鼻用减充血剂致豚鼠鼻黏膜损伤及修复的实验研究
该研究将65只雄性豚鼠随机分组,分别使用0.1%盐酸萘甲唑啉、1%呋麻滴鼻液或色甘萘甲那敏鼻喷雾剂2周,观察鼻黏膜损伤;停药后部分豚鼠分别用糠酸莫米松鼻喷雾剂或2.3%盐水治疗2周。结果显示短期大剂量减充血剂可致鼻黏膜损伤,用药时间越长损伤越重,糖皮质激素和2.3%盐水有助于修复。
要点
- 短期大剂量鼻用减充血剂可致豚鼠鼻黏膜充血、水肿及纤毛损伤。
- 用药时间越长,鼻黏膜损伤越重。
- 糠酸莫米松鼻喷雾剂和2.3%盐水冲洗可促进损伤修复。
核心结论
- 短期、大剂量鼻用减充血剂可致豚鼠鼻黏膜损伤,用药时间越长损伤越重。
- 鼻喷糖皮质激素和2.3%盐水有助于鼻黏膜损伤的修复。
研究设计与样本
- 65只雄性豚鼠随机分为4组:A组20只用0.1%盐酸萘甲唑啉喷鼻,每次2喷,每日6次,2周。
- B组20只用1%呋麻滴鼻液滴鼻,每次2滴,每日6次,2周;C组20只用色甘萘甲那敏鼻喷雾剂喷鼻,每次2喷,每日8次,2周;D组5只空白对照。
- 停药2周后从A、B、C组剩余豚鼠中随机组成甲组9只、乙组9只和丙组6只;甲组用糠酸莫米松鼻喷雾剂喷鼻,每次2喷,每日1次,2周;乙组用2.3%盐水冲洗鼻腔,每次1 ml,每日1次,2周;丙组无治疗。
主要发现
- 使用减充血剂2周后与使用前及使用1周后相比,A、B、C三组鼻内镜下鼻黏膜充血、水肿及显微镜下组织水肿、充血、纤毛损伤差异均有统计学意义(P值均<0.05)。
- 糖皮质激素及2.3%盐水治疗2周后,甲乙组鼻内镜下鼻黏膜颜色、鼻甲形态及显微镜下鼻黏膜组织水肿、充血、纤毛损伤较治疗前均有恢复,差异均有统计学意义(P值均<0.05)。
- 丙组无任何治疗措施,未观察到恢复。
关键数值与推荐
- A组:0.1%盐酸萘甲唑啉喷鼻液,每次2喷,每日6次,喷鼻2周。
- B组:1%呋麻滴鼻液,每次2滴,每日6次,滴鼻2周。
- C组:色甘萘甲那敏鼻喷雾剂,每次2喷,每日8次,喷鼻2周。
- 甲组:糠酸莫米松鼻喷雾剂,每次2喷,每日1次,治疗2周。
- 乙组:2.3%盐水冲洗双侧鼻腔,每次1 ml,每日1次,治疗2周。
临床怎么用
- 临床应避免短期大剂量使用鼻用减充血剂,以减少鼻黏膜损伤风险。
- 对减充血剂所致鼻黏膜损伤,可考虑使用鼻喷糖皮质激素或2.3%盐水冲洗促进修复。
局限性
- 本研究为豚鼠动物实验,结论外推至人类需谨慎。
- 样本量有限,各组动物数量不等,统计效能可能受限。
- 观察时间较短,长期修复效果未评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To observe the process of nasal mucosa injury and repair induced by nasal decongestants in guinea pigs Methods: Sixty-five male guinea pigs were randomly divided into 4groups by digital random method.The guinea pigs in Group A (20 guinea pigs)were treated with 2 sprays of 0.1% Naphazoline 6 times a day for 2 weeks; Group B (20 guinea pigs)with 2 drops of 1% Ephedrine 6 times a day for 2 weeks; Group C(20 guinea pigs) with 2 sprays of Naphazolin hydrochloride and Chlorphenamine Maleate Nasal Spray 8 times a day for 2 weeks.Group D (5guinea pigs)did not do any intervention as a control group.At the end of first and second weekend, 6 guinea pigs randomly selected from each group were observed the morphological changes of the nasal cavity with nasal endoscope and pathological microscope.Two weeks after stopping use of decongestant, 24 animals were grouped.Three guinea pigs were selected randomly from each group to form Group E (n=9) and Group F (n=9)respectively. The 6 remaining guinea pigs falled into Group G. Group E received 2 sprays of Mometasone Furoate Nasal