下一代听觉稳态反应与听性脑干反应测听在正常听力及听力损失儿童中的速度与准确性评估
本研究为多中心临床研究,纳入102名转诊进行电生理测听的婴幼儿,比较采用窄带CE-Chirp刺激的下一代ASSR检测与ABR(FMP分析)在500–4000 Hz的阈值预测及测试时间。结果显示ASSR校正阈值显著低于ABR(500 Hz差异14.39 dB),且ASSR平均测试时间19.93分钟显著短于ABR的32.15分钟(p<0.001)。
要点
- ASSR阈值显著低于ABR,低频差异更大(500 Hz达14.39 dB)。
- ASSR预测双耳4频率阈值的平均时间显著短于ABR。
- 两种技术测试时间均达到临床优秀标准。
核心结论
- 采用下一代检测算法的ASSR阈值较ABR低最多14 dB,逆转了既往研究中的差异方向。
- ASSR预测听力图所需时间显著短于ABR,但两种方法测试时间均属临床优秀水平。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心临床研究,在三个大学附属儿童医院听力科实施。
- 纳入102名转诊进行电生理测听的婴幼儿,测试电池包括宽频鼓室图、畸变产物耳声发射及双耳4频率ABR与ASSR(随机顺序)。
主要发现
- ASSR校正阈值显著低于ABR,ABR-ASSR差异在500 Hz为14.39 dB、1000 Hz为10.12 dB、2000 Hz为3.73 dB、4000 Hz为3.67 dB。
- ASSR平均测试时间19.93分钟(8个阈值)显著低于ABR的32.15分钟(p<0.001)。
- 半数受试者听力正常,其ASSR阈值(dB nHL)为迄今描述的最低值之一(除一项使用相同技术的研究外)。
临床怎么用
- 在婴幼儿电生理测听中,可优先考虑采用下一代检测算法的ASSR以缩短测试时间并获取更低阈值。
- 解读ASSR与ABR阈值时需注意两者间存在频率依赖性差异,低频差异尤为明显。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The first objective of this study was to compare the predicted audiometric thresholds obtained by auditory steady state response (ASSR) and auditory brainstem response (ABR) in infants and toddlers when both techniques use optimal stimuli and detection algorithms. This information will aid in determining the basis for large discrepancies in ABR and ASSR measures found in past studies. The hypothesis was that advancements in ASSR response detection would improve (lower) thresholds and decrease discrepancies between the thresholds produced by the two techniques. The second objective was to determine and compare test times required by the two techniques to predict thresholds for both ears at the 4 basic audiometric frequencies of 500, 1000, 2000, and 4000 Hz. DESIGN: A multicenter clinical study was implemented at three university-based children's hospital audiology departments. Participants were 102 infants and toddlers referred to the centers for electrophysiologic testing for audiometric purposes. The test battery included wideband tympanometry, distortion-product otoacoustic emissions, and threshold measurements at four frequencies in both ears using ABR and ASSR (randomized) as implemented on the Interacoustics Eclipse systems with "Next-Generation" ASSR detection and FMP analysis for ABR. Both methods utilized narrow band CE-Chirp stimuli. Testers were trained on a specialized test battery designed to minimize test time for both techniques. Testing with both techniques was performed in one session. Thresholds were evaluated and confirmed by the first author and correction factors were applied. Test times were documented in system software. RESULTS: Corrected thresholds for ABR and ASSR were compared by regression, by the Bland-Altman technique and by matched pairs t tests. Thresholds were significantly lower for ASSR than ABR. The ABR-ASSR discrepancy at 500 Hz was 14.39 dB, at 1000 Hz was 10.12 dB, at 2000 Hz was 3.73 dB, and at 4000 Hz was 3.67 dB. The average test time for ASSR of 19.93 min (for 8 thresholds) was found to be significantly lower (p < 0.001) than the ABR test time of 32.15 min. One half of the subjects were found to have normal hearing. ASSR thresholds plotted in dB nHL for normal-hearing children in this study were found to be the lowest yet described except for one study which used the same technology. CONCLUSIONS: This study found a reversal of previous findings with up to 14 dB lower thresholds found when using the ASSR technique with "Next-Generation" detection as compared with ABR using an automated detection (FMP). The test time for an audiogram prediction was significantly lower when using ASSR than ABR but was excellent by clinical standards for both techniques. ASSRs improved threshold performance was attributed to advancements in response detection including utilization of information at multiple harmonics of the modulation frequency. The stimulation paradigm which utilized narrow band CE-Chirps also contributed to the low absolute levels of the thresholds in nHL found with both techniques.
引用
- Sininger YS, Hunter LL, Hayes D, et al. Evaluation of Speed and Accuracy of Next-Generation Auditory Steady State Response and Auditory Brainstem Response Audiometry in Children With Normal Hearing and Hearing Loss. Ear Hear. 2018. PMID: 29624540. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000580
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。