基于共识的痉挛性发声障碍及其他嗓音障碍患者识别特征
该研究首先评估专家在无指南情况下对ADSD、ABSD、VT和MTD分类的一致性,发现一致性差(最高κ=0.26)。随后通过四阶段德尔菲法,由13名专家和46名社区专家制定了18项用于研究的分类特征,形成痉挛性发声障碍特征清单。
要点
- 无指南时专家分类一致性差,最高κ仅0.26。
- 德尔菲法制定18项特征用于研究分类。
- 特征清单有助于标准化患者选择。
核心结论
- 无指南时专家分类一致性差,需通过德尔菲法制定共识特征。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心观察性研究评估专家间一致性,样本为178例临床诊断患者。
- 四阶段德尔菲法研究,由13名专家和46名社区专家参与制定共识特征。
主要发现
- 无指南分类时,评级者分类分布不同(似然比χ2=107.66),一致性差。
- 11类分类中最高一致率为34%,无κ值大于0.26。
- 外部评级者对中最高κ为0.23,最高一致率为38.5%。
- 6类分类中最高一致率为73.3%,最高κ为0.40。
关键数值与推荐
- 德尔菲法产生18项用于分类的言语和鼻喉镜特征。
- 最终形成痉挛性发声障碍特征清单用于研究分类。
临床怎么用
- 临床研究中可采用18项共识特征对ADSD、ABSD、VT和MTD患者进行分类。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: A roadblock for research on adductor spasmodic dysphonia (ADSD), abductor SD (ABSD), voice tremor (VT), and muscular tension dysphonia (MTD) is the lack of criteria for selecting patients with these disorders. OBJECTIVE: To determine the agreement among experts not using standard guidelines to classify patients with ABSD, ADSD, VT, and MTD, and develop expert consensus attributes for classifying patients for research. DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: From 2011 to 2016, a multicenter observational study examined agreement among blinded experts when classifying patients with ADSD, ABSD, VT or MTD (first study). Subsequently, a 4-stage Delphi method study used reiterative stages of review by an expert panel and 46 community experts to develop consensus on attributes to be used for classifying patients with the 4 disorders (second study). The study used a convenience sample of 178 patients clinically diagnosed with ADSD, ABSD, VT MTD, vocal fold paresis/paralysis, psychogenic voice disorders, or hypophonia secondary to Parkinson disease. Participants were aged 18 years or older, without laryngeal structural disease or surgery for ADSD and underwent speech and nasolaryngoscopy video recordings following a standard protocol. EXPOSURES: Speech and nasolaryngoscopy video recordings following a standard protocol. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Specialists at 4 sites classified 178 patients into 11 categories. Four international experts independently classified 75 patients using the same categories without guidelines after viewing speech and nasolaryngoscopy video recordings. Each member from the 4 sites also classified 50 patients from other sites after viewing video clips of voice/laryngeal tasks. Interrater κ less than 0.40 indicated poor classification agreement among rater pairs and across recruiting sites. Consequently, a Delphi panel of 13 experts identified and ranked speech and laryngeal movement attributes for classifying ADSD, ABSD, VT, and MTD, which were reviewed by 46 community specialists. Based on the median attribute rankings, a final attribute list was created for each disorder. RESULTS: When classifying patients without guidelines, raters differed in their classification distributions (likelihood ratio, χ2 = 107.66), had poor interrater agreement, and poor agreement with site categories. For 11 categories, the highest agreement was 34%, with no κ values greater than 0.26. In external rater pairs, the highest κ was 0.23 and the highest agreement was 38.5%. Using 6 categories, the highest percent agreement was 73.3% and the highest κ was 0.40. The Delphi method yielded 18 attributes for classifying disorders from speech and nasolaryngoscopic examinations. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Specialists without guidelines had poor agreement when classifying patients for research, leading to a Delphi-based development of the Spasmodic Dysphonia Attributes Inventory for classifying patients with ADSD, ABSD, VT, and MTD for research.
引用
- Ludlow CL, Domangue R, Sharma D, et al. Consensus-Based Attributes for Identifying Patients With Spasmodic Dysphonia and Other Voice Disorders. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2018. PMID: 29931028. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2018.0644
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。