文献速递小儿耳鼻咽喉耳科与耳神经

基于数字三联测验的学龄儿童噪声下言语感知听力筛查

School-Age Hearing Screening Based on Speech-in-Noise Perception Using the Digit Triplet Test.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2018-01-01

DTT测得的言语接收阈值(SRT)可靠,且无需对训练或年龄进行校正;年级特异性通过/失败标准更合适,优化后转诊率降至1.3%和2.4%。DTT已作为佛兰德斯学龄儿童听力筛查项目的新筛查方法。

要点

  • DTT可用于9至16岁儿童的听力筛查,SRT测量可靠,无需训练或年龄校正。
  • 年级特异性通过/失败标准更合适,优化标准为-6.5 dB SNR(五年级)和-8.1 dB SNR(三年级)。
  • 转诊儿童中仅部分检出外周性听力损失,筛查未通过需进一步验证而非仅靠纯音测听。

核心结论

  • DTT已被实施为佛兰德斯学龄儿童听力筛查项目的新筛查方法,并据此确定和优化了用于五年级和三年级中学生系统听力筛查的通过/失败标准。
  • 本研究为9至16岁儿童的DTT提供了参考值,该测试可获得可靠的SRT,有助于随时间准确监测听力。

研究设计与样本

  • 共纳入3412名五年级(9至12岁)和3617名三年级中学生(13至16岁)参与。
  • 初始通过/失败标准为SRT≤-7.2 dB SNR(五年级)和≤-8.3 dB SNR(三年级)者通过,否则转诊进行听力图和随访。

主要发现

  • 群体SRT(±2 SD)为-9.8(±1.8)dB SNR(五年级)和-10.5(±1.6)dB SNR(三年级),无需对训练和/或年龄进行校正。
  • 线性回归分析显示SRT至青春期后期每年改善0.2 dB。
  • SRT的测量内信度为0.6 dB;测试时长平均为6分50秒(SD=61秒)(五年级)和5分45秒(SD=49秒)(三年级),双耳。
  • 初始切点值下,五年级2.9%、三年级3.5%的儿童被转诊;基于39名(五年级)和59名(三年级)转诊儿童的听力图,分别有31%和53%检出外周性听力损失,均为轻度。
  • 更宽松的通过/失败标准提高了诊断准确性,最佳标准为-6.5 dB SNR(五年级)和-8.1 dB SNR(三年级),转诊率降至1.3%(五年级)和2.4%(三年级)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 初始通过/失败标准:SRT≤-7.2 dB SNR(五年级)和≤-8.3 dB SNR(三年级)为通过,否则转诊。
  • 优化后最佳通过/失败标准:-6.5 dB SNR(五年级)和-8.1 dB SNR(三年级)。

临床怎么用

  • DTT可作为学龄儿童听力筛查工具,使用年级特异性通过/失败标准。
  • 筛查未通过儿童应进行进一步听力学评估,但需注意外周性听力损失不一定总能检出。
  • DTT测得的SRT可靠,可用于监测儿童听力随时间的变化,有助于识别噪声性听力损失。

局限性

  • 转诊儿童中仅部分完成听力图检查(五年级39名,三年级59名),诊断准确性评估基于此子样本。
  • 检出的听力损失均为轻度,可能影响对更显著听力损失的推断。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: This study aims to investigate the large-scale applicability of the Digit Triplet test (DTT) for school-age hearing screening in fifth grade elementary (5E) (9 to 12 years old) and third grade secondary (3S) (13 to 16 years old) school children. The reliability of the test is investigated as well as whether pass/fail criteria need to be corrected for training and/or age, and whether these criteria have to be refined with respect to referral rates and pure-tone audiometry results. DESIGN: Eleven school health service centers participated in the region of Flanders (the Northern part of Belgium). Pure-tone screening tests, which are commonly used for hearing screening in school children, were replaced by the DTT. Initial pass/fail criteria were determined. Children with speech reception thresholds (SRT) of -7.2 dB signal to noise ratio (SNR) (5E) and -8.3 dB SNR (3S) or worse were referred for an audiogram and follow-up. In total, n = 3412 (5E) and n = 3617 (3S) children participated. RESULTS: Population SRTs (±2 SD) were -9.8 (±1.8) dB SNR (5E) and -10.5 (±1.6) dB SNR (3S), and do not need correction for training and/or age. Whereas grade-specific pass/fail criteria are more appropriate, a linear regression analysis showed an improvement of 0.2 dB per year of the SRT until late adolescence. SRTs could be estimated with a within-measurement reliability of 0.6 dB. Test duration was also grade-dependent, and was 6 min 50 sec (SD = 61 sec) (5E) and 5 min 45 sec (SD = 49 sec) (3S) on average for both ears. The SRT, test reliability, and test duration were comparable across centers. With initial cut-off values, 2.9% (5E) and 3.5% (3S) of children were referred. Based on audiograms of n = 39 (5E) and n = 59 (3S) children, the diagnostic accuracy of the DTT was assessed. A peripheral hearing loss was detected in 31% (5E) and 53% (3S) of the referred children. Hearing losses found were mild. Less strict pass/fail criteria increased the diagnostic accuracy. Optimal pass/fail criteria were determined at -6.5 dB SNR (5E) and -8.1 dB SNR (3S). With these criteria, referral rates dropped to 1.3% (5E) and 2.4% (3S). CONCLUSIONS: The DTT has been implemented as the new hearing screening methodology in the Flemish school-age hearing screening program. Based on the results of this study, pass/fail criteria were determined and optimized to be used for systematic hearing screening of 5E and 3S school children. Furthermore, this study provides reference values for the DTT in children 9 to 16 years of age. Reliable SRTs can be obtained with the test, allowing accurate monitoring of hearing over time. This is important in the context of a screening guideline, which aims to identify children with noise-induced hearing loss. Validation of the screening result should go beyond taking an audiogram, as a peripheral hearing impairment cannot always be found in children with a failed test.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Denys S, Hofmann M, Luts H, et al. School-Age Hearing Screening Based on Speech-in-Noise Perception Using the Digit Triplet Test. Ear Hear. 2018. PMID: 29557793. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000563

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。