyment; and (7) music training program. The questionnaire was posted out to adult HA users, who were subsequently divided into three groups: (i) HA users with a mild HL (Mild group); (ii) HA users with a moderate to moderately-severe HL (Moderate group); and (iii) HA users with a severe or worse (Severe group) HL. RESULTS: One hundred eleven questionnaires were completed; of these, 51 participants had a mild HL, 42 had a moderate to moderately-severe loss, and 18 a severe or worse loss. Overall, there were some significant differences noted, predominantly between the Mild and Severe groups, with fewer differences between the Mild and Moderate groups. The respondents with the greater levels of HL reported a greater reduction in their music enjoyment as a result of their HL and that HAs made music sound significantly less melodic for them. It was also observed that the Severe group's mean scores for both the pleasant rating as well as the combined rating for the six different musical styles were lower than both the Mild and Moderate groups' ratings for every style, with just one exception (pop/rock pleasantness rating). There were significant differences between the three groups for the styles of music that were reported to sound the best with HA(s), as well as differences between the ratings on more specific timbre rating scales used to rate different elements of each style. In rating the pleasantness and naturalness of different musical instruments or instrumental groups, there was no difference between the groups. There were also significant differences between the Mild and Severe groups in relation to musical preferences for the pitch range of music, with the Severe group significantly preferring male singers and lower pitched instruments. CONCLUSIONS: The overall results indicated little difference in music appreciation between those with a mild versus moderate loss. However, poorer appreciation scores were given by those with a severe or worse HL. This would suggest that HAs or HL have a negative impact on music listening, particularly when the HL becomes more significant. There was a large degree of variability in ratings, though, with music listening being satisfactory for some listeners and largely unsatisfactory for others, in all three groups. Music listening preferences also varied significantly, and the reported benefit (or otherwise) provided by the HA for music was also mixed. The overriding variability in listening preferences and ratings leads to the question as to the benefit and effectiveness of generic, manufacturer-derived music programs on HAs. Despite the heterogeneity in the listening habits, preferences, and ratings, it is clear that music appreciation and enjoyment is still challenging for many HA users and that level of HL is one, but not the only factor that impacts on music appreciation.
引用
- Looi V, Rutledge K, Prvan T, et al. Music Appreciation of Adult Hearing Aid Users and the Impact of Different Levels of Hearing Loss. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 30096062. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000632
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。