需多皮瓣重建的头颈切除术结局:系统综述
该系统综述纳入24项研究共487例接受多皮瓣重建的头颈手术患者,中位随访生存2.36年,24.8%依赖喂养管,29.3%口腔控制差,17.6%言语不可懂,14.1%对美观不满意。作者认为应综合权衡疗效与姑息获益,术前强调现实期望。
要点
- 多皮瓣重建头颈术后功能与美观结局有限,需术前充分沟通期望。
- 随访时24.8%患者部分或完全依赖喂养管,29.3%存在中重度流涎。
- 平均住院24.5天,并发症常见,应综合评估获益与风险。
核心结论
- 因患者预期寿命有限、功能与美观结局中等且相关费用显著,术者应全面权衡根治潜力与姑息获益。
- 术前讨论应强调现实期望。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed、Embase和Cochrane数据库,仅限英文文献,发表时间不限。
- 纳入24项研究(1992年11月1日至2016年9月1日发表),共487例患者,其中男性370例(79.4%),加权平均年龄55.1岁(SD 4.1)。
- 采用MINORS标准评估偏倚,改良牛津循证医学中心推荐分级评估证据质量。
主要发现
- 108例患者中19例(17.6%)言语不可懂;64例患者中9例(14.1%)对美观结局不满意。
- 报告的平均生存期为2.36年(SD 1.39);219例患者平均住院日24.5天(SD 12.2)。
临床怎么用
- 对需多皮瓣重建的头颈缺损患者,术前应综合评估根治潜力、功能结局、费用与生存预期。
- 术前谈话需明确告知患者可能长期依赖喂养管、口腔控制差、言语障碍及美观不满意等风险。
局限性
- 仅纳入英文文献,可能存在语言偏倚。
- 纳入研究多为非随机设计,MINORS评分非比较研究平均仅11.4,证据质量有限。
- 部分结局指标报告例数不全(如喂养管依赖仅250例、口腔控制仅75例)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Complex head and neck cancer defects that require multiflap reconstructions are technically feasible, but the morbidity and patient outcomes of such large-scale head and neck operations have yet to be systematically reviewed. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review existing literature to characterize the outcomes of large-scale head and neck resections that require multiple-flap reconstructions (defined as defects that require >1 flap [free, pedicled, or combinations thereof]). EVIDENCE REVIEW: Two authors independently searched PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Review databases for English-only texts published on any date. Included studies examined patients who underwent complex head and neck surgical resections that required multiple simultaneous flaps for reconstruction. Included studies reported results on at least one of the following outcomes: functional and aesthetic, patient survival, or cost (estimated by operating room time, length of stay, and/or complications). Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS) criteria for bias and modified Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine recommendations were used to assess study quality. FINDINGS: Twenty-four studies published from November 1, 1992, through September 1, 2016, met the final inclusion criteria, with a total of 487 patients (370 male [79.4%]; mean [SD] weighted age, 55.1 [4.1] years). Sixty-two of 250 patients (24.8%) were partially or fully dependent on feeding tubes at follow-up. Twenty-two of 75 patients (29.3%) had poor postoperative oral competence, causing moderate to severe drooling. Nineteen of 108 patients (17.6%) had unintelligible speech. Nine of 64 patients (14.1%) were unsatisfied with their aesthetic outcome. The mean (SD) reported survival was 2.36 (1.39) years. The mean (SD) length of stay was 24.5 (12.2) days in 219 patients. Eighty-eight minor complications (eg, partial flap necrosis, donor site complications) and 185 major complications (eg, surgical reexplorations, flap loss, or cardiopulmonary complications) were reported in 380 patients. Mean (SD) MINORS scores were 16.0 (3.2) for comparison studies and 11.4 (1.8) for noncomparison studies. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Because of limited patient life expectancies, modest functional and aesthetic outcomes, and significant associated costs, surgeons should weigh the curative potential and palliative benefits for individual patients with a comprehensive view of the overall outcomes of extensive head and neck resections and reconstructions. Realistic expectations should be emphasized during preoperative discussions with patients.
引用
- Gao RW, Nuyen BA, Divi V, et al. Outcomes in Head and Neck Resections That Require Multiple-Flap Reconstructions: A Systematic Review. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2018. PMID: 29978196. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2018.0835
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。