新型表面传声器骨导验证工具的开发:经皮骨导使用者的验证
在55、65、75 dB SPL三种输入水平下,90项计划比较中仅5项差异显著,平均差异为3.3 dB,多数比较结果等效,提示表面传声器可用于经皮骨导验证。
要点
- 表面传声器与颅骨模拟器在多数比较中可听度估算等效
- 仅5项比较差异显著,平均差异小(3.3 dB)
- 该工具为无经皮植入的骨导装置验证提供可能
核心结论
- 表面传声器对经皮骨导使用者可在多种输入水平下获得与颅骨模拟器等效的可听度测量。
研究设计与样本
- 两种传感器(颅骨模拟器与表面传声器)测量同一助听器相同设置。
- 表面传声器移除后复测以评估重测信度。
主要发现
- 采用2(传感器)×3(输入水平)×10(频率)混合方差分析,存在显著三阶交互作用。
- 90项计划比较中5项在颅骨模拟器与表面传声器(测试与复测)间可听度估算差异显著。
- 上述显著效应的平均差异较小,为3.3 dB。
- 多数比较中两种传感器结果等效。
关键数值与推荐
- 输入水平为55、65、75 dB SPL粉红噪声。
- 多重比较采用Holm-Bonferroni法校正alpha。
- 可听度以各听力频率的阈值与测试助听器输出之差计算。
临床怎么用
- 对有完整皮肤的骨导装置模型,颅骨模拟器无法测量,表面传声器可作为验证替代工具。
- 该工具潜在适用于Sentio、BoneBridge、Attract及软头带装置等无经皮植入的骨导装置。
局限性
- 仅在55、65、75 dB SPL三种输入水平下验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To determine if a newly-designed, forehead-mounted surface microphone would yield equivalent estimates of audibility when compared to audibility measured with a skull simulator for adult bone conduction users. DESIGN: Data was analyzed using a within subjects, repeated measures design. There were two different sensors (skull simulator and surface microphone) measuring the same hearing aid programmed to the same settings for all subjects. We were looking for equivalent results. PATIENTS: Twenty-one adult percutaneous bone conduction users (12 females and 9 males) were recruited for this study. Mean age was 54.32 years with a standard deviation of 14.51 years. Nineteen of the subjects had conductive/mixed hearing loss and two had single-sided deafness. METHODS: To define audibility, we needed to establish two things: (1) in situ-level thresholds at each audiometric frequency in force (skull simulator) and in sound pressure level (SPL; surface microphone). Next, we measured the responses of the preprogrammed test device in force on the skull simulator and in SPL on the surface mic in response to pink noise at three input levels: 55, 65, and 75 dB SPL. The skull simulator responses were converted to real head force responses by means of an individual real head to coupler difference transform. Subtracting the real head force level thresholds from the real head force output of the test aid yielded the audibility for each audiometric frequency for the skull simulator. Subtracting the SPL thresholds from the surface microphone from the SPL output of the test aid yielded the audibility for each audiometric frequency for the surface microphone. The surface microphone was removed and retested to establish the test-retest reliability of the tool. RESULTS: We ran a 2 (sensor) × 3 (input level) × 10 (frequency) mixed analysis of variance to determine if there were any significant main effects and interactions. There was a significant three-way interaction, so we proceeded to explore our planned comparisons. There were 90 planned comparisons of interest, three at each frequency (3 × 10) for the three input levels (30 × 3). Therefore, to minimize a type 1 error associated with multiple comparisons, we adjusted alpha using the Holm-Bonferroni method. There were five comparisons that yielded significant differences between the skull simulator and surface microphone (test and retest) in the estimation of audibility. However, the mean difference in these effects was small at 3.3 dB. Both sensors yielded equivalent results for the majority of comparisons. CONCLUSIONS: Models of bone conduction devices that have intact skin cannot be measured with the skull simulator. This study is the first to present and evaluate a new tool for bone conduction verification. The surface microphone is capable of yielding equivalent audibility measurements as the skull simulator for percutaneous bone conduction users at multiple input levels. This device holds potential for measuring other bone conduction devices (Sentio, BoneBridge, Attract, Soft headband devices) that do not have a percutaneous implant.
引用
- Hodgetts W, Scott D, Maas P, et al. Development of a Novel Bone Conduction Verification Tool Using a Surface Microphone: Validation With Percutaneous Bone Conduction Users. Ear Hear. 2018. PMID: 29578886. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000572
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。