学龄儿童聆听努力的行为学测量:信噪比、听力损失与助听放大的影响
本研究纳入82名6-13岁儿童(37名听力正常,45名听力损失),采用双任务范式比较双任务视觉反应时与言语反应时两种聆听努力行为学指标。结果显示言语反应时在困难信噪比条件下更慢,听力损失儿童显著慢于听力正常儿童,而双任务视觉反应时无信噪比效应、组间差异及放大效应。
要点
- 言语反应时较双任务视觉反应时对信噪比与听力损失更敏感。
- 听力损失儿童即使言语被准确识别,加工速度仍较听力正常儿童下降。
- 个人放大对两种聆听努力行为学指标均未显示效应。
核心结论
- 言语反应时比双任务视觉反应时更能反映信噪比与听力损失对学龄儿童聆听努力的负面影响。
- 学龄听力损失儿童在言语被准确识别时仍表现出更大的加工速度下降,可能影响课堂学习与学业表现。
研究设计与样本
- 共82名6-13岁儿童参与,其中37名听力正常(CNH)、45名听力损失(CHL)。
- 采用双任务范式,主任务为多说话人babble下词识别,设Easy、Moderate、Hard三种个体化信噪比条件,次任务为视觉监测任务。
- CHL完成助听和/或未助听条件下测试以考察放大效应。
主要发现
- 言语反应时在更具挑战的信噪比条件下普遍更慢,但信噪比未影响双任务视觉反应时。
- CHL的言语反应时整体显著慢于CNH,而双任务视觉反应时在两组间无差异。
- 放大对双任务视觉反应时和言语反应时均未显示效应。
临床怎么用
- 对学龄听力损失儿童评估时,言语反应时或可作为比双任务视觉反应时更敏感的聆听努力行为学指标。
- 即使词识别正确,也需关注听力损失儿童课堂中的加工速度下降与学习负担。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Increased listening effort in school-age children with hearing loss (CHL) could compromise learning and academic achievement. Identifying a sensitive behavioral measure of listening effort for this group could have both clinical and research value. This study examined the effects of signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), hearing loss, and personal amplification on 2 commonly used behavioral measures of listening effort: dual-task visual response times (visual RTs) and verbal response times (verbal RTs). DESIGN: A total of 82 children (aged 6-13 years) took part in this study; 37 children with normal hearing (CNH) and 45 CHL. All children performed a dual-task paradigm from which both measures of listening effort (dual-task visual RT and verbal RT) were derived. The primary task was word recognition in multi-talker babble in three individually selected SNR conditions: Easy, Moderate, and Hard. The secondary task was a visual monitoring task. Listening effort during the dual-task was quantified as the change in secondary task RT from baseline (single-task visual RT) to the dual-task condition. Listening effort based on verbal RT was quantified as the time elapsed from the onset of the auditory stimulus to the onset of the verbal response when performing the primary (word recognition) task in isolation. CHL completed the task aided and/or unaided to examine the effect of amplification on listening effort. RESULTS: Verbal RTs were generally slower in the more challenging SNR conditions. However, there was no effect of SNR on dual-task visual RT. Overall, verbal RTs were significantly slower in CHL versus CNH. No group difference in dual-task visual RTs was found between CNH and CHL. No effect of amplification was found on either dual-task visual RTs or verbal RTs. CONCLUSIONS: This study compared dual-task visual RT and verbal RT measures of listening effort in the child population. Overall, verbal RTs appear more sensitive than dual-task visual RTs to the negative effects of SNR and hearing loss. The current findings extend the literature on listening effort in the pediatric population by demonstrating that, even for speech that is accurately recognized, school-age CHL show a greater processing speed decrement than their normal-hearing counterparts, a decrement that could have a negative impact on learning and academic achievement in the classroom.
引用
- McGarrigle R, Gustafson SJ, Hornsby BWY, et al. Behavioral Measures of Listening Effort in School-Age Children: Examining the Effects of Signal-to-Noise Ratio, Hearing Loss, and Amplification. Ear Hear. 2019. PMID: 29905670. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000623
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。