Spray once a day for 2 weeks; Group F received 1 ml 2.3% saline to wash the nasal cavities once a day for 2 weeks.Group F was used to show the natural progess without any treatment.At the end of the third and fourth weekend, nasal endoscopic and pathological microscopes were used to observe the nasal cavity structure and the pathological changes of nasal mucosa. Results: Nasal mocusa congestion and edema were observed with nasal endoscopy after 2 weeks of using nasal decongestant. Cell edema, blood vessel expansion, acute and chronic inflammatory cell infiltration, cilium lodging or loss were observed under the pathological microscope in GroupA, B, C. After using MometasoneFuroate Nasal Spray and 2.3% saline for 2 weeks, the above changes were all recovered in Group E and F. No recovery was found in Group G. Conclusions: Short-term and over dose of nasal decongestant can result in the injury of nasal mucosa in guinea pigs, and the injury is much severe as using decongestant last longer.MometasoneFuroate nasal spray and 2.3% saline can repair the injury. 目的: 观察减充血剂对豚鼠鼻黏膜的损伤作用,并探讨糖皮质激素及盐水冲洗对鼻黏膜损伤的修复作用。 方法: 采用数字随机法(以下同)将65只雄性豚鼠随机分为4组;A组(20只)用0.1%盐酸萘甲唑啉喷鼻液双侧鼻孔喷鼻,每次2喷,每日6次,喷鼻2周;B组(20只)用1%呋麻滴鼻液双侧鼻孔滴鼻,每次2滴,每日6次,滴鼻2周;C组(20只)用色甘萘甲那敏鼻喷雾剂双侧喷鼻,每次2喷,每日8次,喷鼻2周。D组(5只):未做任何干预处理,作为空白对照组。在使用鼻减充血剂第1周末和第2周末,从A、B、C组分别随机抽取6只豚鼠,从D组抽取1只豚鼠,用鼻内镜观察鼻腔形态学改变;随后处死并取鼻黏膜,HE染色并在显微镜下观察组织细胞学改变。2周后停用鼻减充血剂,从A、B、C三组剩余的豚鼠中每组随机抽取3只,组成甲组( 9只),再次从三组豚鼠中每组随机抽取3只,组成乙组( 9只),最后剩余的6只豚鼠组成丙组。甲组用糠酸莫米松双侧喷鼻治疗,每次2喷,每日1次;乙组用2.3%盐水冲洗双侧鼻腔治疗,每次1 ml,每日1次;丙组无任何治疗措施。治疗后第1、2周末,比较甲乙丙各组内镜下所见的鼻黏膜颜色、鼻甲形态差异以及显微镜下鼻黏膜组织水肿、充血、纤毛损伤的差异(采用等级计分方式进行半定量评估)。采用SPSS 19.0软件进行统计学分析,Fisher确切概率法进行检验。 结果: 使用减充血剂2周后与使用前及使用1周后相比,A、B、C三组豚鼠鼻内镜下鼻黏膜充血、水肿,显微镜下组织水肿、充血、纤毛损伤差异均有统计学意义(P值均<0.05)。糖皮质激素及2.3%盐水治疗2周后,甲乙组豚鼠鼻内镜下鼻黏膜颜色、鼻甲形态以及显微镜下鼻黏膜组织水肿、充血、纤毛损伤较治疗前均有恢复,差异均有统计学意义(P值均<0.05)。 结论: 短期、大剂量鼻用减充血剂可致豚鼠鼻黏膜损伤,用药时间越长损伤越重,鼻喷糖皮质激素和2.3%盐水有助于损伤的修复。.
引用
- Wang YN, Wang HT. [Experimental study on nasal mucosa injury and repair induced by nasal decongestants in guinea pigs]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2018. PMID: 29902847. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-0860.2018.06.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。