鼻窦外科医生抗生素与全身激素处方差异:共识尚未形成
本研究评估了经常进行鼻窦手术的耳鼻咽喉科医生在抗生素和口服糖皮质激素(OCS)处方上的差异。通过分析2015年Medicare Part D处方数据发现,受过专科培训的鼻科医生抗生素处方率较低但疗程较长,而OCS使用率较高;非专科培训的鼻窦外科医生和球囊手术医生更倾向于使用抗生素。执业年限较长的医生更常处方抗生素。
要点
- 专科培训鼻科医生抗生素处方率15.1%,90.2%者处方数少于100张
- 专科培训鼻科医生抗生素疗程更长(14.1 vs 10.3天,p<0.05)
- 专科培训鼻科医生OCS使用率8.9%,高于其他组(7.1%),疗程更长(15.0 vs 8.1天)
核心结论
- 抗生素和OCS的使用因培训类型而异,非专科培训的鼻窦外科医生和球囊手术医生更积极地使用抗生素,而专科培训的鼻科医生更频繁地使用OCS。
- 执业年限较长的耳鼻咽喉科医生更可能在鼻窦疾病管理中纳入抗生素。
研究设计与样本
- 通过美国鼻科学会网站识别专科培训的鼻科医生(包括 fellowship 主任),并纳入每年进行至少25例球囊手术(额窦/上颌窦)或至少25例功能性内镜鼻窦手术(FESS)(额窦/上颌窦/筛窦)的非专科培训耳鼻咽喉科医生,分别归入“球囊手术医生”和“鼻窦外科医生”队列。
- 获取2015年Medicare Part D受益人的处方数据进行分析。
主要发现
- 纳入分析的耳鼻咽喉科医生抗生素处方中位数为54张,抗生素处方率为15.1%,每种抗生素的总体疗程长度为11.1天。
- 专科培训鼻科医生中90.2%抗生素处方数少于100张,而鼻窦外科医生和球囊手术医生分别为25.6%和32.5%。
- 专科培训鼻科医生抗生素疗程更长(14.1 vs 10.3天,p < 0.05)。
- 专科培训鼻科医生OCS使用率(8.9%)高于球囊手术医生和鼻窦外科医生(7.1%),且疗程更长(15.0 vs 8.1天)。
- 执业年限较长的医生处方抗生素显著更频繁;早期职业耳鼻咽喉科医生比执业11-20年和>20年者处方更长的激素疗程。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应意识到培训背景和执业年限可能影响抗生素和OCS的处方习惯,需关注指南以规范实践。
- 进一步明确指南可能有助于减少实践差异并维持共识。
局限性
- 结论需考虑该资源局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The objective of this work was to evaluate factors associated with antibiotic and oral corticosteroid (OCS) prescription among otolaryngologists regularly performing sinus surgery. METHODS: Fellowship-trained rhinologists, including fellowship directors, were identified via the American Rhinologic Society (ARS) website. Non-fellowship-trained otolaryngologists performing ≥25 balloons (frontal/maxillary) or ≥25 functional endoscopic sinus surgeries (FESSs) (frontal/maxillary/ethmoids) were also included in "balloon surgeons" and "sinus surgeon" cohorts, respectively. Prescribing data for Medicare Part D beneficiaries was obtained for 2015. RESULTS: Otolaryngologists included in this analysis wrote a median of 54 scripts for antibiotics, with a 15.1% antibiotic prescription rate. The overall script length per antibiotic was 11.1 days. Of fellowship-trained rhinologists, 90.2% wrote fewer than 100 scripts, compared to 25.6% and 32.5% of sinus surgeons and balloon surgeons, respectively. Fellowship-trained rhinologists wrote lengthier antibiotic scripts (14.1 vs 10.3 days, p < 0.05). Clinicians who have been in practice longer prescribed antibiotics significantly more frequently. Fellowship-trained rhinologists had a greater OCS rate (8.9%) than balloon and sinus surgeons (7.1%), also writing lengthier courses (15.0 vs 8.1 days). Early-career otolaryngologists wrote lengthier steroid prescriptions than those with 11 to 20 years and >20 years in practice. CONCLUSION: Antibiotic and OCS utilization varies by type of training, as non-fellowship-trained sinus surgeons and balloon surgeons tend to utilize antibiotics more aggressively, and fellowship-trained rhinologists utilize OCS more frequently. Otolaryngologists with more years in practice are more likely to incorporate antibiotics in the management of sinus disorders, although these conclusions must be considered in the context of this resource's limitations. Further clarification of guidelines may be helpful for minimizing divergent practices and maintaining a consensus.
引用
- Arianpour K, Svider PF, Guys N, et al. Incorporation of antibiotics and systemic steroids by sinus surgeons: is there widespread consensus? Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2018. PMID: 29979841. doi:10.1002/alr.22131
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。